European Union Bill — Clause 18 — Status of EU law dependent on continuing statutory basis — 11 Jan 2011 at 22:00
Nick Herbert MP, Arundel and South Downs voted with the majority (No).
The majority of MPs voted against inserting the amendment tabled by William Cash, which would have inserted the following into Clause 18 of the European Union Bill:
- 'The sovereignty of the United Kingdom Parliament in relation to EU law is hereby reaffirmed'
He also tabled a second amendment, which would have added the words
- 'and not by virtue of a common law principle'
to the end of the Clause. This second amendment was also defeated in the same vote.
Mr Cash was concerned that there was an increasing sense in academic and legal circles that Parliament derived its power from common law (law made by judges, and that follows precedent), rather than being itself Sovereign.
Speaking against the amendments, David Lidingstone, Minister for Europe, said:
- 'The Government think that this amendment is not necessary. It is not necessary to take up additional parliamentary time through the process that the Opposition propose. In the event that there were to be a serious challenge to the authority and sovereignty of Parliament, I would expect that hon. Members, on both sides, would want an immediate statement from the Minister and an urgent debate, instead of waiting 12 months for an annual report, which is the only remedy that the hon. Gentleman proposes.'
A second division took place over the preparing of the annual report that David Lidingstone mentions: more information is available on its division page.
Votes by party, red entries are votes against the majority for that party.
What is Tell? '+1 tell' means that in addition one member of that party was a teller for that division lobby.
What are Boths? An MP can vote both aye and no in the same division. The boths page explains this.
What is Turnout? This is measured against the total membership of the party at the time of the vote.
|Party||Majority (No)||Minority (Aye)||Both||Turnout|
|Con||256 (+1 tell)||25 (+2 tell)||0||92.8%|
|LDem||51 (+1 tell)||0||0||91.2%|
|Brian Binley||Northampton South||Con||aye|
|Andrew Bridgen||North West Leicestershire||Con||aye|
|David Davis||Haltemprice and Howden||Con||aye|
|Richard Drax||South Dorset||Con||aye|
|Zac Goldsmith||Richmond Park||Con||aye|
|Gordon Henderson||Sittingbourne and Sheppey||Con||aye|
|Bernard Jenkin||Harwich and North Essex||Con||tellaye|
|Chris Kelly||Dudley South||Con||aye|
|Julian Lewis||New Forest East||Con||aye|
|Jason McCartney||Colne Valley||Con||aye|
|David Nuttall||Bury North||Con||aye|
|Mark Reckless||Rochester and Strood||Con||aye|
|Sir John Stanley||Tonbridge and Malling||Con||aye|
|Peter Tapsell||Louth and Horncastle||Con||aye|
|Andrew Turner||Isle of Wight||Con||aye|