European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Bill — Report (1st Day) — Amendment 12 — 20 Jan 2020 at 19:15

Moved by Lord Beith

12: Clause 26, page 30, line 13, leave out paragraph (b)Member’s explanatory statementThis amendment would remove the power of Ministers by delegated legislation to decide which courts and tribunals should have power to depart from judgments of the Court of Justice of the European Union and by reference to what test.

Ayes 241, Noes 205.

Debate in Parliament |

Public Whip is run as a free not-for-profit service. If you'd like to support us, please consider switching your (UK) electricity and/or gas to Octopus Energy or tip us via Ko-Fi.

All Votes Cast - sorted by name

Lords for which their vote in this division differed from the majority vote of their party are marked in red. Also shows which lords were ministers at the time of this vote. You can also see every eligible lord including those who did not vote in this division.

Sort by: Name | Party | Vote

Name	Party	Vote
Lord Aberdare	Crossbench	aye
Baroness Adams of Craigielea	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Addington	LDem (front bench)	aye
Lord Adonis	Lab	aye
Lord Agnew of Oulton	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Ahmad of Wimbledon	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Allan of Hallam	LDem	aye
Lord Allen of Kensington	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Alli	Lab	aye
Lord Anderson of Ipswich	Crossbench (front bench)	aye
Baroness Andrews	Lab (minister)	aye
Baroness Anelay of St Johns	Con (front bench)	no
The Earl of Arran	Con	no
Lord Ashton of Hyde	Con (front bench)	tellno
Viscount Astor	Con	no
Lord Astor of Hever	Con	no
Earl Attlee	Con	no
Lord Bach	Lab	aye
Lord Baker of Dorking	Con	no
Baroness Bakewell	Lab	aye
Baroness Bakewell of Hardington Mandeville	LDem (front bench)	aye
Lord Balfe	Con	no
Baroness Barker	LDem (front bench)	aye
Baroness Barran	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Barwell	Con	no
Lord Bassam of Brighton	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Bates	Con	no
Lord Beecham	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Beith	LDem (front bench)	aye
Baroness Benjamin	LDem	aye
Lord Berkeley	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Berkeley of Knighton	Crossbench	aye
Baroness Berridge	Con (front bench)	no
Baroness Bertin	Con	no
Lord Bethell	Con (front bench)	no
Baroness Billingham	Lab	aye
Lord Black of Brentwood	Con (front bench)	no
Baroness Blackstone	Independent Labour (front bench)	aye
Baroness Blackwood of North Oxford	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Blencathra	Con (front bench)	no
Baroness Bloomfield of Hinton Waldrist	Con (front bench)	no
Baroness Blower	Lab	aye
Lord Blunkett	Lab	aye
Lord Boateng	Lab	aye
Baroness Bonham-Carter of Yarnbury	LDem (front bench)	aye
Baroness Boothroyd	Crossbench	aye
Lord Borwick	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Bourne of Aberystwyth	Con	no
Baroness Bowles of Berkhamsted	LDem (front bench)	aye
Lord Brabazon of Tara	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Bradley	Lab (minister)	aye
Baroness Brady	Con	no
Lord Bragg	Lab	aye
Lord Brennan	Lab (minister)	aye
Viscount Bridgeman	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Bridges of Headley	Con (front bench)	no
Baroness Brinton	LDem	aye
Lord Brooke of Alverthorpe	Lab	aye
Lord Brookman	Lab	aye
Lord Brougham and Vaux	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Brown of Eaton-under-Heywood	Judge (front bench)	aye
Lord Browne of Ladyton	Lab (minister)	aye
Baroness Browning	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Brownlow of Shurlock Row	Con	no
Lord Bruce of Bennachie	LDem (front bench)	aye
Baroness Bryan of Partick	Lab (minister)	aye
Baroness Bull	Crossbench (front bench)	aye
Baroness Burt of Solihull	LDem	aye
Baroness Butler-Sloss	Crossbench (front bench)	aye
Lord Butler of Brockwell	Crossbench (front bench)	aye
Baroness Byford	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Caine	Con	no
The Earl of Caithness	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Callanan	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Campbell-Savours	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Campbell of Pittenweem	LDem (front bench)	aye
Lord Carrington	Crossbench	no
Lord Carrington of Fulham	Con	no
Lord Carter of Coles	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Cashman	Non-affiliated	aye
Earl Cathcart	Con	no
Lord Cavendish of Furness	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Chadlington	Con	no
Baroness Chakrabarti	Lab (minister)	aye
Baroness Chalker of Wallasey	Con (front bench)	no
Viscount Chandos	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Chidgey	LDem	aye
Baroness Chisholm of Owlpen	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Choudrey	Con	no
The Earl of Clancarty	Crossbench (front bench)	aye
Lord Clement-Jones	LDem (front bench)	aye
Lord Coe	Con	no
Lord Colgrain	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Collins of Highbury	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Colwyn	Con	no
Lord Cope of Berkeley	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Cormack	Con (front bench)	no
Baroness Corston	Lab (minister)	aye
The Earl of Courtown	Con (front bench)	tellno
Baroness Coussins	Crossbench	aye
Lord Craig of Radley	Crossbench (front bench)	aye
Baroness Crawley	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Cromwell	Crossbench (front bench)	aye
Baroness Cumberlege	Con	no
Lord Davies of Gower	Con	no
Lord Davies of Oldham	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Davies of Stamford	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord de Mauley	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Dear	Crossbench (front bench)	aye
Baroness Deech	Crossbench (front bench)	no
Lord Dholakia	LDem (front bench)	aye
Lord Dixon-Smith	Con	no
Lord Dobbs	Con	no
Baroness Donaghy	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Donoughue	Lab	aye
Baroness Doocey	LDem (front bench)	aye
Lord Dubs	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Duncan of Springbank	Con (front bench)	no
The Earl of Dundee	Con	no
Lord Dunlop	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Dykes	Crossbench (front bench)	aye
Baroness Eaton	Con (front bench)	no
Viscount Eccles	Con (front bench)	no
Baroness Eccles of Moulton	Con	no
Lord Elder	Lab	aye
Lord Elton	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Empey	UUP (front bench)	no
Baroness Evans of Bowes Park	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Fairfax of Cameron	Con	no
Baroness Fall	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Farmer	Con	no
Lord Faulkner of Worcester	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Fellowes of West Stafford	Con	no
Lord Filkin	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Fink	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Finkelstein	Con	no
Baroness Finlay of Llandaff	Crossbench (front bench)	aye
Baroness Finn	Con (front bench)	no
Baroness Fookes	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Forsyth of Drumlean	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Foster of Bath	LDem (front bench)	aye
Lord Foulkes of Cumnock	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Fox	LDem (front bench)	aye
Lord Framlingham	Con	no
Lord Fraser of Corriegarth	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Freeman	Con	no
Lord Gadhia	Non-affiliated	no
Baroness Gale	Lab (minister)	aye
Baroness Garden of Frognal	LDem (front bench)	aye
Lord Gardiner of Kimble	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Geddes	Con (front bench)	no
Lord German	LDem (front bench)	aye
Lord Giddens	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Gilbert of Panteg	Con (front bench)	no
The Earl of Glasgow	LDem	aye
Lord Glenarthur	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Glendonbrook	Con	no
Lord Goddard of Stockport	LDem (front bench)	aye
Baroness Goldie	Con (front bench)	no
Baroness Golding	Lab	aye
Lord Goldsmith	Lab	aye
Lord Goldsmith of Richmond Park	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Goodlad	Con	no
Viscount Goschen	Con	no
Baroness Goudie	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Grade of Yarmouth	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Grantchester	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Greaves	LDem	aye
Lord Green of Deddington	Crossbench	aye
Lord Greenway	Crossbench	no
Baroness Grender	LDem (front bench)	aye
Lord Griffiths of Burry Port	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Griffiths of Fforestfach	Con	no
Lord Hague of Richmond	Con	no
Lord Hain	Lab	aye
Lord Hamilton of Epsom	Con	no
Baroness Hamwee	LDem (front bench)	aye
Lord Hannay of Chiswick	Crossbench (front bench)	aye
Viscount Hanworth	Lab (minister)	aye
Baroness Harding of Winscombe	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Harries of Pentregarth	Crossbench	aye
Lord Harris of Peckham	Con	no
Lord Haselhurst	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Haworth	Lab	aye
Baroness Hayter of Kentish Town	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Hayward	Con (front bench)	no
Baroness Healy of Primrose Hill	Lab (minister)	aye
Baroness Helic	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Hendy	Lab	aye
Baroness Henig	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Henley	Con	no
Lord Hill of Oareford	Con	no
Lord Hodgson of Astley Abbotts	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Hogan-Howe	Crossbench	no
Baroness Hollins	Crossbench	aye
Lord Holmes of Richmond	Non-affiliated (front bench)	no
Baroness Hooper	Con	no
Lord Hope of Craighead	Judge	aye
Lord Horam	Con	no
Lord Howard of Rising	Con	no
Lord Howarth of Newport	Lab (minister)	aye
Earl Howe	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Howell of Guildford	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Hoyle	Lab	aye
Lord Hughes of Woodside	Lab	aye
Baroness Humphreys	LDem (front bench)	tellaye
Lord Hunt of Kings Heath	Lab	aye
Lord Hunt of Wirral	Con	no
Lord Hussain	LDem	aye
Baroness Hussein-Ece	LDem (front bench)	aye
Lord Hylton	Crossbench	aye
Baroness Janke	LDem (front bench)	aye
Baroness Jenkin of Kennington	Con (front bench)	no
Baroness Jolly	LDem (front bench)	aye
Lord Jones	Lab	aye
Baroness Jones of Moulsecoomb	Green	aye
Baroness Jones of Whitchurch	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Judd	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Judge	Judge (front bench)	aye
Lord Keen of Elie	Con (front bench)	no
Baroness Kennedy of Cradley	Lab	aye
Lord Kennedy of Southwark	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Kerr of Kinlochard	Crossbench (front bench)	aye
Lord Kerslake	Crossbench (front bench)	aye
Lord Kilclooney	Crossbench	aye
Baroness Kingsmill	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Kirkham	Con	no
Lord Kirkhope of Harrogate	Con (front bench)	no
Baroness Kramer	LDem (front bench)	aye
Lord Lamont of Lerwick	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Lang of Monkton	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Lansley	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Layard	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Lea of Crondall	Non-affiliated	aye
Lord Leigh of Hurley	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Lennie	Lab (minister)	aye
Baroness Liddell of Coatdyke	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Liddle	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Lilley	Con (front bench)	no
The Earl of Lindsay	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Lingfield	Con (front bench)	no
Baroness Lister of Burtersett	Lab	aye
Lord Livermore	Lab	aye
The Earl of Liverpool	Con	no
Lord Livingston of Parkhead	Con (front bench)	no
The Marquess of Lothian	Con	no
Lord Lucas	Con (front bench)	no
Baroness Ludford	LDem (front bench)	aye
The Earl of Lytton	Crossbench	no
Lord MacKenzie of Culkein	Lab	aye
Baroness Maddock	LDem (front bench)	aye
Lord Magan of Castletown	Con	no
Lord Maginnis of Drumglass	Independent Ulster Unionist	aye
Lord Mancroft	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Mandelson	Lab	aye
Lord Mann	Non-affiliated	no
Baroness Manzoor	Con	no
Lord Marks of Henley-on-Thames	LDem (front bench)	aye
Lord Marland	Con	no
Lord Marlesford	Con	no
Baroness Massey of Darwen	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Maude of Horsham	Con	no
Lord Mawson	Crossbench	no
Lord Maxton	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord McAvoy	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord McColl of Dulwich	Con (front bench)	no
Baroness McDonagh	Lab	aye
Baroness McGregor-Smith	Con (front bench)	no
Lord McInnes of Kilwinning	Con (front bench)	no
Baroness McIntosh of Hudnall	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord McKenzie of Luton	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord McNally	LDem (front bench)	aye
Lord McNicol of West Kilbride	Lab (minister)	aye
Baroness Meacher	Crossbench (front bench)	aye
Lord Mendelsohn	Lab (minister)	aye
Baroness Meyer	Con (front bench)	no
Baroness Miller of Chilthorne Domer	LDem	aye
Baroness Mone	Con	no
Lord Monks	Lab (minister)	aye
The Duke of Montrose	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Morgan	Lab	aye
Baroness Morgan of Cotes	Con (front bench)	no
Baroness Morris of Bolton	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Morris of Handsworth	Lab (minister)	aye
Baroness Morris of Yardley	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Moynihan	Con	no
Baroness Murphy	Crossbench	aye
Lord Murphy of Torfaen	Lab	aye
Lord Naseby	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Nash	Con	no
Baroness Neville-Rolfe	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Newby	LDem (front bench)	aye
Baroness Newlove	Con (front bench)	no
Baroness Nicholson of Winterbourne	Con	no
Baroness Noakes	Con	no
Lord Northbrook	Con	no
Baroness Northover	LDem (front bench)	aye
Lord Norton of Louth	Con	no
Baroness Nye	Lab	aye
Baroness O'Neill of Bengarve	Crossbench (front bench)	aye
Lord O'Shaughnessy	Con	no
Lord Oakeshott of Seagrove Bay	Non-affiliated	aye
Lord Oates	LDem (front bench)	aye
Baroness Osamor	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Paddick	LDem (front bench)	aye
Lord Palmer of Childs Hill	LDem (front bench)	aye
Lord Pannick	Crossbench (front bench)	aye
Lord Parkinson of Whitley Bay	Con (front bench)	no
Baroness Parminter	LDem (front bench)	aye
Lord Patel of Bradford	Non-affiliated	aye
Lord Patten	Con	no
Baroness Penn	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Pickles	Con	no
Baroness Pidding	Con (front bench)	no
Baroness Pinnock	LDem (front bench)	aye
Baroness Pitkeathley	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Popat	Con	no
Lord Porter of Spalding	Con	no
Baroness Primarolo	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Prior of Brampton	Non-affiliated	no
Baroness Prosser	Lab	aye
Baroness Quin	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Randall of Uxbridge	Con	no
Baroness Randerson	LDem (front bench)	aye
Lord Ranger	Con	no
Baroness Rawlings	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Razzall	LDem (front bench)	aye
Lord Reay	Con	no
Baroness Rebuck	Lab	aye
Lord Redesdale	LDem	aye
Baroness Redfern	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Renfrew of Kaimsthorn	Con	no
Lord Ribeiro	Con	no
Viscount Ridley	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Risby	Con	no
Baroness Ritchie of Downpatrick	Non-affiliated	aye
Lord Robathan	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Roberts of Llandudno	LDem	aye
Lord Robertson of Port Ellen	Lab	aye
Baroness Rock	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Rodgers of Quarry Bank	LDem (front bench)	aye
Lord Rogan	UUP (front bench)	aye
Lord Rosser	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Rowe-Beddoe	Crossbench (front bench)	aye
Lord Rowlands	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Russell of Liverpool	Crossbench (front bench)	aye
Lord Ryder of Wensum	Con	no
Baroness Sanderson of Welton	Con	no
Baroness Sater	Con	no
Lord Sawyer	Lab	aye
Baroness Scott of Bybrook	Con (front bench)	no
Baroness Scott of Needham Market	LDem (front bench)	aye
Lord Scriven	LDem (front bench)	aye
Baroness Seccombe	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Selkirk of Douglas	Con	no
Baroness Shackleton of Belgravia	Con	no
Lord Sharkey	LDem (front bench)	aye
Baroness Sheehan	LDem (front bench)	aye
Lord Sheikh	Con	no
Baroness Shephard of Northwold	Con	no
Lord Sherbourne of Didsbury	Con (front bench)	no
Baroness Sherlock	Lab (minister)	aye
Baroness Shields	Con	no
Lord Shinkwin	Con	no
Lord Shipley	LDem (front bench)	aye
The Earl of Shrewsbury	Con	no
Viscount Simon	Lab (minister)	aye
Baroness Smith of Basildon	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Smith of Finsbury	Non-affiliated	aye
Baroness Smith of Gilmorehill	Lab	aye
Lord Smith of Hindhead	Con (front bench)	no
Baroness Smith of Newnham	LDem (front bench)	aye
Lord Snape	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Soley	Lab (minister)	aye
The Duke of Somerset	Crossbench	aye
Baroness Stedman-Scott	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Stephen	LDem	aye
Lord Stoneham of Droxford	LDem (front bench)	tellaye
Lord Storey	LDem (front bench)	aye
Lord Strasburger	LDem	aye
Lord Strathclyde	Con	no
Baroness Stroud	Con	no
Lord Stunell	LDem	aye
Baroness Sugg	Con (front bench)	no
Baroness Suttie	LDem (front bench)	aye
Lord Swinfen	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Taverne	LDem	aye
Baroness Taylor of Bolton	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Taylor of Goss Moor	LDem	aye
Lord Taylor of Holbeach	Con	no
Lord Taylor of Warwick	Non-affiliated	no
Lord Teverson	LDem (front bench)	aye
Lord Thomas of Cwmgiedd	Judge (front bench)	aye
Lord Thomas of Gresford	LDem (front bench)	aye
Baroness Thornhill	LDem (front bench)	aye
Baroness Thornton	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Thurlow	Crossbench (front bench)	aye
Viscount Thurso	LDem	aye
Baroness Tonge	Non-affiliated	aye
Lord Tope	LDem (front bench)	aye
Lord Trefgarne	Con	no
Viscount Trenchard	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Trevethin and Oaksey	Crossbench (front bench)	aye
Lord Triesman	Lab	aye
Lord Trimble	Con (front bench)	no
Lord True	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Tugendhat	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Tunnicliffe	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Tyler	LDem (front bench)	aye
Baroness Tyler of Enfield	LDem	aye
Baroness Uddin	Non-affiliated	aye
Viscount Ullswater	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Vaux of Harrowden	Crossbench (front bench)	aye
Baroness Vere of Norbiton	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Verjee	LDem	aye
Baroness Verma	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Wakeham	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Wallace of Saltaire	LDem (front bench)	aye
Lord Wallace of Tankerness	LDem (front bench)	aye
Baroness Walmsley	LDem (front bench)	aye
Lord Warner	Crossbench	aye
Baroness Warsi	Con	no
Baroness Watkins of Tavistock	Crossbench (front bench)	aye
Lord Watson of Invergowrie	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Watts	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Wei	Con	no
The Duke of Wellington	Non-affiliated	aye
Baroness Wheatcroft	Non-affiliated	aye
Baroness Wheeler	Lab (minister)	aye
Baroness Whitaker	Lab	aye
Lord Whitby	Con	no
Lord Whitty	Lab (minister)	aye
Lord Wigley	PC (front bench)	aye
Baroness Wilcox	Con	no
Baroness Wilcox of Newport	Lab	aye
Lord Willetts	Con	no
Baroness Williams of Trafford	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Willis of Knaresborough	LDem	aye
Lord Wilson of Tillyorn	Crossbench	aye
Lord Woolley of Woodford	Crossbench	aye
Lord Wrigglesworth	LDem	aye
Baroness Wyld	Con	no
Lord Young of Cookham	Con	no
Viscount Younger of Leckie	Con (front bench)	no
Lord Young of Norwood Green	Lab (minister)	aye
Baroness Young of Old Scone	Lab (minister)	aye

European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Bill — Report (1st Day) — Amendment 12 — 20 Jan 2020 at 19:15

All Votes Cast - sorted by name

About the Project

The Whip on the Web

Help keep PublicWhip alive