Voting Comparison — Clare Short MP, Birmingham, Ladywood
to Mr Alastair Goodlad MP, Eddisbury
Clare Short
Note: our records only go back to 1997 for the Commons and 2001 for the Lords (more details).
| From | To | Party | Rebellions (explain...) | Attendance (explain...) | Teller |
| 21 Oct 2006 | 12 Apr 2010 | Independent Labour | no whip | 117 votes out of 970, 12.1% | 0 times |
| 5 May 2005 | 20 Oct 2006 | Lab | 33 votes out of 179, 18.4% | 179 votes out of 318, 56.3% | 0 times |
| 7 Jun 2001 | 11 Apr 2005 | Lab | 43 votes out of 420, 10.2% | 420 votes out of 1246, 33.7% | 0 times |
| 1 May 1997 | 14 May 2001 | Lab | 0 votes out of 413, 0.0% | 413 votes out of 1273, 32.4% | 0 times |
Voting Differences
| House | Date | Subject | Clare Short | Mr Alastair Goodlad | Rôle | |
| no votes listed | ||||||
| House | Date | Subject | Clare Short | Mr Alastair Goodlad | Rôle | |
| no votes listed | ||||||
| House | Date | Subject | Clare Short | Mr Alastair Goodlad | Rôle | |
| no votes listed | ||||||
| House | Date | Subject | Clare Short | Mr Alastair Goodlad | Rôle | |
| Commons | 20 May 1999 | Welfare Reform and Pensions Bill - Incapacity benefit: restriction to recent contributors | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 17 May 1999 | Welfare Reform and Pensions Bill - Excessive pension contributions made by persons who have become insolvent | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 17 May 1999 | Welfare Reform and Pensions Bill - Optional work-focused interviews | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 31 Mar 1999 | Employment Relations Bill - '9. Compensatory award: removal of limit in certain cases | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 15 Mar 1999 | Finance [Money] | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 15 Mar 1999 | Budget Resolutions and Economic Situation - 49. Insurance premium tax (standard rate) | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 15 Mar 1999 | Budget Resolutions and Economic Situation - 45. Ring fence profits | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 15 Mar 1999 | Budget Resolutions and Economic Situation - 37. Extra-statutory arrangements for insurance groups | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 15 Mar 1999 | Budget Resolutions and Economic Situation - 25. Cars available for private use | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 15 Mar 1999 | Budget Resolutions and Economic Situation - 21. Rates of capital gains tax | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 15 Mar 1999 | Budget Resolutions and Economic Situation - 5. Tobacco products duty (rates) | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 15 Mar 1999 | Budget Resolutions and Economic Situation - 3. Hydrocarbon oil duties (rates and rebates) | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 15 Mar 1999 | Budget Resolutions and Economic Situation — 2. Sparkling cider (rate of duty) | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 22 Feb 1999 | Immigration and Asylum Bill | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 15 Feb 1999 | House of Lords Bill — Exclusion of hereditary peers from voting — rejected | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 2 Feb 1999 | House of Lords Bill — Second Reading | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 2 Feb 1999 | House of Lords Bill — Decline to give a Second Reading — rejected | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 18 Jan 1999 | NHS (Rationing) | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 2 Dec 1998 | European Parliamentary Elections Bill | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 30 Nov 1998 | Constitution and Parliament | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 10 Nov 1998 | Factory Closures | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 4 Nov 1998 | The Economy | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 30 Apr 1998 | Economic and Monetary Union | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 11 Mar 1998 | School Standards and Framework Bill — Grant Maintained Schools (Parental Ballot) — rejected | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 11 Mar 1998 | School Standards and Framework Bill - Functions of Education Action Forum | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 24 Feb 1998 | European Parliamentary Elections Bill | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 24 Feb 1998 | European Parliamentary Elections Bill - Number of MEPs, electoral regions and electoral system | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 16 Feb 1998 | Human Rights Bill [Lords] | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 16 Feb 1998 | Human Rights Bill [Lords] | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 10 Feb 1998 | Beef Bones Regulations | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 10 Feb 1998 | Scotland Bill - Power to prevent or require action | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 10 Feb 1998 | Scotland Bill - Exercise of functions | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 10 Feb 1998 | Scotland Bill - Ministers | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 10 Feb 1998 | Scotland Bill - The Scottish Executive | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 21 Jan 1998 | Government of Wales Bill - Transfer of Ministerial functions | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 15 Jan 1998 | European Communities (Amendment) Bill | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 15 Jan 1998 | European Communities (Amendment) Bill - Meaning of "the Treaties" and "the Community Treaties" | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 14 Jan 1998 | Regional Development Agencies Bill | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 14 Jan 1998 | Regional Development Agencies Bill | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 13 Jan 1998 | Scotland Bill | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 17 Dec 1997 | European Communities (Amendment) Bill (Allocation of Time) | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 17 Dec 1997 | Fisheries | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 9 Dec 1997 | Government of Wales Bill | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 9 Dec 1997 | Government of Wales Bill | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 25 Nov 1997 | European Parliamentary Elections Bill | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 12 Nov 1997 | European Communities (Amendment) Bill | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 11 Nov 1997 | Bank of England Bill | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 4 Nov 1997 | Student Finance — Opposition Day Debate | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 3 Nov 1997 | Firearms (Amendment) Bill - Disabled persons: exemption. | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 30 Jul 1997 | Referendums (Scotland and Wales) Bill - Referendum in Scotland | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 29 Jul 1997 | Table - Tax credits | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 29 Jul 1997 | Table | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 28 Jul 1997 | Finance Bill - Stamp duty on conveyance or transfer on sale | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 28 Jul 1997 | Finance Bill - Mortgage Interest Payments | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 28 Jul 1997 | Finance Bill | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 28 Jul 1997 | Finance Bill — Rate of duty on spirits | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 15 Jul 1997 | Finance Bill - Charge to windfall tax | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 14 Jul 1997 | Finance Bill (Allocation of Time) | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 10 Jul 1997 | Finance Bill | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 7 Jul 1997 | Budget Resolutions and Economic Situation - 3. Spirits (rate of duty) | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 7 Jul 1997 | Budget Resolutions and Economic Situation | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 11 Jun 1997 | Firearms (Amendment) Bill | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 10 Jun 1997 | Education (Schools) Bill - Power of local authority to continue to assist pupils | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 3 Jun 1997 | M66 - 3 Jun 1997 : Column 187 Referendums (Scotland and Wales) Bill (Allocation of Time) | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 22 May 1997 | Referendums (Scotland and Wales) Bill | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 20 May 1997 | The Economy and European Affairs | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Commons | 20 May 1997 | The Economy and European Affairs | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |