Policy #230: "Identity cards — Against introduction"
Comparison to all MPs, Lords and MSPs
Colours represent political parties. If MPs, Lords or MSPs of a party vote the same way as the policy, then that party's colour appears by 'agree'. If they vote the opposite way, then it appears by 'disagree'.
MPs, Lords and MSPs are graded according to their agreement with the policy in terms of their votes.
If they always vote the same as the policy then their agreement is 100%; if they
always vote opposite to the policy votes, their agreement is 0%.
If they could never have voted at the same time as the policy, they are not listed.
| Lab partytype">Lab | dist9 lab topborder"> Angela Eagle | dist7 lab topborder">Lord Leitch | dist9 lab topborder">Baroness Thornton | dist5 non-affiliated topborder">Lord Elis-Thomas | dist1 ldem topborder">B Northover. | dist5 crossbench topborder">Lord Best | dist5 crossbench topborder">Lord Sentamu | dist1 con topborder"> Stephen Crabb | dist1 con topborder">L Herbert of S | dist5 con topborder rightborder">L Norton of L |
| Lab partytype2"> | dist9 lab"> Maria Eagle | dist7 lab">Lord Levy | dist9 lab"> Stephen Timms | dist2 non-affiliated">Lord Fowler | dist1 ldem">Lord Razzall | dist6 crossbench">Lord Birt | dist5 crossbench">Lord Skidelsky | dist4 con">Lord Crathorne | dist1 con">L Hodgson of A | dist4 con rightborder">Lord Patten |
| dist6 lab">B Adams of C | dist7 lab">Lord Eatwell | dist5 lab">B Liddell of C | dist9 lab">Lord Touhig | dist3 non-affiliated">Lord Hanningfield | dist1 ldem">Lord Redesdale | dist4 crossbench">V Brookeborough | dist5 crossbench">L St John of B | dist2 con">B Cumberlege. | dist1 con"> Philip Hollobone | dist4 con rightborder">L Patten of B |
| dist9 lab">Lord Adonis | dist8 lab"> Clive Efford | dist9 lab">Lord Lipsey | dist8 lab"> Jon Trickett | dist5 non-affiliated">Lord Heseltine | dist2 ldem">Lord Rennard | dist5 crossbench">L Browne of M | dist2 crossbench">Baroness Stern | dist2 con"> David Davies | dist1 con"> Adam Holloway | dist1 con rightborder"> Mike Penning |
| dist7 lab">Lord Alli | dist5 lab">L Evans of W | dist9 lab">L MacKenzie of C | dist9 lab">Lord Triesman | dist3 non-affiliated">Baroness Hoey | dist1 ldem">L Roberts of L | dist5 crossbench">Lord Burns | dist5 crossbench">L Stevens of K | dist1 con"> Philip Davies | dist3 con">Baroness Hooper | dist1 con rightborder"> John Penrose |
| dist9 lab">Baroness Amos | dist9 lab">L Falconer of T | dist9 lab"> Khalid Mahmood | dist9 lab">Lord Tunnicliffe | dist3 non-affiliated">Lord Inglewood | dist1 ldem">B Scott of N | dist5 crossbench">L Butler of B | dist5 crossbench">Lord Turnbull | dist1 con"> David Davis | dist1 con">L Howard of L | dist2 con rightborder">Lord Pickles |
| dist8 lab">L Anderson of S | dist9 lab">L Faulkner of W | dist5 lab">B Mallalieu. | dist7 lab">Lord Turnberg | dist3 non-affiliated">Lord Kalms | dist1 ldem">Lord Stunell | dist5 crossbench">L Cameron of D | dist5 crossbench">L Turner of E | dist1 con">Lord de Mauley | dist3 con">L Howard of R | dist3 con rightborder"> Mark Pritchard |
| dist9 lab">Baroness Andrews | dist9 lab">Lord Filkin | dist9 lab">B Massey of Darwen | dist8 lab"> Derek Twigg | dist9 non-affiliated">L Mackenzie of F | dist1 ldem">Lord Taverne | dist5 crossbench">L Carey of C | dist5 crossbench">B Valentine. | dist1 con">Lord Deben | dist3 con">Earl Howe | dist5 con rightborder">Lord Rana |
| dist8 lab">B Armstrong of H | dist6 lab">L Foulkes of C | dist9 lab">Lord Maxton | dist9 lab">B Warwick of U | dist9 non-affiliated">Lord Mann | dist1 ldem">L Taylor of G | dist5 crossbench">L Carlile of B | dist5 crossbench">Lord Warner | dist1 con"> Jonathan Djanogly | dist2 con">L Howell of G | dist1 con rightborder">L Randall of U |
| dist9 lab">Lord Bach | dist9 lab">Baroness Gale | dist9 lab">Lord McAvoy | dist5 lab">L Watson of I | dist9 non-affiliated">L McFall of A | dist1 ldem">L Thomas of G | dist5 crossbench">Lord Chartres | dist4 crossbench">Viscount Waverley | dist1 con"> James Duddridge | dist1 con"> Jeremy Hunt | dist3 con rightborder">Baroness Rawlings |
| dist9 lab">L Bassam of B | dist8 lab"> Barry Gardiner | dist9 lab"> Steve McCabe | dist9 lab">L Watson of W | dist5 non-affiliated">The D of Norfolk. | dist2 ldem">Viscount Thurso | dist4 crossbench">Baroness Cox | dist5 crossbench">L Wilson of D | dist1 con"> Iain Duncan Smith | dist1 con">L Hunt of W | dist2 con rightborder"> John Redwood |
| dist9 lab"> Margaret Beckett | dist7 lab">Lord Giddens | dist9 lab"> Kerry McCarthy | dist9 lab">Lord Watts | dist1 non-affiliated">L Oakeshott of S | dist1 ldem">Lord Tope | dist1 crossbench">V Craigavon. | dist5 crossbench">Lord Woolf | dist3 con">The E of Dundee. | dist1 con">L Jackson of P | dist2 con rightborder">Lord Risby |
| dist8 lab"> Hilary Benn | dist9 lab">Baroness Golding | dist9 lab"> Siobhain McDonagh | dist9 lab">Baroness Whitaker | dist7 non-affiliated">Lord Paul | dist1 ldem">L Wallace of S | dist2 crossbench">L Craig of R | dist3 crossbench">B Young of Hornsey | dist1 con"> Philip Dunne | dist2 con"> Bernard Jenkin | dist2 con rightborder">Lord Robathan |
| dist6 lab">Lord Berkeley | dist9 lab">Lord Goldsmith | dist4 lab">J McDonnell. | dist9 lab"> Alan Whitehead | dist5 non-affiliated">L Pearson of R | dist1 ldem">Baroness Walmsley | dist5 crossbench">L Currie of M | Conservative Independent partytype">Conservative Independent | dist1 con">Viscount Eccles | dist1 con"> David Jones | dist1 con rightborder">L Robertson. |
| dist9 lab"> Clive Betts | dist9 lab">Baroness Goudie | dist9 lab"> Pat McFadden | dist9 lab">Lord Whitty | dist6 non-affiliated">L Smith of F | dist1 ldem">L Willis of K | dist1 crossbench">B D'Souza. | Conservative Independent partytype2"> | dist1 con">B Eccles of M | dist1 con">Lord Jopling | dist2 con rightborder"> Andrew Rosindell |
| dist9 lab">B Billingham. | dist7 lab">Lord Grantchester | dist9 lab">B McIntosh of H | dist9 lab">Lord Wills | dist7 non-affiliated">L Stone of B | Judge partytype">Judge | dist4 crossbench">Baroness Deech | dist5 conservativeindependent">L Stevens of L | dist1 con"> Tobias Ellwood | dist1 con"> Daniel Kawczynski | dist3 con rightborder">Lord Saatchi |
| dist8 lab">Lord Blunkett | dist9 lab"> Nia Griffith | dist9 lab"> Ed Miliband | dist7 lab">Lord Winston | dist8 non-affiliated">B Stuart of E | Judge partytype2"> | dist1 crossbench">Lord Dykes | Con partytype">Con | dist1 con"> Nigel Evans | dist4 con">L King of B | dist1 con rightborder">Baroness Seccombe |
| dist5 lab">Lord Boateng | dist9 lab">L Griffiths of B | dist8 lab">Lord Mitchell | dist8 lab"> Rosie Winterton | dist3 non-affiliated">L Taylor of W | dist7 judge">B Clark of Calton | dist5 crossbench">Lord Eames | Con partytype2"> | dist1 con"> David Evennett | dist2 con">Lord Kirkham | dist1 con rightborder"> Andrew Selous |
| dist7 lab">Lord Bradley | dist9 lab">Lord Grocott | dist9 lab"> Jessica Morden | dist7 lab">L Young of N | dist9 non-affiliated">Lord Truscott | dist5 judge">B Hale of Richmond | dist1 crossbench">The E of Erroll. | dist1 con"> Adam Afriyie | dist1 con"> Michael Fabricant | dist1 con"> Greg Knight | dist1 con rightborder"> Grant Shapps |
| dist9 lab"> Ben Bradshaw | dist9 lab"> Andrew Gwynne | dist8 lab">Lord Morgan | dist5 lab">B Young of O | dist1 non-affiliated">Lord Tyrie | dist5 judge">Lord Hardie | dist1 crossbench">B Falkner of M | dist1 con">B Anelay of S | dist3 con">Lord Flight | dist1 con"> Eleanor Laing | dist4 con rightborder">B Shephard of N |
| dist8 lab">Lord Bragg | dist9 lab">Lord Hain | dist7 lab">B Morgan of Huyton | Workers Party partytype">Workers Party | dist7 non-affiliated">Baroness Uddin | dist5 judge">L Hope of C | dist8 crossbench">L Field of B | dist1 con">L Arbuthnot of E | dist1 con">Baroness Fookes | dist1 con">L Lamont of L | dist5 con rightborder">T of Shrewsbury |
| dist9 lab"> Kevin Brennan | dist8 lab"> Fabian Hamilton | dist9 lab">B Morris of Y | Workers Party partytype2"> | dist5 non-affiliated">L Willoughby de . | dist5 judge">Lord Mance | dist5 crossbench">B Finlay of L | dist4 con">The Earl of Arran | dist1 con">L Forsyth of D | dist1 con">L Lancaster of K | dist2 con rightborder">L Soames of F |
| dist9 lab">L Brooke of A | dist9 lab"> Harriet Harman | dist8 lab">L Murphy of T | dist2 workersparty"> George Galloway | LDem partytype">LDem | dist5 judge">L Phillips of W | dist4 crossbench">Lord Freyberg | dist3 con">Viscount Astor | dist2 con"> Liam Fox | dist2 con">Lord Lansley | dist5 con rightborder">L Sterling of P |
| dist9 lab">L Browne of L | dist9 lab">L Harris of H | dist5 lab">Lord Parekh | UUP partytype">UUP | LDem partytype2"> | Independent Labour partytype">Independent Labour | dist4 crossbench">Baroness Fritchie | dist1 con">Earl Attlee | dist5 con">Lord Framlingham | dist1 con"> Edward Leigh | dist1 con rightborder">Lord Strathclyde |
| dist9 lab"> Lyn Brown | dist6 lab">Lord Haskel | dist9 lab">B Pitkeathley. | UUP partytype2"> | dist1 ldem">Lord Addington | Independent Labour partytype2"> | dist7 crossbench">Lord Grabiner | dist2 con"> Richard Bacon | dist1 con"> Mark Francois | dist1 con"> Julian Lewis | dist2 con rightborder"> Gary Streeter |
| dist9 lab"> Chris Bryant | dist7 lab"> John Healey | dist7 lab">L Ponsonby of S | dist4 uup">Lord Rogan | dist3 ldem">Lord Alderdice | dist6 independentlabour">B Blackstone. | dist5 crossbench">B Greenfield. | dist3 con">L Baker of D | dist4 con"> Roger Gale | dist1 con">I Liddell-Graing. | dist1 con rightborder"> Graham Stuart |
| dist7 lab"> Karen Buck | dist9 lab"> Mark Hendrick | dist8 lab">Lord Prescott | SPK partytype">SPK | dist3 ldem">L Allan of H | Independent Ulster Unionist partytype">Independent Ulster Unionist | dist1 crossbench">Lord Greenway | dist1 con">L Barker of B | dist1 con">B Gardner of P | dist2 con">Lord Lilley | dist1 con rightborder"> Desmond Swayne |
| dist9 lab"> Dawn Butler | dist9 lab"> Meg Hillier | dist8 lab">B Primarolo. | SPK partytype2"> | dist3 ldem">Lord Alliance | Independent Ulster Unionist partytype2"> | dist5 crossbench">L Hannay of C | dist2 con"> John Baron | dist1 con">Lord Garnier | dist2 con">The E of Lindsay. | dist1 con rightborder">Lord Swire |
| dist9 lab"> Liam Byrne | dist8 lab"> Margaret Hodge | dist8 lab">Baroness Prosser | dist8 spk"> Lindsay Hoyle | dist1 ldem">Baroness Barker | dist5 independentulsterunionist">L Maginnis of D | dist6 crossbench">L Harries of P | dist1 con">Lord Bellingham | dist1 con">Lord Geddes | dist3 con">The E of Liverpool. | dist1 con rightborder"> Robert Syms |
| dist9 lab">L Campbell-Savou. | dist9 lab"> Sharon Hodgson | dist9 lab">B Ramsay of C | SNP partytype">SNP | dist1 ldem">Lord Beith | Independent Social Democrat partytype">Independent Social Democrat | dist5 crossbench">L Hastings of S | dist1 con">Lord Benyon | dist1 con"> Nick Gibb | dist3 con">T of Lothian | dist3 con rightborder">Lord Trefgarne |
| dist8 lab"> Alan Campbell | dist6 lab">Lord Hollick | dist8 lab">L Reid of C | SNP partytype2"> | dist1 ldem">B Bonham-Car of Y | Independent Social Democrat partytype2"> | dist9 crossbench">Baroness Hayman | dist2 con"> Paul Beresford | dist4 con">Lord Glenarthur | dist1 con"> Tim Loughton | dist3 con rightborder">V Trenchard. |
| dist9 lab">L Carter of C | dist9 lab"> George Howarth | dist5 lab">L Robertson of P | dist1 snp"> Angus Robertson | dist1 ldem">Lord Bradshaw | dist4 independentsocialdemocrat">Lord Owen | dist5 crossbench">Lord Hoffmann | dist3 con">Lord Blackwell | dist3 con"> Robert Goodwill | dist2 con">Lord Lucas | dist3 con rightborder">Lord Tugendhat |
| dist7 lab">Viscount Chandos | dist9 lab">L Howarth of N | dist9 lab">Lord Rooker | dist1 snp"> Stewart Hosie | dist1 ldem">L Bruce of B | Independent partytype">Independent | dist4 crossbench">Baroness Hogg | dist1 con">Lord Blencathra | dist4 con">Viscount Goschen | dist3 con">Lord Mancroft | dist2 con rightborder">L Vaizey of D |
| dist9 lab">Lord Christopher | dist9 lab">B Hughes of S | dist9 lab">Lord Rosser | dist2 snp"> Pete Wishart | dist1 ldem">B Burt of Solihull | Independent partytype2"> | dist7 crossbench">B Howarth of B | dist1 con"> Crispin Blunt | dist1 con"> Michael Gove | dist3 con">Lord Marlesford | dist1 con rightborder"> Shailesh Vara |
| dist9 lab">L Clarke of H | dist9 lab">L Hunt of K | dist5 lab">Lord Rowlands | SF partytype">SF | dist1 ldem">L Campbell of P | dist5 independent"> Diane Abbott | dist5 crossbench">L Kerr of K | dist4 con">B Bottomley of N | dist2 con"> James Gray | dist4 con">L Maude of H | dist1 con rightborder"> Theresa Villiers |
| dist5 lab">B Clark of K | dist8 lab">L Hutton of F | dist9 lab">B Royall of B | SF partytype2"> | dist1 ldem">A Carmichael. | dist8 independent"> Nick Brown | dist6 crossbench">Lord Kilclooney | dist1 con"> Peter Bottomley | dist1 con"> Chris Grayling | dist1 con"> Theresa May | dist1 con rightborder">Lord Wakeham |
| dist8 lab">L Clark of W | dist9 lab">L Irvine of L | dist7 lab">Lord Sawyer | dist5 sf">M Gildernew. | dist1 ldem">L Clement-Jones. | dist3 independent"> Jeremy Corbyn | dist5 crossbench">Lord Laming | dist2 con"> Graham Brady | dist1 con"> Damian Green | dist3 con">L McColl of D | dist5 con rightborder">L Waldegrave of N |
| dist9 lab">Lord Coaker | dist9 lab">B Jay of P | dist9 lab">B Scotland of A | PC partytype">PC | dist2 ldem"> Edward Davey | dist7 independent"> Geraint Davies | dist5 crossbench">L Levene of P | dist2 con">V Bridgeman. | dist5 con">L Griffiths of F | dist1 con">B McIntosh of P | dist1 con rightborder"> Charles Walker |
| dist7 lab">B Cohen of Pimlico | dist9 lab"> Diana R. Johnson | dist9 lab"> Barry Sheerman | PC partytype2"> | dist1 ldem">Lord Dholakia | dist2 independent"> Angus MacNeil | dist9 crossbench">B Morgan of D | dist1 con">Baroness Browning | dist1 con">L Hague of R | dist1 con">Lord McLoughlin | dist1 con rightborder"> Ben Wallace |
| dist8 lab"> Yvette Cooper | dist9 lab">Lord Jones | dist9 lab"> Andrew Slaughter | dist2 pc"> Hywel Williams | dist1 ldem"> Tim Farron | DUP partytype">DUP | dist8 crossbench">Baroness Murphy | dist3 con">Baroness Buscombe | dist3 con">Viscount Hailsham | dist1 con"> Maria Miller | dist2 con rightborder"> John Whittingdale |
| dist8 lab">Baroness Corston | dist9 lab"> Kevan Jones | dist8 lab">B Smith of B | Non-affiliated partytype">Non-affiliated | dist1 ldem">B Featherstone. | DUP partytype2"> | dist4 crossbench">B Neuberger. | dist1 con">The E of Caithness. | dist3 con">L Hamilton of E | dist2 con"> Andrew Mitchell | dist2 con rightborder"> Bill Wiggin |
| dist8 lab">Baroness Crawley | dist9 lab">Lord Jordan | dist5 lab">B Smith of G | Non-affiliated partytype2"> | dist1 ldem">L Foster of B | dist3 dup"> Gregory Campbell | dist5 crossbench">B O'Neil of B | dist2 con">L Cameron of C | dist1 con">L Hammond of R | dist2 con">The D of Montrose. | dist2 con rightborder">Lord Willetts |
| dist7 lab"> Jon Cruddas | dist5 lab">K [Missing last . | dist7 lab">Lord Snape | dist5 non-affiliated">L Archer of W | dist2 ldem">The E of Glasgow. | dist3 dup">L Dodds of D | dist4 crossbench">Lord Patel | dist1 con"> Bill Cash | dist1 con"> Stephen Hammond | dist1 con">B Morris of Bolton | dist1 con rightborder"> Jeremy Wright |
| dist7 lab"> John Cryer | dist9 lab"> Barbara Keeley | dist8 lab"> John Spellar | dist9 non-affiliated">B Ashton of U | dist1 ldem">Baroness Hamwee | dist4 dup">J Donaldson. | dist1 crossbench">Earl Peel | dist4 con">Lord Chadlington | dist3 con"> Greg Hands | dist3 con">Lord Moynihan | dist1 con rightborder">L Young of C |
| dist7 lab">L Cunningham of F | dist1 lab">B Kennedy of T | dist8 lab"> Graham Stringer | dist9 non-affiliated">L Austin of D | dist1 ldem">B Harris of R | dist1 dup">L McCrea of M | dist7 crossbench">L Powell of B | dist2 con"> Christopher Chope | dist1 con"> Mark Harper | dist1 con"> David Mundell | dist1 topborder rightborder"> |
| dist9 lab"> Wayne David | dist7 lab">B King of B | dist9 lab">B Symons of V | dist5 non-affiliated">L Black of C | dist1 ldem">Baroness Kramer | dist1 dup"> Sammy Wilson | dist5 crossbench">Baroness Prashar | dist2 con">L Clarke of N | dist5 con">L Harris of P | dist1 con"> Andrew Murrison | |
| dist9 lab">L Davies of O | dist7 lab">Lord Kinnock | dist9 lab"> Mark Tami | dist1 non-affiliated">L Boswell of A | dist3 ldem">Baroness Ludford | Crossbench partytype">Crossbench | dist5 crossbench">L Rees of L | dist1 con"> Greg Clark | dist5 con">Lord Haselhurst | dist3 con">Lord Naseby | |
| dist7 lab">Lord Donoughue | dist8 lab">L Knight of W | dist7 lab">B Taylor of Bolton | dist1 non-affiliated">Lord Bowness | dist1 ldem">Lord McNally | Crossbench partytype2"> | dist5 crossbench">The E of Rosslyn. | dist1 con">G Clifton-Brown | dist1 con"> John Hayes | dist5 con">B Nicholson of W | |
| dist9 lab">Lord Drayson | dist9 lab"> David Lammy | dist8 lab"> Gareth Thomas | dist7 non-affiliated">Lord Brennan | dist1 ldem">B Miller of C | dist5 crossbench">Lord Adebowale | dist5 crossbench">The E of Sandwich. | dist2 con">The E of Courtown. | dist1 con"> Oliver Heald | dist1 con">Baroness Noakes | |
| dist8 lab bottomborder">Lord Dubs | dist9 lab bottomborder">Lord Layard | dist9 lab bottomborder"> Emily Thornberry | dist8 non-affiliated bottomborder">Lord Desai | dist2 ldem bottomborder">Lord Newby | dist4 crossbench bottomborder">L Alton of L | dist5 crossbench bottomborder">L Saville of N | dist1 con bottomborder"> Geoffrey Cox | dist2 con bottomborder">Lord Henley | dist4 con bottomborder">Lord Northbrook |