Voting Comparison — Denis MacShane MP, Rotherham
to Paul Holmes MP, Chesterfield

Denis MacShane

Note: our records only go back to 1997 for the Commons and 2001 for the Lords (more details).

From	To	Party	Rebellions (explain...)	Attendance (explain...)	Teller
6 May 2010	2 Nov 2012	Lab	7 votes out of 280, 2.5%	280 votes out of 636, 44.0%	0 times
5 May 2005	12 Apr 2010	Lab	9 votes out of 670, 1.3%	670 votes out of 1288, 52.0%	1 time
7 Jun 2001	11 Apr 2005	Lab	4 votes out of 608, 0.7%	608 votes out of 1246, 48.8%	0 times
1 May 1997	14 May 2001	Lab	2 votes out of 813, 0.2%	813 votes out of 1273, 63.9%	0 times

Voting Differences

House	Date	Subject	Denis MacShane	Paul Holmes	Rôle
no votes listed
House	Date	Subject	Denis MacShane	Paul Holmes	Rôle
no votes listed
House	Date	Subject	Denis MacShane	Paul Holmes	Rôle
Commons	10 Mar 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill — Weak Sunset Clause	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	10 Mar 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill — Insisted Amendment — Courts and Control Orders	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	10 Mar 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill — Amendments — Burden of Proof	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	10 Mar 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill — Insisted Amendment — Privy Council Review	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	10 Mar 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill — Insisted Again — Courts and Control Orders	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	10 Mar 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill — Weak Sunset Clause	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	10 Mar 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill — Insisted Amendment — Privy Council Review	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	10 Mar 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill — Insisted Amendment — Courts and Conrol Orders	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	10 Mar 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill — Insisted Amendment — Human Rights Obligations	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	10 Mar 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill — Weak Sunset Clause	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	10 Mar 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill — Insisted Amendment — Privy Council Review	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	10 Mar 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill — Insisted Amendments — Application to a Court	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	10 Mar 2005	Support For Members Who Have Chosen Not To Take Their Seats	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	9 Mar 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill — Rejection of Lords' Amendment — Human Rights Obligations	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	9 Mar 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill — Rejection of Lords' Amendment — Rules of the Court	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	9 Mar 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill — Rejection of New Lords' Amendment — Sunset Clause	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	9 Mar 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill — Rejection of New Lords' Clause — Review by Privy Council	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	9 Mar 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill — Rejection of New Lords' Clause — Duration of Control Orders	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	9 Mar 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill — Rejection of Lords' Amendment to Clause 3 — Balance of Probability	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	9 Mar 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill — Derogating Control Orders	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	28 Feb 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill — Third Reading	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	28 Feb 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill — Clauses 1 to 13	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	28 Feb 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill — New Clause 6 — Court of Terrorism Control	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	28 Feb 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill — Amendment to Clause 1 — Power to make control orders	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	28 Feb 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill — Programme — Alteration	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	23 Feb 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill — Programme — Committee of the whole House	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	23 Feb 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill — Second Reading	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	23 Feb 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill — Second Reading — Amendment	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	22 Feb 2005	Drugs Bill — Clause 1 — Aggravated supply of controlled drug	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	22 Feb 2005	Drugs Bill (Programme) (No.2)	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	8 Feb 2005	Belmarsh Judgment	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	7 Feb 2005	Serious Organized Crime and Police Bill -- Authorisation for demonstrations in a designated area	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	7 Feb 2005	Serious Organized Crime and Police Bill -- Demonstrating without authorisation in a designated area	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	7 Feb 2005	Serious Organised Crime and Police Bill — [1st Allotted Day] — New Clause 6 — Interception of communications	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	7 Feb 2005	Serious Organised Crime and Police Bill — [1st Allotted Day] — New Clause 6 — Interception of communications	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	7 Feb 2005	Serious Organised Crime and Police Bill — Abolish the offense of Blasphemy — rejected	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	7 Feb 2005	Serious Organised Crime and Police Bill — New Clause 3 — Racial and religious hatred	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	26 Jan 2005	Commissioners for Revenue and Customs Bill — New Clause 1 — Report on Establishment of Commissioners	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	25 Jan 2005	Food Supplements Directive	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	25 Jan 2005	Food Supplements Directive	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	25 Jan 2005	Licensing Act 2003	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	24 Jan 2005	Gambling Bill — Clause 226 — Gaming machines: Categories A to D	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	24 Jan 2005	Gambling Bill — Clause 170 — Casino premises licence: overall limits	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	24 Jan 2005	Gambling Bill — Clause 58 — Age limit for Category D gaming machines	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	24 Jan 2005	Gambling Bill — Casino conditions	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	12 Jan 2005	Child Benefit Bill (Programme)	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	20 Dec 2004	Identity Cards Bill [Money]	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	20 Dec 2004	Identity Cards Bill (Programme)	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	20 Dec 2004	Identity Cards Bill	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	20 Dec 2004	Identity Cards Bill — Second Reading	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	16 Dec 2004	Pre-Budget Report 2004	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	14 Dec 2004	Mental Capacity Bill — New Clause 5 — Appointment of independent advocates (No. 2)	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	13 Dec 2004	Family Justice	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	7 Dec 2004	Serious Organised Crime and Police Bill — Timetable	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	30 Nov 2004	Health and Education	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	16 Nov 2004	Pensions Bill — Removal of compulsion to take annuities	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	16 Nov 2004	Pensions Bill — Clause 168 — Amounts to be raised by the pension protection levies	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	8 Nov 2004	Housing Bill — Improvements in Energy Efficiency — rejected	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	8 Nov 2004	Housing Bill (Programme) (No. 3)	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	1 Nov 2004	Gambling Bill (Programme)	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	1 Nov 2004	Gambling Bill — 2nd reading	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	1 Nov 2004	Gambling Bill — reasoned amendment on 2nd reading	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	27 Oct 2004	Domestic Violence, Crime and Victims Bill [Lords] (Programme) (No.2)	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	19 Oct 2004	New Clause 1 — Amendment of Companies Act 1985: limit on auditor's liability (No.1)	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	18 Oct 2004	Crime	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	18 Oct 2004	Crime	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	8 Sep 2004	Hospital-Acquired Infection	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	8 Sep 2004	Hospital-Acquired Infection	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	8 Sep 2004	Pensions Policy	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	19 Jul 2004	New Clause 1 — Infection control standards — Clause 5 — Co-operation	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	19 Jul 2004	New Clause 1 — Infection control standards	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	6 Jul 2004	Finance Bill — [1st Allotted Day] — New Clause 7 — Application of sections 298 to 301	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	28 Jun 2004	Human Tissue Bill — New Clause 1 — Determination of consent for removal, storage and use of organs from Adults for purpose of transplantation	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	23 Jun 2004	European Union Documents — Marketing of Maize Genetically Modified for Glyphosate Tolerance	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	23 Jun 2004	Delegated Legislation — Urban Development	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	23 Jun 2004	Higher Education Bill — Clause 27 — Sections 22 to 26: supplementary provisions	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	23 Jun 2004	Higher Education Bill — Clause 27 — Sections 22 to 26: supplementary provisions	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	23 Jun 2004	Higher Education Bill — Director of Fair Access to Higher Education	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	23 Jun 2004	Higher Education Bill — Director of Fair Access to Higher Education	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	22 Jun 2004	Nhs Recruitment and Retention	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	22 Jun 2004	Electoral System	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	15 Jun 2004	Transport	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	26 May 2004	Town Planning	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	26 May 2004	Town Planning	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	26 May 2004	Local Government Finance	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	19 May 2004	Pensions Bill — [2nd Allotted Day] — New Clause 34 — Financial assistance scheme for members of certain pension schemes	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	18 May 2004	Pensions Bill — [1st Allotted Day] — New Clause 30 — Payment of surplus to employer	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	11 May 2004	Housing Bill — Clause 137 — Duty to have a home information pack	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	11 May 2004	Housing Bill — Schedule 11 — Buildings which are not HMOs (except in Part 1)	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	5 May 2004	Housing	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	5 May 2004	Housing	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	28 Apr 2004	Finance Bill — [2nd Allotted Day] — Schedule 39 — Stamp Duty Land Tax: Application to Certain Partnership Transactions	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	27 Apr 2004	Finance Bill — [1st Allotted Day] — Clause 4 — Duty Stamps for Spirits Etc	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	31 Mar 2004	Higher Education Bill — Third Reading	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	31 Mar 2004	Higher Education Bill — Meaning of "the relevant authority"	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	31 Mar 2004	Higher Education Bill — New Clause 5 — Abolition of tuition fees chargeable to qualifying student	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	31 Mar 2004	Higher Education Bill — New Clause 5 — Abolition of tuition fees chargeable to qualifying student	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	31 Mar 2004	Higher Education Bill (Programme) (No. 4)	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	30 Mar 2004	European Parliamentary and Local Elections (Pilots) Bill	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	30 Mar 2004	EU Constitution Referendum	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	30 Mar 2004	EU Constitution Referendum	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	29 Mar 2004	Employment Relations Bill — Clause 34 — Information and Consultation: Great Britain	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	29 Mar 2004	Employment Relations Bill — New Clause 2 — Intimidation	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	29 Mar 2004	European Parliamentary and Local Elections (Pilots) Bill	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	9 Mar 2004	Iraq — Attorney-General's Advice	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	8 Mar 2004	European Parliamentary and Local Elections (Pilots) Bill — Clause 2 — Pilot Order	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	8 Mar 2004	European Parliamentary and Local Elections (Pilots) Bill — Clause 2 — Pilot Order	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	8 Mar 2004	European Parliamentary and Local Elections (Pilots) Bill — Clause 1 — Piloting Conduct at European and Local Elections	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	8 Mar 2004	European Parliamentary and Local Elections (Pilots) Bill (Programme) (No. 3)	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	1 Mar 2004	Asylum and Immigration (Treatment of Claimants, Etc.) Bill — Third Reading	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	1 Mar 2004	Asylum and Immigration (Treatment of Claimants, Etc.) Bill — New Clause 8 — Initial decisions	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	1 Mar 2004	Asylum and Immigration (Treatment of Claimants, Etc.) Bill — Give support to asylum seekers even when they make a late claim — rejected	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	1 Mar 2004	Asylum and Immigration (Treatment of Claimants, Etc.) Bill — Clause 11 — Unification of appeal system	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	1 Mar 2004	Asylum and Immigration (Treatment of Claimants, Etc.) Bill — Asylum appeals should be referred to a higher court — rejected	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	1 Mar 2004	Asylum and Immigration (Treatment of Claimants, Etc.) Bill — Give support to failed asylum seekers and their families — rejected	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	1 Mar 2004	Asylum and Immigration (Treatment of Claimants, Etc.) Bill — Burden of proof on prosecution rather than defendant in cases where immigrants to not have travel documents — rejected	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	26 Feb 2004	Employment Relations Bill [Money]	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	11 Feb 2004	Regional Assemblies	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	3 Feb 2004	Child Trust Funds Bill — Clause 29 — Interpretation	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	2 Feb 2004	Horserace Betting and Olympic Lottery Bill — Clause 8 — Exclusive licence	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	27 Jan 2004	Higher Education Bill (Programme)	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	27 Jan 2004	Higher Education Bill — Second Reading — Increase in University Tuition Fees	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	26 Jan 2004	Fire and Rescue Services Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	13 Jan 2004	Future of the Post Office Network — Deplores the programme — rejected	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	6 Jan 2004	National Insurance Contributions and Statutory Payments Bill (Programme)	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	17 Dec 2003	Asylum and Immigration (Treatment of Claimants, etc.) Bill — Second Reading	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	17 Dec 2003	Asylum and Immigration (Treatment of Claimants, etc.) Bill — Decline to give a Second Reading — rejected	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	16 Dec 2003	European Parliamentary and Local Elections (Pilots) Bill — New Clause 4 — Conduct of elections under a pilot order	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	16 Dec 2003	European Parliamentary and Local Elections (Pilots) Bill — New Clause 2 — Additional provisions in respect of postal voting	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	19 Nov 2003	Health and Social Care (Community Health and Standards) Bill — Clause 1 — NHS Foundation Trusts	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	19 Nov 2003	Criminal Justice Bill — Clause 41 — Application by Defendant for Trial to be Conducted without Jury	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	19 Nov 2003	Criminal Justice Bill — Clause 41 — Application by Defendant for Trial to be Conducted without Jury	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	19 Nov 2003	Criminal Justice Bill — Clause 41 — Application by Defendant for Trial to be Conducted without Jury	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	19 Nov 2003	Health and Social Care (Community Health and Standards) Bill — Clause 15 — Private Health Care	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	19 Nov 2003	Health and Social Care (Community Health and Standards) Bill — Clause 15 — Private Health Care	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	19 Nov 2003	Health and Social Care (Community Health and Standards) Bill — Clause 3 — General Duty of Regulator	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	19 Nov 2003	Health and Social Care (Community Health and Standards) Bill — Clause 1 — NHS foundation trusts	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	18 Nov 2003	Criminal Justice Bill — Clause 254 — Determination of Minimum Term in Relation to Mandatory Life Sentence	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	18 Nov 2003	Criminal Justice Bill — Clause 216 — Life Sentence or Imprisonment for Public Protection for Serious Offences	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	18 Nov 2003	Criminal Justice Bill — Clause 146 — General Limit on Magistrates' Court's Power to Impose Imprisonment	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	18 Nov 2003	Criminal Justice Bill — New Clause	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	18 Nov 2003	Criminal Justice Bill — Clause 78 — Authorisation of Investigations	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	18 Nov 2003	Criminal Justice Bill — Clause 4 — Use of Telephones for Review of Police Detention	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	18 Nov 2003	Criminal Justice Bill — Clause 43 — Application by Prosecution for Trial to be Conducted without Jury where Danger of Jury Tampering	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	18 Nov 2003	Criminal Justice Bill — Clause 42 — Applications by Prosecution for Certain Complex or Lengthy Trials to be Conducted without Jury	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	5 Nov 2003	Decommissioning (Northern Ireland)	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	28 Oct 2003	Waste and Emissions Trading Bill [Lords] — New Clause 17 — Directions to Waste Disposal Authorities	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	28 Oct 2003	Waste and Emissions Trading Bill [Lords] — New Clause 5 — Environmental impact assessment of incineration	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	28 Oct 2003	Waste and Emissions Trading Bill [Lords] — New Clause 1 — Strategies for Waste Minimisation: England	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	27 Oct 2003	Health Care Targets	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	22 Oct 2003	Deferred Division — Recovery Plan for Cod and the Recovery of the Northern Hake Stock	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	21 Oct 2003	European Parliamentary and Local Elections (Pilots) Bill (Programme)	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	21 Oct 2003	European Parliamentary and Local Elections (Pilots) Bill	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	20 Oct 2003	Courts Bill [Lords] — Clause 4 — Establishment of Courts Boards	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	20 Oct 2003	Courts Bill [Lords] — Clause 1 — The General Duty	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	20 Oct 2003	Courts Bill [Lords] — New Clause 2 — Judicial Independence	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	16 Jul 2003	Deferred Divisions — Immigration — Social Security	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	16 Jul 2003	Asylum (Designated States) (No. 2) Order 2003	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	16 Jul 2003	Deferred Divisions	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	16 Jul 2003	Deferred Divisions	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	16 Jul 2003	Iraq — Foreign Affairs Committee Report	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	14 Jul 2003	Communications Bill (Programme) (No. 3)	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	9 Jul 2003	Convention on the Future of Europe	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	8 Jul 2003	Health and Social Care (Community Health and Standards) Bill — New Clause 9 — Foundation Patients' Fora	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	8 Jul 2003	Health and Social Care (Community Health and Standards) Bill — NHS Community Trusts	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	7 Jul 2003	Tax Credits	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	7 Jul 2003	Tax Credits	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	7 Jul 2003	Government Targets	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	2 Jul 2003	Small Businesses	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	2 Jul 2003	Small Businesses	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	1 Jul 2003	Finance Bill — Schedule 19 — Stamp Duty Land Tax: Commencement and Transitional Provisions	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	1 Jul 2003	Finance Bill — Schedule 19 — Stamp Duty Land Tax: Commencement and Transitional Provisions	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	1 Jul 2003	Finance Bill — Clause 56 — Amount of Tax Chargeable: Rent	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	25 Jun 2003	Fair Trade	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	25 Jun 2003	Tuition Fees	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	24 Jun 2003	Licensing Bill [Lords]	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	24 Jun 2003	Licensing Bill [Lords] (Programme) (No. 3)	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	24 Jun 2003	Anti-social Behaviour Bill — third reading—	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	24 Jun 2003	Anti-social Behaviour Bill — Clause 29 — Dispersal of Groups and Removal of Persons Under 16 to Their Place of Residence	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	24 Jun 2003	Anti-social Behaviour Bill (Programme) (No. 2)	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	23 Jun 2003	Consolidated Fund (Appropriation) (No. 2) Bill	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	23 Jun 2003	Consolidated Fund (Appropriation) (No. 2) Bill	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	23 Jun 2003	Transport	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	23 Jun 2003	Transport	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	23 Jun 2003	Student Finance	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	23 Jun 2003	Student Finance	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	17 Jun 2003	Community Pharmacies	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	17 Jun 2003	Government Reshuffle	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	16 Jun 2003	Licensing Bill [Lords] — Clause 17 — Application For Premises Licence	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	16 Jun 2003	Licensing Bill [Lords] — Schedule 1 — Provision Of Regulated Entertainment	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	16 Jun 2003	Licensing Bill [Lords] — Schedule 1 — Provision Of Regulated Entertainment	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	11 Jun 2003	Post Office Card Accounts	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	11 Jun 2003	Post Office Card Accounts	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	11 Jun 2003	European Treaty Referendum	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	10 Jun 2003	Planning and Compulsory Purchase Bill (Extension of Period for Proceedings)	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	4 Jun 2003	Iraq — Weapons of Mass Destruction Inquiry	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	20 May 2003	Criminal Justice Bill — Third Reading	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	20 May 2003	Criminal Justice Bill — [3rd Alloted Day] — New Clause 6	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	20 May 2003	Criminal Justice Bill — [3rd Alloted Day] — New Clause 6	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	20 May 2003	Criminal Justice Bill — [3rd Alloted Day] — Government New Clause 30 — Determination of Minimum Term in Relation to Mandatory Life Sentence	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	19 May 2003	Criminal Justice Bill — [2nd Allotted Day] — Clause 63 — Cases that may be Retried	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	19 May 2003	Criminal Justice Bill — [2nd Allotted Day] — New Clause 29 — Rules of Court	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	19 May 2003	Criminal Justice Bill — [2nd Allotted Day] — New Clause 29 — Rules of Court	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	13 May 2003	Finance Bill — Clause 22 — Non-Business Use of Business Property	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	13 May 2003	Finance Bill — Clause 22 — Non-Business Use of Business Property	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	13 May 2003	Finance Bill — Clause 22 — Non-Business Use of Business Property	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	13 May 2003	Finance Bill — Clause 22 — Non-Business Use of Business Property	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	13 May 2003	Finance Bill — Clause 5 — Rebates on Hydrocarbon Oil Duties	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	13 May 2003	Finance Bill — Clause 4 — Rates of Hydrocarbon Oil Duties	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	8 May 2003	Fire Services Bill (Programme)	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	8 May 2003	Fire Services Bill	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	7 May 2003	Health and Social Care (Community Health and Standards) Bill (Programme)	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	7 May 2003	Health and Social Care (Community Health and Standards) Bill	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	7 May 2003	Health and Social Care (Community Health and Standards) Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	6 May 2003	Finance Bill (Programme)	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	27 Mar 2003	Police (Northern Ireland) Bill [Lords] — New Clause 8 — Appointments to the Police Service of Northern Ireland	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	26 Mar 2003	Police (Northern Ireland) Bill [Lords] — New Clause 2 — Independent Members: Disqualification	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	26 Mar 2003	Police (Northern Ireland) Bill [Lords] — New Clause 2 — Independent Members: Disqualification	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	25 Mar 2003	Extradition Bill — New Clause 19 — Injustice and Oppression	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	25 Mar 2003	Extradition Bill — New Clause 19 — Injustice and Oppression	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	24 Mar 2003	Licensing Bill — Second Reading	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	19 Mar 2003	Community Care (Delayed Discharges Etc.) Bill — After Clause 4	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	19 Mar 2003	Community Care (Delayed Discharges Etc.) Bill — After Clause 3	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	19 Mar 2003	Community Care (Delayed Discharges Etc.) Bill — Clause 3 — Duties Arising Where a Notice Under Section 2 is Given	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	18 Mar 2003	Iraq — Declaration of War	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	18 Mar 2003	Iraq — Case for war not established — rejected	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	26 Feb 2003	Iraq — Endorse UN Security Council Resolution 1441 — Final Opportunity for Iraq to Disarm	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	26 Feb 2003	Iraq — Case for war is unproven — rejected	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	25 Feb 2003	Delegated Legislation — Local Government Bill (Programme) (No. 3)	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	12 Feb 2003	Mid-Term Review of the Common Agricultural Policy	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	12 Feb 2003	Mid-Term Review of the Common Agricultural Policy	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	4 Feb 2003	House of Lords Reform — Option 4 (80 per Cent. Elected) — rejected	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	4 Feb 2003	House of Lords Reform — Option 2 (100 per Cent. Elected) — rejected	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	3 Feb 2003	European Parliament (Representation) Bill — Clause 2 — Electoral Commission Recommendations	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	15 Jan 2003	Community Care (Delayed Discharges etc.) Bill — Clause 12 — Free Provision of Certain Community Care Services	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	15 Jan 2003	Community Care (Delayed Discharges etc.) Bill — New Clause 3 — Meaning of 'Carer' and 'Carers' Assessment'	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	7 Jan 2003	Local Government Bill	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	18 Dec 2002	Deferred Divisions — Section 5 Of The European Communities (Amendment) Act 1993	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	18 Dec 2002	Regional Assemblies (Preparations) Bill — [Sir Alan Haselhurst in the Chair] — Clause 1 — Referendums	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	17 Dec 2002	Planning and Compulsory Purchase Bill	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	17 Dec 2002	Planning and Compulsory Purchase Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	4 Dec 2002	Criminal Justice Bill	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	26 Nov 2002	Regional Assemblies (Preparations) Bill (Programme)	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	25 Nov 2002	Iraq — UN Security Council Resolution 1441 — Second resolution necessary — rejected	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	30 Oct 2002	Enterprise Bill — Clause 21 — Duty To Make References In Relation To Completed Mergers	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	30 Oct 2002	Enterprise Bill — Clause 1 — Office of Fair Trading	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	24 Jul 2002	Education — Clause 10 — Powers of governing bodies to form or invest in companies to provide services etc	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	24 Jul 2002	Education — Clause 10 — Powers of governing bodies to form or invest in companies to provide services etc	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	18 Jul 2002	Proceeds of Crime Bill — Clause 251 — Proceedings for recovery orders in England and Wales or Northern Ireland	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	18 Jul 2002	Proceeds of Crime Bill — Clause 6 — Making of order	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	15 Jul 2002	Education Bill — Clause 41 — Schools forums	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	15 Jul 2002	Education Bill — Before Clause 18	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	15 Jul 2002	Education Bill — Clause 10 — Powers of governing bodies to form or invest in companies to provide services etc.	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	4 Jul 2002	Finance Bill — [2nd Allotted Day] — Schedule 37 — Aggregates levy amendments	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	4 Jul 2002	Finance Bill — [2nd Allotted Day] — Clause 98 — Gift aid: election to be treated as if gift made in previous year	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	4 Jul 2002	Finance Bill — [2nd Allotted Day] — Clause 91 — Supplementary charge in respect of ring fence trades	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	4 Jul 2002	Finance Bill — [2nd Allotted Day] — Clause 3 — Duty on beverages made with spirits to be at spirits rates	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	3 Jul 2002	Finance Bill — [1st Allotted Day] — New Clause 7 — Taxation of community amateur sports clubs	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	3 Jul 2002	Finance Bill — [1st Allotted Day] — New Clause 5 — Contingent liabilities under the Private Finance Initiative	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	3 Jul 2002	Finance Bill — [1st Allotted Day] — New Clause 1 — Supplementary charge in respect of ring fence trades: financing costs	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	25 Jun 2002	Mental Health	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	24 Jun 2002	Export Control Bill — Clause 1 — Export controls	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	12 Jun 2002	Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Bill — Third Reading	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	12 Jun 2002	Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Bill — [2nd Allotted Day] — Clause 126 — Power to search for evidence	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	12 Jun 2002	Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Bill — Do not penalise those who bring passengers to the UK without the necessary authority — rejected	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	12 Jun 2002	Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Bill — [2nd Allotted Day] — New Clause 10 — Withholding and withdrawal of support	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	11 Jun 2002	Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Bill — Allow earlier rights of appeal — rejected	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	11 Jun 2002	Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Bill — [1st Allotted Day] — New Clause 15 — Appeal from within United Kingdom: unfounded human rights or asylum claim: transitional provision	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	11 Jun 2002	Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Bill — Do not allow appeals against rejected asylum claims from within the UK if the claim is unfounded	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	11 Jun 2002	Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Bill — Do not allow appeals against rejected asylum claims from within the UK if the claim is unfounded	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	11 Jun 2002	Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Bill — [1st Allotted Day] — Clause 14 — Establishment of centres	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	11 Jun 2002	Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Bill — [1st Allotted Day] — Clause 14 — Establishment of centres	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	11 Jun 2002	Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Bill (Programme) (No. 3) — Re-committal	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	10 Jun 2002	National Insurance Contributions Bill — [Sir Michael Lord in the Chair] — Clause 1 — Primary Class 1 contributions	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	23 May 2002	State Pension Credit Bill [Lords] — New Clause 5 — Report on incentives etc.	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	22 May 2002	National Health Service Reform and Health Care Professions Bill — New Clause	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	22 May 2002	National Health Service Reform and Health Care Professions Bill — New Clause	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	21 May 2002	Special Educational Needs	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	21 May 2002	School Discipline	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	15 May 2002	Johannesburg Summit	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	15 May 2002	Post Office Closures — Deep concern — rejected	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	14 May 2002	Payment for Chairmen	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	14 May 2002	Modernisation of the House of Commons — SELECT COMMITTEES (No. 1)	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	14 May 2002	Modernisation of the House of Commons	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	24 Apr 2002	Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Bill (Programme) — Programming Committee	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	15 Apr 2002	Electoral Fraud (Northern Ireland) Bill (Programme) — Subsequent stages	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	13 Mar 2002	Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill [Lords] — [2nd Allotted Day] — New Clause 19 — Leases exceeding 21 years	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	13 Mar 2002	Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill [Lords] — [2nd Allotted Day] — New Clause 3 — Abolition of forfeiture	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	12 Mar 2002	London and the South-East	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	12 Mar 2002	London and the South-East	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	11 Mar 2002	Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill [Lords] — [1st Allotted Day] — New Clause 1 — Landlord's share of marriage value	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	5 Mar 2002	Steel Industry	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	5 Mar 2002	Steel Industry	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	27 Feb 2002	Proceeds of Crime Bill — [2nd Allotted Day] — Clause 447 — Orders and regulations	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	5 Feb 2002	Education Bill — Power of school to innovate without permission of the Secretary of State — rejected	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	5 Feb 2002	Education Bill — [1st Allotted Day]	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	31 Jan 2002	Travel Concessions (Eligibility) Bill [Lords] — Clause 1 — Eligibility for travel concessions: age	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	30 Jan 2002	Local Government Finance	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	22 Jan 2002	Public Services	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	22 Jan 2002	Public Services	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	16 Jan 2002	Care System	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	16 Jan 2002	Care System	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	16 Jan 2002	Railways	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	15 Jan 2002	National Health Service Reform and Health Care Professions Bill — Schedule 2 — Reallocation of Functions of Health Authorities to Primary Care Trusts	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	15 Jan 2002	National Health Service Reform and Health Care Professions Bill — New Clause 5 — Establishment of Patients' Councils	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	15 Jan 2002	National Health Service Reform and Health Care Professions Bill — New Clause 2 — Community Health Councils: scheme for reform	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	14 Jan 2002	Office of Communications Bill [Lords] (Programme) — Consideration and Third Reading	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	18 Dec 2001	Facilities of the House	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	13 Dec 2001	Anti-terrorism, Crime and Security Bill — Removal of Sunset Clause — Insistence	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	13 Dec 2001	Animal Health Bill — New Clause 11 — National Contingency Plan	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	4 Dec 2001	Education Bill	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	4 Dec 2001	Education Bill	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	4 Dec 2001	Education Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	3 Dec 2001	Public Services	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	3 Dec 2001	Public Services	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	3 Dec 2001	Dissemination of Information	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	3 Dec 2001	Dissemination of Information	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	26 Nov 2001	Anti-terrorism, Crime and Security Bill — Third Reading	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	26 Nov 2001	Anti-terrorism, Crime and Security Bill — Amendment to Clause 17 — Disclosure Powers	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	26 Nov 2001	Anti-terrorism, Crime and Security Bill — Clauses 101 to 105, 120 to 122 — Communication Data	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	26 Nov 2001	Anti-terrorism, Crime and Security Bill — Amendment to Clause 89 — Identification at a Police Station	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	26 Nov 2001	Anti-terrorism, Crime and Security Bill — Clause 38 — Religious Hatred	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	13 Nov 2001	Stakeholder Pensions	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	13 Nov 2001	Stakeholder Pensions	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	13 Nov 2001	Railtrack	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	12 Nov 2001	Animal Health Bill [Money]	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	12 Nov 2001	Animal Health Bill (Programme) — Consideration and Third Reading	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	12 Nov 2001	Animal Health Bill	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	12 Nov 2001	Animal Health Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	23 Oct 2001	Ministerial Conduct (DTLR)	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	16 Jul 2001	Select Committees — Accommodation and Works — Transport, Local Government and the Regions	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	16 Jul 2001	Select Committees — Accommodation and Works — Foreign Affairs	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	11 Jul 2001	Deferred Divisions — Education	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	10 Jul 2001	Electoral Fraud (Northern Ireland) Bill (Programme) — Consideration and Third Reading	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
House	Date	Subject	Denis MacShane	Paul Holmes	Rôle
no votes listed

Voting Comparison — Denis MacShane MP, Rotherham
to Paul Holmes MP, Chesterfield

Voting Differences

About the Project

The Whip on the Web

Help keep PublicWhip alive

Voting Comparison — Denis MacShane MP, Rotherham to Paul Holmes MP, Chesterfield

Voting Differences

About the Project

The Whip on the Web

Help keep PublicWhip alive

Voting Comparison — Denis MacShane MP, Rotherham
to Paul Holmes MP, Chesterfield