Voting Comparison — Robert Smith MP, West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
to Paul Holmes MP, Chesterfield

Robert Smith

Note: our records only go back to 1997 for the Commons and 2001 for the Lords (more details).

From	To	Party	Rebellions (explain...)	Attendance (explain...)	Teller
6 May 2010	30 Mar 2015	LDem	14 votes out of 954, 1.5%	954 votes out of 1239, 77.0%	1 time
5 May 2005	12 Apr 2010	LDem	6 votes out of 935, 0.6%	935 votes out of 1288, 72.6%	31 times
7 Jun 2001	11 Apr 2005	LDem	32 votes out of 960, 3.3%	960 votes out of 1246, 77.0%	54 times
1 May 1997	14 May 2001	LDem	25 votes out of 858, 2.9%	858 votes out of 1273, 67.4%	49 times

Voting Differences

House	Date	Subject	Robert Smith	Paul Holmes	Rôle
no votes listed
House	Date	Subject	Robert Smith	Paul Holmes	Rôle
no votes listed
House	Date	Subject	Robert Smith	Paul Holmes	Rôle
Commons	10 Mar 2005	Support For Members Who Have Chosen Not To Take Their Seats	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	28 Feb 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill — Third Reading	tellno	no	agrees with policy
Commons	28 Feb 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill — Clauses 1 to 13	tellno	no	agrees with policy
Commons	28 Feb 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill — New Clause 6 — Court of Terrorism Control	tellaye	aye	agrees with policy
Commons	28 Feb 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill — Programme — Alteration	tellno	no	agrees with policy
Commons	10 Feb 2005	Identity Cards Bill — Clause 31 — Tampering with the Register etc.	tellno	no	agrees with policy
Commons	10 Feb 2005	Identity Cards Bill — Clause 5 — Applications Relating to Entries in Register	tellaye	aye	agrees with policy
Commons	7 Feb 2005	Serious Organized Crime and Police Bill -- Demonstrating without authorisation in a designated area	tellno	no	agrees with policy
Commons	7 Feb 2005	Serious Organised Crime and Police Bill — New Clause 3 — Racial and religious hatred	tellaye	aye	agrees with policy
Commons	26 Jan 2005	Modernisation of the House of Commons	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	16 Dec 2004	School Transport Bill — Clause 1 — School travel schemes	tellaye	aye	agrees with policy
Commons	14 Dec 2004	Mental Capacity Bill — Clause 31 — Requirements for approval	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	14 Dec 2004	Mental Capacity Bill — Clause 4 — Best interests	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	14 Dec 2004	Mental Capacity Bill — New Clause 2 — Excluded decisions (No. 2)	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	14 Dec 2004	Mental Capacity Bill — New Clause 1 — Excluded decisions	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	18 Nov 2004	Hunting Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	18 Nov 2004	Hunting Bill	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	18 Nov 2004	Hunting Bill (Procedure) (No. 3)	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	16 Nov 2004	Hunting Bill — Clause 1 — Hunting wild mammals with dogs	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	16 Nov 2004	Hunting Bill — Clause 1 — Hunting wild mammals with dogs	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	16 Nov 2004	Hunting Bill — Clause 1 — Hunting wild mammals with dogs	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	16 Nov 2004	Hunting Bill — Clause 1 — Hunting wild mammals with dogs	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	16 Nov 2004	Hunting Bill (Procedure) (No.2)	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	3 Nov 2004	Third Report of the Procedure Committee — Election of an MP to More Than One Seat — Brian Haw's Protest Camp	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	3 Nov 2004	Members' Allowances	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	2 Nov 2004	Children Bill [Lords] — New Clause 12 — Reasonable punishment	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	2 Nov 2004	Children Bill [Lords] — New Clause 12 — Reasonable punishment	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	27 Oct 2004	New Clause 10 — Victims of persons subject to hospital order with restriction order: representations — Clause 22 — Procedure for determining fitness to plead: England and Wales	both	no	absent
Commons	27 Oct 2004	New Clause 10 — Victims of persons subject to hospital order with restriction order: representations — Clause 16 — Higher fixed penalty for repeated road traffic offences	tellaye	aye	agrees with policy
Commons	26 Oct 2004	Carry-over of Bills	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	26 Oct 2004	Programming of Bills	tellno	no	agrees with policy
Commons	26 Oct 2004	Programming of Bills	tellaye	aye	agrees with policy
Commons	26 Oct 2004	Programming of Bills	tellaye	aye	agrees with policy
Commons	26 Oct 2004	Programming of Bills	tellaye	aye	agrees with policy
Commons	15 Sep 2004	Hunting Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	15 Sep 2004	Hunting Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	15 Sep 2004	Hunting Bill — Timetable	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	15 Sep 2004	Hunting Bill (Procedure)	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	15 Sep 2004	Hunting Bill (Procedure)	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	15 Sep 2004	Hunting Bill (Procedure)	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	14 Sep 2004	Older Women	tellno	no	agrees with policy
Commons	14 Sep 2004	Older Women	tellaye	aye	agrees with policy
Commons	14 Sep 2004	Higher Education	tellaye	aye	agrees with policy
Commons	19 Jul 2004	New Clause 1 — Infection control standards — Clause 5 — Co-operation	tellaye	aye	agrees with policy
Commons	25 May 2004	Gender Recognition Bill [Lords] — Religion	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	25 Feb 2004	School Admissions (Prohibition of Religious Discrimination)	Majority	tellaye	disagrees with policy
Commons	10 Feb 2004	Local Taxation	tellaye	aye	agrees with policy
Commons	19 Nov 2003	Health and Social Care (Community Health and Standards) Bill — Clause 15 — Private Health Care	tellno	no	agrees with policy
Commons	18 Nov 2003	Criminal Justice Bill — New Clause	tellno	no	agrees with policy
Commons	30 Oct 2003	Pay for Chairmen of Select Committees — PAY FOR CHAIRMEN OF SELECT COMMITTEES (No. 2)	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	30 Oct 2003	Pay for Chairmen of Select Committees	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	28 Oct 2003	Waste and Emissions Trading Bill [Lords] — New Clause 5 — Environmental impact assessment of incineration	tellaye	aye	agrees with policy
Commons	14 Jul 2003	Communications Bill — Clause 340 — Modification of Disqualification Provisions	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	9 Jul 2003	Hunting Bill — New Clause 1 — Compensation	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	8 Jul 2003	Health and Social Care (Community Health and Standards) Bill — New Clause 9 — Foundation Patients' Fora	tellaye	aye	agrees with policy
Commons	1 Jul 2003	Hunting Bill (Programme) (No. 4)	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	30 Jun 2003	Hunting Bill — New Clause 14 — Registration in Respect of Hunting of Mink	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	30 Jun 2003	Hunting Bill — New Clause 11 — Registration in Respect of Hunting of Foxes	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	30 Jun 2003	Hunting Bill — New Clause 6 — Use of Dogs Below Ground (No. 2)	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	19 Mar 2003	Community Care (Delayed Discharges Etc.) Bill — After Clause 3	tellno	no	agrees with policy
Commons	16 Dec 2002	Hunting Bill (Programme)	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	16 Dec 2002	Hunting Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	16 Dec 2002	Hunting Bill	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	4 Dec 2002	Criminal Justice Bill	tellno	no	agrees with policy
Commons	21 Nov 2002	Common Fisheries Policy	tellaye	aye	agrees with policy
Commons	29 Oct 2002	Programming	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	29 Oct 2002	Permanent Arrangements for Westminster Hall, Thursday Sittings and Standing Committees	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	29 Oct 2002	Start Sittings of the House of Commons at 11.30 am rather than 14.30 on Tuesdays	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	29 Oct 2002	New Provision for Earlier Sittings on Wednesdays, and for Thursdays and Fridays	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	29 Oct 2002	New Provision for Earlier Sittings on Wednesdays, and for Thursdays and Fridays	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	22 Oct 2002	Nuclear Power — Not competitive — rejected	tellaye	aye	agrees with policy
Commons	10 Jul 2002	Police Reform Bill [Lords] — Schedule 4 — Powers exercisable by police civilians	tellaye	aye	agrees with policy
Commons	12 Jun 2002	Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Bill — [2nd Allotted Day] — Clause 126 — Power to search for evidence	tellaye	aye	agrees with policy
Commons	12 Jun 2002	Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Bill — Do not penalise those who bring passengers to the UK without the necessary authority — rejected	tellaye	aye	agrees with policy
Commons	12 Jun 2002	Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Bill — [2nd Allotted Day] — New Clause 10 — Withholding and withdrawal of support	tellno	no	agrees with policy
Commons	10 Jun 2002	National Insurance Contributions Bill — [Sir Michael Lord in the Chair] — Clause 1 — Primary Class 1 contributions	tellaye	aye	agrees with policy
Commons	23 Apr 2002	Budget Resolutions and Economic Situation	tellno	no	agrees with policy
Commons	18 Mar 2002	Hunting with Dogs: Ban	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	18 Mar 2002	Hunting with Dogs: Hunting Under Licence	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	18 Mar 2002	Hunting with Dogs: Self-Supervision Scheme	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	26 Feb 2002	Proceeds of Crime Bill — [1st Allotted Day] — Clause 6 — Making of order	tellaye	aye	agrees with policy
Commons	18 Dec 2001	Facilities of the House	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	26 Nov 2001	Anti-terrorism, Crime and Security Bill — Third Reading	tellno	no	agrees with policy
Commons	26 Nov 2001	Anti-terrorism, Crime and Security Bill — Amendment to Clause 17 — Disclosure Powers	tellaye	aye	agrees with policy
Commons	26 Nov 2001	Anti-terrorism, Crime and Security Bill — Clauses 101 to 105, 120 to 122 — Communication Data	tellno	no	agrees with policy
Commons	26 Nov 2001	Anti-terrorism, Crime and Security Bill — Amendment to Clause 97 — Jurisdiction of MoD police	tellaye	aye	agrees with policy
Commons	26 Nov 2001	Anti-terrorism, Crime and Security Bill — Clauses 79 to 87 — Fissile Nuclear Material, Aviation Security	tellno	no	agrees with policy
Commons	26 Nov 2001	Anti-terrorism, Crime and Security Bill — Clause 38 — Religious Hatred	tellno	no	agrees with policy
Commons	5 Jul 2001	Parliamentary Pensions	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	5 Jul 2001	Members' Pay (Expression of Opinion)	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	5 Jul 2001	Members' Pay (Expression of Opinion)	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	5 Jul 2001	Members' Allowances, Insurance &c. — Members' Pay (Money Resolution)	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	28 Jun 2001	Business of the House	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	27 Jun 2001	Home Affairs and Constitution	tellaye	aye	agrees with policy
House	Date	Subject	Robert Smith	Paul Holmes	Rôle
no votes listed

Voting Comparison — Robert Smith MP, West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
to Paul Holmes MP, Chesterfield

Voting Differences

About the Project

The Whip on the Web

Help keep PublicWhip alive

Voting Comparison — Robert Smith MP, West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine to Paul Holmes MP, Chesterfield

Voting Differences

About the Project

The Whip on the Web

Help keep PublicWhip alive

Voting Comparison — Robert Smith MP, West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
to Paul Holmes MP, Chesterfield