Voting Comparison — Margaret Smith MSP, Edinburgh West
to John Farquhar Munro MSP, Ross, Skye and Inverness West

Note: our records only go back to 1997 for the Commons and 2001 for the Lords (more details).

FromToPartyRebellions (explain...)Attendance (explain...)Teller
3 May 2007 23 Mar 2011 LDem 1 vote out of 555, 0.2% 555 votes out of 606, 91.6% n/a
1 May 2003 2 Apr 2007 LDem 11 votes out of 1314, 0.8% 1314 votes out of 1411, 93.1% n/a
6 May 1999 31 Mar 2003 LDem 22 votes out of 1094, 2.0% 1094 votes out of 1287, 85.0% n/a

Voting Differences

HouseDateSubjectMargaret SmithJohn Farquhar MunroRôle
no votes listed
HouseDateSubjectMargaret SmithJohn Farquhar MunroRôle
no votes listed
HouseDateSubjectMargaret SmithJohn Farquhar MunroRôle
Scotland30 Jan 2003[S1M-3818] Decision Time abstentionaye disagrees with policy
Scotland8 Jan 2003Local Government in Scotland Bill: Stage 3 — Section 15 — Publication by local authorities of information about finance and performance minorityno disagrees with policy
Scotland8 Jan 2003Points of Order minorityabstention disagrees with policy
Scotland12 Dec 2002[S1M-3702.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland28 Nov 2002[S1M-3648] Decision Time Majorityno disagrees with policy
Scotland13 Nov 2002Debt Arrangement and Attachment (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 46 — Exceptional attachment order Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland13 Nov 2002Debt Arrangement and Attachment (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 26 — Notice of public auction Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland31 Oct 2002[S1M-3511.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time minorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland20 Jun 2002[S1M-3223] Decision Time Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland29 May 2002[S1M-3153.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time Majorityno disagrees with policy
Scotland29 May 2002[S1M-3154] Decision Time Majorityabstention disagrees with policy
Scotland29 May 2002[S1M-3154.3 (Amendment)] Decision Time Majorityabstention disagrees with policy
Scotland29 May 2002[S1M-3162.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time Majorityabstention disagrees with policy
Scotland29 May 2002[S1M-3155] Decision Time Majorityabstention disagrees with policy
Scotland29 May 2002[S1M-3155.3 (Amendment)] Decision Time Majorityabstention disagrees with policy
Scotland29 May 2002[S1M-3155.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time Majorityabstention disagrees with policy
Scotland29 May 2002[S1M-3155.1.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time Majorityabstention disagrees with policy
Scotland18 Apr 2002[S1M-2994] Social Care Work Force (Development) minorityno disagrees with policy
Scotland14 Feb 2002Water Industry (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Long Title Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland14 Feb 2002Water Industry (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Schedule 6 — Modifications of Water (Scotland) Act 1980 Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland14 Feb 2002Water Industry (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Schedule 1 — Water Industry Commissioner and Customer Panels: Further Provision Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland14 Feb 2002Water Industry (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 49 — Directions Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland14 Feb 2002Water Industry (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 28 — Charges for goods and services Majorityabstention disagrees with policy
Scotland13 Feb 2002[S1M-2726] Decision Time Majorityno disagrees with policy
Scotland13 Feb 2002[S1M-2726.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland13 Feb 2002Protection of Wild Mammals (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — After section 6 minorityno disagrees with policy
Scotland13 Feb 2002Protection of Wild Mammals (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — After section 6 Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland13 Feb 2002Protection of Wild Mammals (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 6 — Disqualification orders minorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland13 Feb 2002Protection of Wild Mammals (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 6 — Disqualification orders Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland13 Feb 2002Protection of Wild Mammals (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 6 — Disqualification orders Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland13 Feb 2002Protection of Wild Mammals (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 6 — Disqualification orders Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland13 Feb 2002Protection of Wild Mammals (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 6 — Disqualification orders abstentionaye disagrees with policy
Scotland13 Feb 2002Protection of Wild Mammals (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 5 — Proceedings and penalties Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland13 Feb 2002Protection of Wild Mammals (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 5 — Proceedings and penalties Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland13 Feb 2002Protection of Wild Mammals (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 4 — Arrest, search and seizure Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland13 Feb 2002Protection of Wild Mammals (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 4 — Arrest, search and seizure Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland13 Feb 2002Protection of Wild Mammals (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 3 — Exception: retrieval and location Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland13 Feb 2002Protection of Wild Mammals (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 1F — Exception: use of dog where method of humane dispatch not available Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland13 Feb 2002Protection of Wild Mammals (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 1D — Exception: use of a dog in connection with falconry and shooting minorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland13 Feb 2002Protection of Wild Mammals (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 1B — Exception: pest control (places unsafe for shooting) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland13 Feb 2002Protection of Wild Mammals (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 1A — Exception: stalking and flushing from cover Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland13 Feb 2002Protection of Wild Mammals (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 1A — Exception: stalking and flushing from cover minorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland13 Feb 2002Protection of Wild Mammals (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 1A — Exception: stalking and flushing from cover Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland13 Feb 2002Protection of Wild Mammals (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 1A — Exception: stalking and flushing from cover Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland13 Feb 2002Protection of Wild Mammals (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — After section 1 Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland13 Feb 2002Protection of Wild Mammals (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — After section 1 Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland24 Jan 2002[S1M-2633.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time Majorityabstention disagrees with policy
Scotland19 Sep 2001[S1M-2078] Decision Time Majorityno disagrees with policy
Scotland29 Mar 2001[S1M-1807.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time Majorityabstention disagrees with policy
Scotland15 Mar 2001[S1M-1760] Decision Time Majorityno disagrees with policy
Scotland15 Mar 2001[S1M-1760.3 (Amendment)] Decision Time Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland8 Mar 2001[S1M-1726] Decision Time Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland8 Mar 2001[S1M-1725] Decision Time noaye disagrees with policy
Scotland8 Mar 2001[S1M-1725.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time minorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland8 Mar 2001[S1M-1725.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time minorityno disagrees with policy
Scotland18 Jan 2001[S1M-1556.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time minorityno disagrees with policy
Scotland17 Jan 2001[S1M-1555] Decision Time Majorityno disagrees with policy
Scotland17 Jan 2001[S1M-1555.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland11 Jan 2001Salmon Conservation (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 1 — Conservation of salmon and sea trout Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland20 Dec 2000Transport (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — After section 68 Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland20 Dec 2000Transport (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 42 — Confirmation of orders Majorityabstention disagrees with policy
Scotland7 Dec 2000[S1M-1428] Business Motion Majorityno disagrees with policy
Scotland6 Dec 2000Abolition of Poindings and Warrant Sales Bill: Stage 3 — Section 3 — Commencement and short title Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland16 Nov 2000[S1M-1354] Decision Time Majorityno disagrees with policy
Scotland25 Oct 2000[S1M-1271.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland25 Oct 2000[S1M-1275.1 (Amendment)] Business Motions Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland6 Sep 2000[S1M-1147.2 (Amendment)] Business Motion abstentionaye disagrees with policy
Scotland5 Jul 2000National Parks (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — After section 33 Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland21 Jun 2000Ethical Standards in Public Life etc (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Schedule 3 — Devolved Public Bodies Majorityno disagrees with policy
Scotland21 Jun 2000Ethical Standards in Public Life etc (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Schedule 3 — Devolved Public Bodies Majorityno disagrees with policy
Scotland15 Jun 2000[S1M-905.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time Majorityno disagrees with policy
Scotland7 Jun 2000Standards in Scotland's Schools etc Bill: Stage 3 — After section 52 abstentionaye disagrees with policy
Scotland7 Jun 2000Standards in Scotland's Schools etc Bill: Stage 3 — Section 51A — Code of practice as regards inspection of education authorities Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland7 Jun 2000Standards in Scotland's Schools etc Bill: Stage 3 — Section 51 — Abolition of Scottish Joint Negotiating Committee for School Education Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland7 Jun 2000Standards in Scotland's Schools etc Bill: Stage 3 — After section 36 Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland7 Jun 2000Standards in Scotland's Schools etc Bill: Stage 3 — Section 29 — Provision of education for pre-school children etc Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland7 Jun 2000Standards in Scotland's Schools etc Bill: Stage 3 — After section 20 Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland7 Jun 2000Standards in Scotland's Schools etc Bill: Stage 3 — Section 3 — Raising standards Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland27 Apr 2000[S1M-772] Decision Time abstentionaye disagrees with policy
Scotland26 Apr 2000[S1M-778] Motion without notice Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland29 Mar 2000Adults with Incapacity (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — After section 48A Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland29 Mar 2000Adults with Incapacity (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — After section 48A Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland29 Mar 2000Adults with Incapacity (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 47 — Medical treatment where guardian etc has been appointed Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland29 Mar 2000Adults with Incapacity (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 1 — General principles and fundamental definitions Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland23 Mar 2000[S1M-675.4 (Amendment)] Decision Time Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland2 Mar 2000[S1M-607.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland1 Mar 2000[S1M-559] Decision Time Majorityno disagrees with policy
Scotland17 Nov 1999[S1M-285.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland4 Nov 1999[S1M-242.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time Majorityno disagrees with policy
Scotland4 Nov 1999[S1M-242.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland28 Oct 1999[S1M-230.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland1 Sep 1999[S1M-105.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland24 Jun 1999[S1M-68] Decision Time Majorityabstention disagrees with policy
Scotland24 Jun 1999[S1M-68.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Scotland17 Jun 1999[S1M-52] Decision Time Majorityno disagrees with policy
Scotland3 Jun 1999[S1M-19.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time Majorityabstention disagrees with policy

About the Project

The Public Whip is a not-for-profit, open source website created in 2003 by Francis Irving and Julian Todd and now run by Bairwell Ltd.

There are lots of plans afoot, including extensive redevelopment of the site and plans for new functionality. To keep up with what's happening, please check out the blog. We're working on updating all the contact details throughout the site, but if you'd like to talk to us about the project, please email [email protected]

The Whip on the Web

Advertisement - Helping keeping PublicWhip alive