Welfare Reform and Pensions Bill — Earnings of workers supplied by service companies etc: Northern Ireland — 3 Nov 1999

Government amendments (b) to (t) to the words so restored to the Bill agreed to.

Lords amendment: No.54, leave out clause 71.

Motion made, and Question put, That this House disagrees with the Lords in the said amendment:--[ Mr. Kevin Hughes. ]

The House divided: Ayes 337, Noes 124.

Historical Hansard | Online Hansard |

Public Whip is run as a free not-for-profit service. If you'd like to support us, please consider switching your (UK) electricity and/or gas to Octopus Energy or tip us via Ko-Fi.

All Votes Cast - sorted by vote

MPs for which their vote in this division differed from the majority vote of their party are marked in red. Also shows which MPs were ministers at the time of this vote. You can also see every eligible MP including those who did not vote in this division.

Sort by: Name | Constituency | Party | Vote

Name	Constituency	Party	Vote
Diane Abbott	Hackney North and Stoke Newington	Lab (minister)	aye
Mrs Irene Adams	Paisley North	Lab (minister)	aye
Nick Ainger	Carmarthen West and South Pembrokeshire	Lab	aye
Bob Ainsworth	Coventry North East	Lab (minister)	tellaye
Douglas Alexander	Paisley South	Lab	aye
Graham Allen	Nottingham North	Lab (minister)	tellaye
Mr Donald Anderson	Swansea East	Lab (minister)	aye
Janet Anderson	Rossendale and Darwen	Lab (minister)	aye
Hilary Armstrong	North West Durham	Lab (minister)	aye
Ms Candy Atherton	Falmouth and Camborne	Lab	aye
John Austin	Erith and Thamesmead	Lab	aye
Mr Harry Barnes	North East Derbyshire	Lab	aye
Kevin Barron	Rother Valley	Lab (minister)	aye
John Battle	Leeds West	Lab (minister)	aye
Hugh Bayley	City of York	Lab (minister)	aye
Mr Nigel Beard	Bexleyheath and Crayford	Lab	aye
Margaret Beckett	Derby South	Lab (minister)	aye
Stuart Bell	Middlesbrough	Lab (minister)	aye
Hilary Benn	Leeds Central	Lab	aye
Mr Tony Benn	Chesterfield	Lab	aye
Mr Andrew Bennett	Denton and Reddish	Lab	aye
Joe Benton	Bootle	Lab (minister)	aye
Mr Gerry Bermingham	St Helens South	Lab	aye
Roger Berry	Kingswood	Lab	aye
Mr Harold Best	Leeds North West	Lab	aye
Clive Betts	Sheffield, Attercliffe	Lab (minister)	aye
Liz Blackman	Erewash	Lab	aye
Hazel Blears	Salford	Lab	aye
Bob Blizzard	Waveney	Lab	aye
Mr Paul Boateng	Brent South	Lab (minister)	aye
David Borrow	South Ribble	Lab	aye
Mr Keith Bradley	Manchester, Withington	Lab (minister)	aye
Mr Peter Bradley	The Wrekin	Lab	aye
Ben Bradshaw	Exeter	Lab (minister)	aye
Nick Brown	Newcastle upon Tyne East and Wallsend	Lab (minister)	aye
Russell Brown	Dumfries	Lab	aye
Des Browne	Kilmarnock and Loudoun	Lab (minister)	aye
Karen Buck	Regent's Park and Kensington North	Lab (minister)	aye
Richard Burden	Birmingham, Northfield	Lab	aye
Colin Burgon	Elmet	Lab	aye
Mrs Christine Butler	Castle Point	Lab	aye
Alan Campbell	Tynemouth	Lab (minister)	aye
Mrs Anne Campbell	Cambridge	Lab	aye
Ronnie Campbell	Blyth Valley	Lab (minister)	aye
Mr Ivor Caplin	Hove	Lab	aye
Martin Caton	Gower	Lab (minister)	aye
Ian Cawsey	Brigg and Goole	Lab	aye
Ben Chapman	Wirral South	Lab	aye
David Chaytor	Bury North	Lab	aye
Ms Judith Church	Dagenham	Lab	aye
Michael Clapham	Barnsley West and Penistone	Lab	aye
Dr David Clark	South Shields	Lab	aye
Ms Helen Clark	Peterborough	Lab	aye
Dr Lynda Clark	Edinburgh Pentlands	Lab (minister)	aye
Paul Clark	Gillingham	Lab	aye
Charles Clarke	Norwich South	Lab (minister)	aye
Tom Clarke	Coatbridge and Chryston	Lab	aye
Mr Tony Clarke	Northampton South	Lab	aye
David Clelland	Tyne Bridge	Lab (minister)	aye
Ann Clwyd	Cynon Valley	Lab (minister)	aye
Vernon Coaker	Gedling	Lab	aye
Ann Coffey	Stockport	Lab	aye
Mr Iain Coleman	Hammersmith and Fulham	Lab	aye
Mr Tony Colman	Putney	Lab	aye
Robin Cook	Livingston	Lab (minister)	aye
Yvette Cooper	Pontefract and Castleford	Lab (minister)	aye
Mr Robin Corbett	Birmingham, Erdington	Lab (minister)	aye
Jeremy Corbyn	Islington North	Lab	aye
Ms Jean Corston	Bristol East	Lab	aye
Jim Cousins	Newcastle upon Tyne Central	Lab	aye
Professor Ross Cranston	Dudley North	Lab (minister)	aye
David Crausby	Bolton North East	Lab (minister)	aye
John Cryer	Hornchurch	Lab	aye
John Cummings	Easington	Lab	aye
Mr Lawrence Cunliffe	Leigh	Lab	aye
Dr Jack Cunningham	Copeland	Lab	aye
Jim Cunningham	Coventry South	Lab (minister)	aye
Claire Curtis-Thomas	Crosby	Lab	aye
Mr Tam Dalyell	Linlithgow	Lab	aye
Alistair Darling	Edinburgh Central	Lab (minister)	aye
Mr Keith Darvill	Upminster	Lab	aye
Mrs Valerie Davey	Bristol West	Lab	aye
Ian Davidson	Glasgow Pollok	Lab (minister)	aye
Mr Denzil Davies	Llanelli	Lab	aye
Geraint Davies	Croydon Central	Lab (minister)	aye
Mr Hilton Dawson	Lancaster and Wyre	Lab	aye
John Denham	Southampton, Itchen	Lab (minister)	aye
Andrew Dismore	Hendon	Lab	aye
Jim Dobbin	Heywood and Middleton	Lab	aye
Brian H Donohoe	Cunninghame South	Lab (minister)	aye
Frank Doran	Aberdeen Central	Lab	aye
Jim Dowd	Lewisham West	Lab (minister)	aye
David Drew	Stroud	Lab (minister)	aye
Angela Eagle	Wallasey	Lab (minister)	aye
Maria Eagle	Liverpool, Garston	Lab (minister)	aye
Mr Huw Edwards	Monmouth	Lab	aye
Clive Efford	Eltham	Lab (minister)	aye
Louise Ellman	Liverpool, Riverside	Lab	aye
Jeff Ennis	Barnsley East and Mexborough	Lab	aye
Bill Etherington	Sunderland North	Lab	aye
Frank Field	Birkenhead	Lab	aye
Mark Fisher	Stoke-on-Trent Central	Lab	aye
Ms Lorna Fitzsimons	Rochdale	Lab	aye
Caroline Flint	Don Valley	Lab (minister)	aye
Paul Flynn	Newport West	Lab	aye
Barbara Follett	Stevenage	Lab	aye
Mr Derek Foster	Bishop Auckland	Lab (minister)	aye
Michael Foster	Worcester	Lab	aye
Michael Jabez Foster	Hastings and Rye	Lab	aye
Mr George Foulkes	Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley	Lab (minister)	aye
Mike Gapes	Ilford South	Lab	aye
Bruce George	Walsall South	Lab	aye
Neil Gerrard	Walthamstow	Lab	aye
Ian Gibson	Norwich North	Lab	aye
Linda Gilroy	Plymouth, Sutton	Lab	aye
Roger Godsiff	Birmingham, Sparkbrook and Small Heath	Lab	aye
Paul Goggins	Wythenshawe and Sale East	Lab	aye
Mrs Llin Golding	Newcastle-under-Lyme	Lab	aye
Mrs Eileen Gordon	Romford	Lab	aye
Ms Jane Griffiths	Reading East	Lab	aye
Nigel Griffiths	Edinburgh South	Lab	aye
Mr Win Griffiths	Bridgend	Lab	aye
Mr Bruce Grocott	Telford	Lab	aye
John Grogan	Selby	Lab (minister)	aye
Mr John Gunnell	Morley and Rothwell	Lab	aye
Peter Hain	Neath	Lab (minister)	aye
Mike Hall	Weaver Vale	Lab (minister)	aye
Patrick Hall	Bedford	Lab	aye
Fabian Hamilton	Leeds North East	Lab (minister)	aye
David Hanson	Delyn	Lab (minister)	aye
Harriet Harman	Camberwell and Peckham	Lab (minister)	aye
Sylvia Heal	Halesowen and Rowley Regis	whilst Lab	aye
John Healey	Wentworth	Lab (minister)	aye
Doug Henderson	Newcastle upon Tyne North	Lab	aye
Mr Ivan Henderson	Harwich	Lab	aye
Stephen Hepburn	Jarrow	Lab (minister)	aye
John Heppell	Nottingham East	Lab	aye
Stephen Hesford	Wirral West	Lab	aye
Keith Hill	Streatham	Lab (minister)	aye
Mr David Hinchliffe	Wakefield	Lab	aye
Margaret Hodge	Barking	Lab (minister)	aye
Kate Hoey	Vauxhall	Lab (minister)	aye
Jimmy Hood	Clydesdale	Lab (minister)	aye
Phil Hope	Corby	Lab	aye
Kelvin Hopkins	Luton North	Lab	aye
Mr Alan Howarth	Newport East	Lab (minister)	aye
George Howarth	Knowsley North and Sefton East	Lab (minister)	aye
Lindsay Hoyle	Chorley	Lab (minister)	aye
Beverley Hughes	Stretford and Urmston	Lab (minister)	aye
Mr Kevin Hughes	Doncaster North	Lab (minister)	aye
Joan Humble	Blackpool North and Fleetwood	Lab	aye
Mr Alan Hurst	Braintree	Lab	aye
John Hutton	Barrow and Furness	Lab (minister)	aye
Brian Iddon	Bolton South East	Lab	aye
Eric Illsley	Barnsley Central	Lab	aye
Adam Ingram	East Kilbride	Lab (minister)	aye
Mrs Helen Jackson	Sheffield, Hillsborough	Lab	aye
Mr David Jamieson	Plymouth, Devonport	Lab (minister)	aye
Brian Jenkins	Tamworth	Lab	aye
Miss Melanie Johnson	Welwyn Hatfield	Lab (minister)	aye
Mr Barry Jones	Alyn and Deeside	Lab	aye
Fiona Jones	Newark	Lab	aye
Helen Jones	Warrington North	Lab (minister)	aye
Mr Jon Owen Jones	Cardiff Central	Lab	aye
Martyn Jones	Clwyd South	Lab	aye
Tessa Jowell	Dulwich and West Norwood	Lab (minister)	aye
Gerald Kaufman	Manchester, Gorton	Lab (minister)	aye
Sally Keeble	Northampton North	Lab	aye
Alan Keen	Feltham and Heston	Lab	aye
Ruth Kelly	Bolton West	Lab	aye
Fraser Kemp	Houghton and Washington East	Lab	aye
Jane Kennedy	Liverpool, Wavertree	Lab (minister)	aye
Piara S Khabra	Ealing, Southall	Lab	aye
David Kidney	Stafford	Lab	aye
Mr Andy King	Rugby and Kenilworth	Lab	aye
Ms Oona King	Bethnal Green and Bow	Lab (minister)	aye
Ashok Kumar	Middlesbrough South and East Cleveland	Lab	aye
Stephen Ladyman	South Thanet	Lab	aye
Mrs Jackie Lawrence	Preseli Pembrokeshire	Lab	aye
Bob Laxton	Derby North	Lab	aye
David Lepper	Brighton, Pavilion	Lab	aye
Chris Leslie	Shipley	Lab	aye
Tom Levitt	High Peak	Lab	aye
Ivan Lewis	Bury South	Lab (minister)	aye
Mr Terry Lewis	Worsley	Lab	aye
Martin Linton	Battersea	Lab	aye
Tony Lloyd	Manchester Central	Lab	aye
Mr David Lock	Wyre Forest	Lab (minister)	aye
Mr Calum MacDonald	Na h-Eileanan an Iar	Lab	aye
Andrew MacKinlay	Thurrock	Lab	aye
Denis MacShane	Rotherham	Lab	aye
Fiona Mactaggart	Slough	Lab	aye
Judy Mallaber	Amber Valley	Lab	aye
Gordon Marsden	Blackpool South	Lab (minister)	aye
Mr Paul Marsden	Shrewsbury and Atcham	Lab	aye
David Marshall	Glasgow Shettleston	Lab	aye
Dr Jim Marshall	Leicester South	Lab	aye
Robert Marshall-Andrews	Medway	Lab	aye
Eric Martlew	Carlisle	Lab	aye
Mr John Maxton	Glasgow Cathcart	Lab	aye
Thomas McAvoy	Glasgow Rutherglen	Lab (minister)	aye
Steve McCabe	Birmingham, Hall Green	Lab (minister)	aye
Chris McCafferty	Calder Valley	Lab	aye
Ian McCartney	Makerfield	Lab (minister)	aye
Siobhain McDonagh	Mitcham and Morden	Lab	aye
John Martin McDonnell	Hayes and Harlington	Lab	aye
John McFall	Dumbarton	Lab (minister)	aye
Anne McGuire	Stirling	Lab (minister)	aye
Shona McIsaac	Cleethorpes	Lab	aye
Rosemary McKenna	Cumbernauld and Kilsyth	Lab	aye
Tony McNulty	Harrow East	Lab (minister)	aye
Mr Tony McWalter	Hemel Hempstead	Lab	aye
Michael Meacher	Oldham West and Royton	Lab (minister)	aye
Alan Meale	Mansfield	Lab (minister)	aye
Gillian Merron	Lincoln	Lab	aye
Mr Bill Michie	Sheffield, Heeley	Lab	aye
Alan Milburn	Darlington	Lab (minister)	aye
Andrew Miller	Ellesmere Port and Neston	Lab	aye
Laura Moffatt	Crawley	Lab	aye
Dr Lewis Moonie	Kirkcaldy	Lab (minister)	aye
Margaret Moran	Luton South	Lab	aye
Julie Morgan	Cardiff North	Lab	aye
Mr Rhodri Morgan	Cardiff West	Lab	aye
Elliot Morley	Scunthorpe	Lab (minister)	aye
Ms Estelle Morris	Birmingham, Yardley	Lab (minister)	aye
Sir John Morris	Aberavon	Lab	aye
Kali Mountford	Colne Valley	Lab	aye
George Mudie	Leeds East	Lab	aye
Chris Mullin	Sunderland South	Lab (minister)	aye
Denis Murphy	Wansbeck	Lab	aye
Jim Murphy	East Renfrewshire	Lab	aye
Paul Murphy	Torfaen	Lab (minister)	aye
Doug Naysmith	Bristol North West	Lab	aye
Dan Norris	Wansdyke	Lab	aye
Mr Bill O'Brien	Normanton	Lab	aye
Mike O'Brien	North Warwickshire	Lab (minister)	aye
Edward O'Hara	Knowsley South	Lab	aye
Mr Martin O'Neill	Ochil	Lab (minister)	aye
Bill Olner	Nuneaton	Lab	aye
Mrs Diana Organ	Forest of Dean	Lab	aye
Sandra Osborne	Ayr	Lab (minister)	aye
Nick Palmer	Broxtowe	Lab	aye
Ian Pearson	Dudley South	Lab	aye
Mr Tom Pendry	Stalybridge and Hyde	Lab	aye
Ms Linda Perham	Ilford North	Lab	aye
Mr Colin Pickthall	West Lancashire	Lab	aye
Mr Peter Pike	Burnley	Lab	aye
James Plaskitt	Warwick and Leamington	Lab	aye
Mr Kerry Pollard	St Albans	Lab	aye
Mr Chris Pond	Gravesham	Lab	aye
Greg Pope	Hyndburn	Lab (minister)	aye
Steve Pound	Ealing North	Lab (minister)	aye
Mr Raymond Powell	Ogmore	Lab	aye
Bridget Prentice	Lewisham East	Lab	aye
Gordon Prentice	Pendle	Lab	aye
Dawn Primarolo	Bristol South	Lab (minister)	aye
Gwyn Prosser	Dover	Lab	aye
Ken Purchase	Wolverhampton North East	Lab	aye
Mr Lawrie Quinn	Scarborough and Whitby	Lab	aye
Mr Giles Radice	North Durham	Lab (minister)	aye
Bill Rammell	Harlow	Lab	aye
Andy Reed	Loughborough	Lab	aye
Mrs Barbara Roche	Hornsey and Wood Green	Lab (minister)	aye
Mr Jeff Rooker	Birmingham, Perry Barr	Lab (minister)	aye
Terry Rooney	Bradford North	Lab	aye
Mr Ernie Ross	Dundee West	Lab	aye
Mr Ted Rowlands	Merthyr Tydfil and Rhymney	Lab (minister)	aye
Frank Roy	Motherwell and Wishaw	Lab	aye
Chris Ruane	Vale of Clwyd	Lab (minister)	aye
Joan Ruddock	Lewisham, Deptford	Lab	aye
Joan Ryan	Enfield North	Lab	aye
Mohammad Sarwar	Glasgow Govan	Lab	aye
Mr Malcolm Savidge	Aberdeen North	Lab	aye
Mr Phil Sawford	Kettering	Lab	aye
Mr Brian Sedgemore	Hackney South and Shoreditch	Lab	aye
Jonathan R Shaw	Chatham and Aylesford	Lab	aye
Mr Robert Sheldon	Ashton-under-Lyne	Lab (minister)	aye
Ms Debra Shipley	Stourbridge	Lab	aye
Alan Simpson	Nottingham South	Lab	aye
Marsha Singh	Bradford West	Lab	aye
Dennis Skinner	Bolsover	Lab (minister)	aye
Andrew Smith	Oxford East	Lab (minister)	aye
Angela Smith	Basildon	Lab	aye
Mr Chris Smith	Islington South and Finsbury	Lab (minister)	aye
Geraldine Smith	Morecambe and Lunesdale	Lab	aye
Jacqui Smith	Redditch	Lab (minister)	aye
Mr Llew Smith	Blaenau Gwent	Lab	aye
Mr Peter Snape	West Bromwich East	Lab	aye
Mr Clive Soley	Ealing, Acton and Shepherd's Bush	Lab (minister)	aye
John Spellar	Warley	Lab (minister)	aye
Rachel Squire	Dunfermline West	Lab	aye
Phyllis Starkey	Milton Keynes South West	Lab	aye
Mr Gerry Steinberg	City of Durham	Lab	aye
Mr George Stevenson	Stoke-on-Trent South	Lab	aye
Mr David Stewart	Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber	Lab	aye
Ian Stewart	Eccles	Lab	aye
Mr Paul Stinchcombe	Wellingborough	Lab	aye
Howard Stoate	Dartford	Lab	aye
Gavin Strang	Edinburgh East and Musselburgh	Lab	aye
Graham Stringer	Manchester, Blackley	Lab (minister)	aye
Gisela Stuart	Birmingham, Edgbaston	Lab (minister)	aye
Gerry Sutcliffe	Bradford South	Lab (minister)	aye
Mrs Ann Taylor	Dewsbury	Lab (minister)	aye
Dari Taylor	Stockton South	Lab	aye
David Taylor	North West Leicestershire	Lab	aye
Mr Peter Temple-Morris	Leominster	whilst Lab	aye
Mr Gareth Thomas	Clwyd West	Lab	aye
Gareth Thomas	Harrow West	Lab (minister)	aye
Stephen Timms	East Ham	Lab (minister)	aye
Paddy Tipping	Sherwood	Lab (minister)	aye
Mark Todd	South Derbyshire	Lab	aye
Don Touhig	Islwyn	Lab	aye
Jon Trickett	Hemsworth	Lab	aye
Mr Dennis Turner	Wolverhampton South East	Lab (minister)	aye
Desmond Turner	Brighton, Kemptown	Lab	aye
Neil Turner	Wigan	Lab	aye
Derek Twigg	Halton	Lab	aye
Stephen Twigg	Enfield, Southgate	Lab	aye
Mr Bill Tynan	Hamilton South	Lab	aye
Keith Vaz	Leicester East	Lab (minister)	aye
Joan Walley	Stoke-on-Trent North	Lab (minister)	aye
Claire Ward	Watford	Lab	aye
Dave Watts	St Helens North	Lab (minister)	aye
Mr Brian White	North East Milton Keynes	Lab	aye
Alan Whitehead	Southampton, Test	Lab (minister)	aye
Malcolm Wicks	Croydon North	Lab (minister)	aye
Dr Alan Williams	Carmarthen East and Dinefwr	Lab	aye
Alan Williams	Swansea West	Lab	aye
Betty Williams	Conwy	Lab	aye
Michael Wills	North Swindon	Lab (minister)	aye
David Winnick	Walsall North	Lab (minister)	aye
Rosie Winterton	Doncaster Central	Lab	aye
Ms Audrey Wise	Preston	Lab	aye
Mike Wood	Batley and Spen	Lab	aye
Phil Woolas	Oldham East and Saddleworth	Lab	aye
Mr Tony Worthington	Clydebank and Milngavie	Lab	aye
Mr Jimmy Wray	Glasgow Baillieston	Lab	aye
Anthony D Wright	Great Yarmouth	Lab	aye
Derek Wyatt	Sittingbourne and Sheppey	Lab	aye
Mr Richard Allan	Sheffield, Hallam	LDem (front bench)	no
Sir David Amess	Southend West	Con (front bench)	no
James Arbuthnot	North East Hampshire	Con (front bench)	no
Peter Atkinson	Hexham	Con	no
Norman Baker	Lewes	LDem (front bench)	no
Mrs Jackie Ballard	Taunton	LDem	no
Mr Roy Beggs	East Antrim	UUP	no
Mr Martin Bell	Tatton	Independent	no
John Bercow	Buckingham	Con (front bench)	no
Crispin Blunt	Reigate	Con (front bench)	no
Tom Brake	Carshalton and Wallington	LDem (front bench)	no
Dr Peter Brand	Isle of Wight	LDem	no
Julian Brazier	Canterbury	Con (front bench)	no
Colin Breed	South East Cornwall	LDem	no
Mr Peter Brooke	Cities of London and Westminster	Con (front bench)	no
Angela Browning	Tiverton and Honiton	Con (front bench)	no
Malcolm Bruce	Gordon	LDem (front bench)	no
Mr John Burnett	Torridge and West Devon	LDem	no
Paul Burstow	Sutton and Cheam	LDem (front bench)	no
Menzies Campbell	North East Fife	LDem (front bench)	no
Dennis Canavan	Falkirk West	whilst Independent	no
Bill Cash	Stone	Con (front bench)	no
Mr David Chidgey	Eastleigh	LDem (front bench)	no
Christopher Chope	Christchurch	Con (front bench)	no
Kenneth Clarke	Rushcliffe	Con	no
Geoffrey Clifton-Brown	Cotswold	Con (front bench)	no
Mr Tim Collins	Westmorland and Lonsdale	Con	no
Mr Michael Colvin	Romsey	Con	no
Mr Brian Cotter	Weston-Super-Mare	LDem (front bench)	no
Mr James Cran	Beverley and Holderness	Con	no
Edward Davey	Kingston and Surbiton	LDem (front bench)	no
Quentin Davies	Grantham and Stamford	Con	no
Mr Stephen Day	Cheadle	Con	no
Nigel Evans	Ribble Valley	Con (front bench)	no
Margaret Ewing	Moray	SNP	no
Michael Fabricant	Lichfield	Con (front bench)	no
Mr Ronnie Fearn	Southport	LDem	no
Eric Forth	Bromley and Chislehurst	Con	no
Don Foster	Bath	LDem (front bench)	no
Christopher Fraser	Mid Dorset and North Poole	Con	no
Andrew George	St Ives	LDem (front bench)	no
Nick Gibb	Bognor Regis and Littlehampton	Con (front bench)	no
Mr Christopher Gill	Ludlow	Con	no
Mrs Teresa Gorman	Billericay	Con	no
Donald Gorrie	Edinburgh West	LDem	no
James Gray	North Wiltshire	Con (front bench)	no
Dominic Grieve	Beaconsfield	Con (front bench)	no
Philip Hammond	Runnymede and Weybridge	Con (front bench)	no
Mike Hancock	Portsmouth South	LDem (front bench)	no
Evan Harris	Oxford West and Abingdon	LDem	no
Nick Harvey	North Devon	LDem (front bench)	no
Mr Nick Hawkins	Surrey Heath	Con	no
Oliver Heald	North East Hertfordshire	Con (front bench)	no
David Heath	Somerton and Frome	LDem (front bench)	no
John Horam	Orpington	Con	no
Gerald Howarth	Aldershot	Con (front bench)	no
Simon Hughes	North Southwark and Bermondsey	LDem (front bench)	no
Michael Jack	Fylde	Con	no
Robert Jackson	Wantage	Con	no
Mr Nigel Jones	Cheltenham	LDem (front bench)	no
Paul Keetch	Hereford	LDem	no
Charles Kennedy	Ross, Skye and Inverness West	LDem (front bench)	no
Mr Tom King	Bridgwater	Con (front bench)	no
Mr Archy Kirkwood	Roxburgh and Berwickshire	LDem (front bench)	no
Eleanor Laing	Epping Forest	Con (front bench)	no
Jacqui Lait	Beckenham	Con	no
Andrew Lansley	South Cambridgeshire	Con (front bench)	no
Edward Leigh	Gainsborough	Con (front bench)	no
Oliver Letwin	West Dorset	Con (front bench)	no
Julian Lewis	New Forest East	Con (front bench)	no
Peter Lilley	Hitchin and Harpenden	Con	no
Mr Richard Livsey	Brecon and Radnorshire	LDem (front bench)	no
Sir Peter Lloyd	Fareham	Con	no
Elfyn Llwyd	Meirionnydd Nant Conwy	PC (front bench)	no
Tim Loughton	East Worthing and Shoreham	Con (front bench)	no
Peter Luff	Mid Worcestershire	Con (front bench)	no
David Maclean	Penrith and The Border	Con	no
Dr Brian Mawhinney	North West Cambridgeshire	Con	no
Anne McIntosh	Vale of York	Con (front bench)	no
Patrick McLoughlin	West Derbyshire	Con (front bench)	no
Mrs Ray Michie	Argyll and Bute	LDem	no
Michael Moore	Tweeddale, Ettrick and Lauderdale	LDem (front bench)	no
Stephen O'Brien	Eddisbury	Con	no
Lembit Öpik	Montgomeryshire	LDem	no
Mr Richard Page	South West Hertfordshire	Con	no
Owen Paterson	North Shropshire	Con (front bench)	no
Eric Pickles	Brentwood and Ongar	Con (front bench)	no
John Randall	Uxbridge	Con (front bench)	no
Mr David Rendel	Newbury	LDem	no
Andrew Robathan	Blaby	Con (front bench)	no
Laurence Robertson	Tewkesbury	Con (front bench)	no
Mr William Ross	East Londonderry	UUP	no
David Ruffley	Bury St Edmunds	Con (front bench)	no
Bob Russell	Colchester	LDem (front bench)	no
Alex Salmond	Banff and Buchan	SNP (front bench)	no
Adrian Sanders	Torbay	LDem (front bench)	no
Mr Jonathan Sayeed	Mid Bedfordshire	Con	tellno
Richard Shepherd	Aldridge-Brownhills	Con (front bench)	no
Keith Simpson	Mid Norfolk	Con (front bench)	no
Robert Smith	West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine	LDem (front bench)	no
Martin Smyth	Belfast South	UUP	no
Michael Spicer	West Worcestershire	Con (front bench)	no
Richard Spring	West Suffolk	Con	no
Mr Nick St Aubyn	Guildford	Con	no
John Stanley	Tonbridge and Malling	Con (front bench)	no
Andrew Stunell	Hazel Grove	LDem (front bench)	no
Desmond Swayne	New Forest West	Con (front bench)	no
John Swinney	North Tayside	SNP	no
Robert Syms	Poole	Con (front bench)	no
Ian Taylor	Esher and Walton	Con	no
Matthew Taylor	Truro and St Austell	LDem (front bench)	no
Mr William Thompson	West Tyrone	UUP	no
Dr Jenny Tonge	Richmond Park	LDem	no
David Tredinnick	Bosworth	Con (front bench)	no
Mr Paul Tyler	North Cornwall	LDem (front bench)	no
Andrew Tyrie	Chichester	Con (front bench)	no
Charles Wardle	Bexhill and Battle	whilst Con	no
Steve Webb	Northavon	LDem (front bench)	no
Andrew Welsh	Angus	SNP	no
Mr Dafydd Wigley	Caernarfon	PC (front bench)	no
Mr John Wilkinson	Ruislip - Northwood	Con	no
Phil Willis	Harrogate and Knaresborough	LDem (front bench)	no
David Wilshire	Spelthorne	Con	tellno
Ann Winterton	Congleton	Con	no
Nicholas Winterton	Macclesfield	Con	no
Shaun Woodward	Witney	whilst Con	no

Welfare Reform and Pensions Bill — Earnings of workers supplied by service companies etc: Northern Ireland — 3 Nov 1999

All Votes Cast - sorted by vote

About the Project

The Whip on the Web

Help keep PublicWhip alive