Voting Comparison — Andrew MacKinlay MP, Thurrock
to Dawn Butler MP, Brent South

Andrew MacKinlay

Note: our records only go back to 1997 for the Commons and 2001 for the Lords (more details).

From	To	Party	Rebellions (explain...)	Attendance (explain...)	Teller
5 May 2005	12 Apr 2010	Lab	79 votes out of 923, 8.6%	923 votes out of 1288, 71.7%	3 times
7 Jun 2001	11 Apr 2005	Lab	53 votes out of 904, 5.9%	904 votes out of 1246, 72.6%	2 times
1 May 1997	14 May 2001	Lab	19 votes out of 906, 2.1%	906 votes out of 1273, 71.2%	3 times

Voting Differences

House	Date	Subject	Andrew MacKinlay	Dawn Butler	Rôle
Commons	4 Mar 2010	Backbench Business Committee	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	2 Dec 2009	Equality Bill — Schedule 9 — Work: exceptions	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	1 Dec 2009	Foreign and Commonwealth Office — Business without Debate — Census	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	25 Nov 2009	Christmas Holiday	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	9 Nov 2009	Coroners and Justice Bill — Clause 61 — Freedom of Speech — Discussion and Criticism of Sexual Conduct and Orientation	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	9 Nov 2009	Coroners and Justice Bill — Enable Minister to Replace Inquest With Inquiry — Incercept Evidence in Inquests	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	3 Nov 2009	Constitutional Reform and Governance Bill -Programme Motion No. 2	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	13 Oct 2009	Local Democracy, Economic Development and Construction Bill — Increase upper size of alternative arrangements Local Authorities — rejected	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	20 Jul 2009	Business of the House	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	20 Jul 2009	Business of the House	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	15 Jul 2009	Opposition Day — [16th Allotted Day] — US-UK Extradition Treaty	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	9 Jul 2009	Terrorism Act 2006 (Disapplication of Section 25) Order 2009	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	8 Jul 2009	Deferred Divisions — Identity cards	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	8 Jul 2009	Deferred Divisions — Identity Cards	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	8 Jul 2009	Deferred Divisions — Identity Cards	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	8 Jul 2009	Deferred Divisions — Identity Cards	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	8 Jul 2009	Deferred Divisions — Identity cards	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	7 Jul 2009	Parliamentary Commissions of Inquiry — New Clause 1 — Implementation of section 1	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	6 Jul 2009	Opposition Day — [15th Allotted Day] — Identity Cards	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	6 Jul 2009	Opposition Day — [15th Allotted Day] — Identity Cards	both	no	absent
Commons	24 Jun 2009	Iraq Inquiry — Welcomes the inquiry	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	24 Jun 2009	Iraq Inquiry — Parliament to set the terms of reference — rejected	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	10 Jun 2009	Immediate General Election — rejected	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	13 May 2009	Bill Presented — Clause 16 — Rates and rebates from September 2009	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	13 May 2009	Bill Presented — Clause 16 — Rates and rebates from September 2009	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	13 May 2009	Bill Presented — Clause 16 — Rates and rebates from September 2009	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	12 May 2009	Finance Bill — Clause 11 — Rates of alcoholic liquor duty	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	12 May 2009	Finance Bill — Clause 11 — Rates of alcoholic liquor duty	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	12 May 2009	Finance Bill — Clause 11 — Rates of alcoholic liquor duty	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	29 Apr 2009	Gurkha Settlement Rights — Government defeat	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	25 Mar 2009	Iraq War Inquiry — Declines to make a proposal	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	25 Mar 2009	Iraq War Inquiry — No reasonable impediment — rejected	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	23 Mar 2009	Bill Presented — Clause 11 — Certified investigations: investigation by a judge, inquest without jury	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	11 Mar 2009	Theft from Shops (Use of Penalty Notices for Disorder) — Clause 2 — Levying authorities	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	11 Mar 2009	Theft from Shops (Use of Penalty Notices for Disorder) — New Clause 1 — Project Delivery Board	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	4 Mar 2009	Prime Minister — Northern Ireland Bill (Allocation of Time)	minority	tellno	disagrees with policy
Commons	3 Mar 2009	Business of the House — Select Committees (Chairmen), Liaison Committee and Green Book	tellno	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	3 Mar 2009	Control Orders — Annual renewal 2009	both	aye	absent
Commons	24 Feb 2009	Airport Expansion (Parliamentary Approval)	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	10 Feb 2009	Employment Opportunities — Banking Bill (Money)	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	2 Feb 2009	Opposition Day — [3rd Allotted Day] — Parliamentary Standards (Constitutional Reform)	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	28 Jan 2009	Heathrow Third Runway — rethink the plans — rejected	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	21 Jan 2009	Opposition Day — [1st Allotted Day] — Savers	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	21 Jan 2009	Opposition Day — [1st Allotted Day] — Savers	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	17 Dec 2008	Deferred Division — Adjournment (Christmas)	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	17 Dec 2008	Consolidated Fund Bill — Electoral Commission (Remuneration of Chairman)	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	8 Dec 2008	Police raid of MP's office — New committee to adjourn immediately	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	8 Dec 2008	Review of House of Commons Proceedures Police Raid of Damian Green MP's Office — Committee to Investigate Immediately — rejected	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	18 Nov 2008	Orders of the Day — Clause 20 — Terms and conditions	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	18 Nov 2008	Orders of the Day — Clause 20 — Terms and conditions	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	12 Nov 2008	Business of the House — European Scrutiny (Standing Orders)	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	12 Nov 2008	Business of the House — Regional Grand Committees	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	12 Nov 2008	Business of the House — Regional Accountability	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	4 Nov 2008	Orders of the Day — New Clause 2 — Employer's duties in relation to industrial action ballots	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	29 Oct 2008	Opposition Day — [11th Allotted Day — Second Part] — Manchester City Council Bill [ Lords] (By Order)	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	29 Oct 2008	Opposition Day — [11th Allotted Day — Second Part] — Manchester City Council Bill [ Lords] (By Order)	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	28 Oct 2008	Climate Change Bill — Third Reading (and other amendments)	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	28 Oct 2008	Climate Change Bill — Report on the civil estate	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	28 Oct 2008	Climate Change Bill — International aviation and shipping emission projections — rejected	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	28 Oct 2008	Climate Change Bill — Electricity generating station performance standards — rejected	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	27 Oct 2008	Orders of the Day — New Clause 23 — Financial penalty deposits: powers of vehicle examiners in Scotland	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	22 Oct 2008	Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill Third Reading	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	22 Oct 2008	Deferred Divisions — Clause 68 — Commencement	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	22 Oct 2008	Deferred Divisions — Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill [Lords]	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	22 Oct 2008	Deferred Divisions — Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill [Lords]	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	17 Jul 2008	Intelligence and Security Committee — Should belong to the House — rejected	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	11 Jun 2008	Counter-Terrorism Bill — Extension of period of detention to 42 days — Order	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	11 Jun 2008	Counter-Terrorism Bill — Extension of Maximim Period of Police Detention Without Charge in Terror Cases from 28 to 42 Days	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	10 Jun 2008	Counter-Terrorism Bill — Disallow inquests without a jury in England and Wales — rejected	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	20 May 2008	Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill — Change abortion limit from 24 weeks to 22 weeks — rejected	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	20 May 2008	Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill — Prospects for life of handicapped child must be given before abortion — rejected	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	20 May 2008	Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill — Change abortion limit from 24 weeks to 20 weeks — rejected	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	20 May 2008	Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill — Change abortion limit from 24 weeks to 16 weeks — rejected	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	20 May 2008	Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill — Change abortion limit from 24 weeks to 12 weeks — rejected	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	20 May 2008	Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill — Fertility treatment requires male role model — rejected	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	20 May 2008	Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill — Fertility treatment requires father and mother — rejected	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	19 May 2008	Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill — Animal DNA may be inserted into an embryo	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	19 May 2008	Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill — Cannot use gametes or pronuclei — rejected	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	12 May 2008	Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill — Timetable	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	12 May 2008	Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill — Second Reading	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	14 Mar 2007	Trident Replacement — Maintain the UK Nuclear Deterrent Beyond the Life of The Existing System	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	7 Mar 2007	House of Lords Reform — Composition Option 5 (60 per Cent. Elected) — rejected	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	19 Jan 2007	Orders of the Day — Sustainable Communities Bill	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	1 Nov 2006	Short Speeches	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	1 Nov 2006	Legislative Process (Notice for Amendments in Public Bill Committee)	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	8 Feb 2006	Opposition Parties (Financial Assistance)	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	31 Jan 2006	Racial and Religious Hatred Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	31 Jan 2006	Racial and Religious Hatred Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	13 Jul 2005	Committees — Term Limits for Chairmen of Select Committees	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
House	Date	Subject	Andrew MacKinlay	Dawn Butler	Rôle
no votes listed
House	Date	Subject	Andrew MacKinlay	Dawn Butler	Rôle
no votes listed

Voting Comparison — Andrew MacKinlay MP, Thurrock
to Dawn Butler MP, Brent South

Voting Differences

About the Project

The Whip on the Web

Help keep PublicWhip alive

Voting Comparison — Andrew MacKinlay MP, Thurrock to Dawn Butler MP, Brent South

Voting Differences

About the Project

The Whip on the Web

Help keep PublicWhip alive

Voting Comparison — Andrew MacKinlay MP, Thurrock
to Dawn Butler MP, Brent South