[S3M-3014.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time — 4 Dec 2008 at 17:00

This looks like the vote on S3M-3014.2

The description in the bulletin on 2008-12-04 is:

*S3M-3014.2 John Swinney: Local Government Finance—As an amendment to motion (S3M-3014) in the name of Derek Brownlee, leave out from "calls on" to end and insert "believes that the council tax is discredited and should be abolished and that a local income tax based on ability to pay is a fairer system of local taxation, and calls on the Scottish Government to publish early in 2009 its detailed response to the consultation on local income tax for debate by this Parliament." Supported by: Jim Mather*

You can search for this motion (S3M-3014.2) on TheyWorkForYou

Text Introducing Division:

The fourth question is, that amendment S3M-3014.2, in the name of John Swinney, which seeks to amend motion S3M-3014, in the name of Derek Brownlee, on local government finance, be agreed to. Are we agreed?

No.

There will be a division.

Debate in Parliament | Source |

Public Whip is run as a free not-for-profit service. If you'd like to support us, please consider switching your (UK) electricity and/or gas to Octopus Energy or tip us via Ko-Fi.

All Votes Cast - sorted by constituency

MPs for which their vote in this division differed from the majority vote of their party are marked in red. Also shows which MPs were ministers at the time of this vote. You can also see every eligible MP including those who did not vote in this division.

Sort by: Name | Constituency | Party | Vote

NameConstituencyPartyVote
Lewis MacdonaldAberdeen CentralLabno
Brian AdamAberdeen NorthSNPaye
Lord Nicol Ross [Missing last name for 80392]Aberdeen SouthLDemaye
Karen WhitefieldAirdrie and ShottsLabno
Andrew WelshAngusSNPaye
Jim MatherArgyll and ButeSNPaye
John ScottAyrConno
Stewart StevensonBanff and BuchanSNPaye
Jamie StoneCaithness, Sutherland and Easter RossLDemaye
Cathy JamiesonCarrick, Cumnock and Doon ValleyLabno
Tricia MarwickCentral FifeSNPaye
Linda FabianiCentral ScotlandSNPaye
Jamie HepburnCentral ScotlandSNPaye
Christina McKelvieCentral ScotlandSNPaye
Margaret MitchellCentral ScotlandConno
Alex NeilCentral ScotlandSNPaye
Hugh O'DonnellCentral ScotlandLDemaye
John WilsonCentral ScotlandSNPaye
Des McNultyClydebank and MilngavieLabno
Karen GillonClydesdaleLabno
Cathie CraigieCumbernauld and KilsythLabno
Kenneth GibsonCunninghame NorthSNPaye
Irene OldfatherCunninghame SouthLabno
Jackie BaillieDumbartonLabno
Elaine MurrayDumfriesLabno
Shona RobisonDundee EastSNPaye
Joe FitzPatrickDundee WestSNPno
Helen EadieDunfermline EastLabno
Jim TolsonDunfermline WestLDemaye
Andy KerrEast KilbrideLabno
Iain GrayEast LothianLabno
Kenneth MacintoshEastwoodLabno
Sarah BoyackEdinburgh CentralLabno
Kenny MacAskillEdinburgh East and MusselburghSNPaye
Malcolm ChisholmEdinburgh North and LeithLabno
David McLetchieEdinburgh PentlandsConno
Mike PringleEdinburgh SouthLDemaye
Margaret SmithEdinburgh WestLDemaye
Cathy PeattieFalkirk EastLabno
Michael MathesonFalkirk WestSNPaye
Bashir AhmadGlasgowSNPaye
Bill AitkenGlasgowConno
Bob DorisGlasgowSNPaye
Patrick HarvieGlasgowGreenno
Bill KiddGlasgowSNPaye
Sandra WhiteGlasgowSNPaye
Bill ButlerGlasgow AnnieslandLabno
Margaret CurranGlasgow BailliestonLabno
Charlie GordonGlasgow CathcartLabno
Nicola SturgeonGlasgow GovanSNPaye
Pauline McNeillGlasgow KelvinLabno
Patricia FergusonGlasgow MaryhillLabno
Johann LamontGlasgow PollokLabno
James KellyGlasgow RutherglenLabno
Frank McAveetyGlasgow ShettlestonLabno
Paul MartinGlasgow SpringburnLabno
Alex SalmondGordonSNP (front bench)aye
Duncan McNeilGreenock and InverclydeLabno
Michael McMahonHamilton North and BellshillLabno
Tom McCabeHamilton SouthLabno
Rob GibsonHighlands and IslandsSNPaye
Rhoda GrantHighlands and IslandsLabno
Jamie McGrigorHighlands and IslandsConno
Peter PeacockHighlands and IslandsLabno
Mary ScanlonHighlands and IslandsConno
David StewartHighlands and IslandsLabno
Dave ThompsonHighlands and IslandsSNPaye
Fergus EwingInverness East, Nairn and LochaberSNPaye
Willie CoffeyKilmarnock and LoudounSNPaye
Marilyn LivingstoneKirkcaldyLabno
Mary MulliganLinlithgowLabno
Angela ConstanceLivingstonSNPaye
Lord George [Missing last name for 80312]LothiansLab (minister)no
Gavin BrownLothiansConno
Robin HarperLothiansGreenno
Fiona HyslopLothiansSNPaye
Margo MacDonaldLothiansIndependentno
Ian McKeeLothiansSNPaye
Shirley-Anne SomervilleLothiansSNPaye
Claire BakerMid Scotland and FifeLabno
Ted BrocklebankMid Scotland and FifeConno
Murdo FraserMid Scotland and FifeConno
Christopher HarvieMid Scotland and FifeSNPaye
John ParkMid Scotland and FifeLabno
Richard SimpsonMid Scotland and FifeLabno
Elizabeth SmithMid Scotland and FifeConno
Rhona BrankinMidlothianLabno
Richard LochheadMoraySNPaye
Lord Jack Wilson [Missing last name for 80353]Motherwell and WishawLabno
Iain SmithNorth East FifeLDemaye
Richard BakerNorth East ScotlandLabno
Nigel DonNorth East ScotlandSNPaye
Marlyn GlenNorth East ScotlandLabno
Alex JohnstoneNorth East ScotlandConno
Alison McInnesNorth East ScotlandLDemaye
Nanette MilneNorth East ScotlandConno
Maureen WattNorth East ScotlandSNPaye
John SwinneyNorth TaysideSNPaye
Keith BrownOchilSNPaye
Liam McArthurOrkney IslandsLDemaye
Wendy AlexanderPaisley NorthLabno
Hugh HenryPaisley SouthLabno
Roseanna CunninghamPerthSNPaye
John LamontRoxburgh and BerwickshireConno
Tavish ScottShetland IslandsLDemaye
Derek BrownleeSouth of ScotlandConno
Aileen CampbellSouth of ScotlandSNPaye
Christine GrahameSouth of ScotlandSNPaye
Jim HumeSouth of ScotlandLDemaye
Adam IngramSouth of ScotlandSNPaye
Alasdair MorganSouth of ScotlandSNPaye
Michael RussellSouth of ScotlandSNPaye
Bruce CrawfordStirlingSNPaye
David WhittonStrathkelvin and BearsdenLabno
Jeremy PurvisTweeddale, Ettrick and LauderdaleLDemaye
Mike RumblesWest Aberdeenshire and KincardineLDemaye
Jackson CarlawWest of ScotlandConno
Ross FinnieWest of ScotlandLDemaye
Annabel GoldieWest of ScotlandConno
Stewart MaxwellWest of ScotlandSNPaye
Stuart McMillanWest of ScotlandSNPaye
Gil PatersonWest of ScotlandSNPaye
Bill WilsonWest of ScotlandSNPaye
Trish GodmanWest RenfrewshireLabno
Alasdair AllanWestern IslesSNPaye

About the Project

The Public Whip is a not-for-profit, open source website created in 2003 by Francis Irving and Julian Todd and now run by Bairwell Ltd.

The Whip on the Web

Help keep PublicWhip alive