House | Date | Subject | Baroness Deech | Baroness Symons of Vernham Dean | Rôle |
Lords | 17 Apr 2024 | Safety of Rwanda (Asylum and Immigration) Bill - Commons Reasons — Motion D1 (as an amendment to Motion D) |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 16 Apr 2024 | Safety of Rwanda (Asylum and Immigration) Bill - Commons Amendments and Reasons — Motion F1 (as an amendment to Motion F) |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 16 Apr 2024 | Safety of Rwanda (Asylum and Immigration) Bill - Commons Amendments and Reasons — Motion C1 (as an amendment to Motion C) |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 16 Apr 2024 | Safety of Rwanda (Asylum and Immigration) Bill - Commons Amendments and Reasons — Motion A1 (as an amendment to Motion A) |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 20 Mar 2024 | Safety of Rwanda (Asylum and Immigration) Bill - Commons Reasons — Motion H1 (as an amendment to Motion H) |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 20 Mar 2024 | Safety of Rwanda (Asylum and Immigration) Bill - Commons Reasons — Motion G1 (as an amendment to Motion G) |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 20 Mar 2024 | Safety of Rwanda (Asylum and Immigration) Bill - Commons Reasons — Motion E1 (as an amendment to Motion E) |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 20 Mar 2024 | Safety of Rwanda (Asylum and Immigration) Bill - Commons Reasons — Motion D1 (as an amendment to Motion D) |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 20 Mar 2024 | Safety of Rwanda (Asylum and Immigration) Bill - Commons Reasons — Motion B1 (as an amendment to Motion B) |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 3 Jul 2023 | Illegal Migration Bill - Report (2nd Day) |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 20 Jun 2023 | Retained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Bill - Commons Reasons — Motion B1 (as an amendment to Motion B) |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 20 Jun 2023 | Retained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Bill - Commons Reasons — Motion A1 (as an amendment to Motion A) |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 13 Jun 2023 | Financial Services and Markets Bill - Report (3rd Day) — Amendment 104 |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 7 Feb 2023 | Public Order Bill - Report (2nd Day) — Amendment 48 |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 28 Jun 2022 | Pharmacy (Responsible Pharmacists, Superintendent Pharmacists etc.) Order 2022 - Motion to Approve — Amendment to the Motion |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 31 Mar 2022 | Judicial Review and Courts Bill - Report — Amendment 5 |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 31 Mar 2022 | Judicial Review and Courts Bill - Report — Amendment 4 |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 31 Mar 2022 | Judicial Review and Courts Bill - Report — Amendment 1 |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 31 Mar 2022 | Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Bill - Commons Amendments — Motion D1 (as an amendment to Motion D) |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 13 Jul 2021 | Procedure and Privileges - Motion to Agree — Amendment to the Motion |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 13 Jul 2021 | Procedure and Privileges - Motion to Agree — Amendment to the Motion |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 30 Dec 2020 | European Union (Future Relationship) Bill - Second Reading (and remaining stages) — Amendment to the Motion |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 9 Dec 2020 | United Kingdom Internal Market Bill - Commons Reasons and Amendments — Motion K1 (as an amendment to Motion K) |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 25 Nov 2020 | United Kingdom Internal Market Bill - Report (3rd Day) — Amendment 69 |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 25 Nov 2020 | United Kingdom Internal Market Bill - Report (3rd Day) — Amendment 64 |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 23 Nov 2020 | United Kingdom Internal Market Bill - Report (2nd Day) — Amendment 15 |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 14 Oct 2020 | Health Protection (Coronavirus, Local COVID-19 Alert Level) (Very High) (England) Regulations 2020 - Motion to Approve — Amendment to the Motion |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 6 Sep 2019 | European Union (Withdrawal) (No. 6) Bill - Report — Amendment 2 |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 6 Sep 2019 | European Union (Withdrawal) (No. 6) Bill - Report — Amendment 1 |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 4 Sep 2019 | Business of the House - Motion on Standing Orders — Amendment to the Motion (2F) |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 4 Sep 2019 | Business of the House - Motion on Standing Orders — Amendment to the Motion (2E) |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 4 Sep 2019 | Business of the House - Motion on Standing Orders — Amendment to the Motion (2D) |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 4 Sep 2019 | Business of the House - Motion on Standing Orders — Motion |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 4 Sep 2019 | Business of the House - Motion on Standing Orders — Motion |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 4 Sep 2019 | Business of the House - Motion on Standing Orders — Motion |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 4 Sep 2019 | Business of the House - Motion on Standing Orders — Motion |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 4 Sep 2019 | Business of the House - Motion on Standing Orders — Motion |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 4 Sep 2019 | Business of the House - Motion on Standing Orders — Motion |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 4 Sep 2019 | Business of the House - Motion on Standing Orders — Motion |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 4 Sep 2019 | Business of the House - Motion on Standing Orders — Motion |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 4 Sep 2019 | Business of the House - Motion on Standing Orders — Motion |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 4 Sep 2019 | Business of the House - Motion on Standing Orders — Motion |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 4 Sep 2019 | Business of the House - Motion on Standing Orders — Amendment to the Motion (2J) |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 4 Sep 2019 | Business of the House - Motion on Standing Orders — Amendment to the Motion (2K) |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 4 Sep 2019 | Business of the House - Motion on Standing Orders — Motion |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 4 Sep 2019 | Business of the House - Motion on Standing Orders — Motion |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 17 Jul 2019 | Northern Ireland (Executive Formation) Bill - Report — Amendment 3 |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 8 Apr 2019 | European Union (Withdrawal) (No. 5) Bill - Committee — Amendment 7 |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 4 Apr 2019 | Business of the House - Motion on Standing Orders — Amendment to the Motion |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 4 Apr 2019 | Business of the House - Motion on Standing Orders — Motion |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 4 Apr 2019 | Business of the House - Motion on Standing Orders — Motion |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 4 Apr 2019 | Business of the House - Motion on Standing Orders — Motion |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 4 Apr 2019 | Business of the House - Motion on Standing Orders — Motion |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 4 Apr 2019 | Business of the House - Motion on Standing Orders — Motion |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 4 Apr 2019 | Business of the House - Motion on Standing Orders — Motion |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 4 Apr 2019 | Business of the House - Motion on Standing Orders — Motion |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 4 Apr 2019 | Business of the House - Motion on Standing Orders — Motion |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 4 Apr 2019 | Business of the House - Motion on Standing Orders — Motion |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 4 Apr 2019 | Business of the House - Motion on Standing Orders — Motion |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 4 Apr 2019 | Business of the House - Motion on Standing Orders — Motion |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 4 Apr 2019 | Business of the House - Motion on Standing Orders — Motion |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 14 Jan 2019 | Brexit: Withdrawal Agreement and Political Declaration - Motion to Take Note (Continued) (3rd Day) |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 10 Dec 2018 | Arrangement of Business |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 8 May 2018 | European Union (Withdrawal) Bill - Report (6th Day) |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 8 May 2018 | European Union (Withdrawal) Bill - Report (6th Day) |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 30 Apr 2018 | European Union (Withdrawal) Bill - Report (4th Day) |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 23 Apr 2018 | European Union (Withdrawal) Bill - Report (2nd Day) |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 23 Apr 2018 | European Union (Withdrawal) Bill - Report (2nd Day) |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 23 Apr 2018 | European Union (Withdrawal) Bill - Report (2nd Day) |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 18 Apr 2018 | European Union (Withdrawal) Bill - Report (1st Day) |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 7 Mar 2017 | European Union (Notification of Withdrawal) Bill - Report (Continued) |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 1 Mar 2017 | European Union (Notification of Withdrawal) Bill — Clause 1 — Rights of EU Citizens Legally Resident in the UK |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 2 Nov 2016 | Investigatory Powers Bill - Commons Reasons |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 27 Apr 2016 | Housing and Planning Bill - Third Reading |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 26 Apr 2016 | Immigration Bill - Commons Reasons and Amendments |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 25 Apr 2016 | Housing and Planning Bill - Report (5th Day) |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 20 Jan 2016 | Trade Union Bill — Motion |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 28 Oct 2015 | Joint Committee on Human Rights — Message from the Commons |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 27 Oct 2015 | Electoral Registration and Administration Act 2013 (Transitional Provisions) Order 2015 - Motion to Annul |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 26 Oct 2015 | Tax Credits (Income Thresholds and Determination of Rates) (Amendment) Regulations 2015 — Motion to Approve |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 26 Oct 2015 | Tax Credits (Income Thresholds and Determination of Rates) (Amendment) Regulations 2015 — Motion to Approve |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 13 Jul 2015 | Cities and Local Government Devolution Bill [HL] — Report (1st Day) |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 26 Mar 2014 | Defence Reform Bill — Report (2nd Day) |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 28 Jan 2014 | Transparency of Lobbying, Non-Party Campaigning and Trade Union Administration Bill — Commons Reasons and Amendments |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 28 Jan 2014 | Transparency of Lobbying, Non-Party Campaigning and Trade Union Administration Bill — Commons Reasons and Amendments |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 21 Jan 2014 | Transparency of Lobbying, Non-Party Campaigning and Trade Union Administration Bill — Third Reading |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 11 Dec 2013 | Energy Bill — Commons Reason |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 6 Nov 2013 | Energy Bill — Report (3rd Day) |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 29 Oct 2013 | Care Bill [HL] — Third Reading |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 28 Oct 2013 | Energy Bill — Report (1st Day) |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 24 Jul 2013 | Local Audit and Accountability Bill [HL] — Third Reading |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 23 Jul 2013 | Intellectual Property Bill [HL] — Report |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 15 Jul 2013 | Local Audit and Accountability Bill [HL] — Report |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 10 Jul 2013 | Marriage (Same Sex Couples) Bill — Report (2nd Day) |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 8 Jul 2013 | Marriage (Same Sex Couples) Bill — Report (1st Day) |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 4 Jun 2013 | Marriage (Same Sex Couples) Bill — Second Reading (2nd Day) |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 26 Mar 2013 | Growth and Infrastructure Bill — Third Reading |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 25 Mar 2013 | Crime and Courts Bill [HL] — Commons Amendments |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 20 Mar 2013 | Enterprise and Regulatory Reform Bill — Third Reading |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 19 Mar 2013 | Welfare Benefits Up-rating Bill — Report |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 12 Mar 2013 | Growth and Infrastructure Bill — Report (2nd Day) |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 6 Mar 2013 | Enterprise and Regulatory Reform Bill — Report (3rd Day) |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 21 Nov 2012 | Justice and Security Bill [HL] — Report (2nd Day) (Continued) |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 21 Nov 2012 | Justice and Security Bill [HL] — Report (2nd Day) |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 21 Nov 2012 | Justice and Security Bill [HL] — Report (2nd Day) |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 21 Nov 2012 | Justice and Security Bill [HL] — Report (2nd Day) |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 10 Oct 2012 | Local Government Finance Bill — Report (1st Day) |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 28 Mar 2012 | Unfair Dismissal and Statement of Reasons for Dismissal (Variation of Qualifying Period) Order 2012 — Motion to Approve |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 20 Mar 2012 | Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill — Report (5th Day) |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 13 Mar 2012 | Health and Social Care Bill — Report (7th Day) (Continued) |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 13 Mar 2012 | Health and Social Care Bill — Report (7th Day) |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 8 Mar 2012 | Health and Social Care Bill — Report (6th Day) |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 8 Mar 2012 | Health and Social Care Bill — Report (6th Day) |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 14 Feb 2012 | Welfare Reform Bill — Commons Reasons and Amendment |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 25 Jan 2012 | Welfare Reform Bill — Report (6th Day) |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 23 Jan 2012 | Welfare Reform Bill — Report (5th Day) |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 26 Oct 2011 | Education Bill — Report (3rd Day) |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 26 Oct 2011 | Education Bill — Report (3rd Day) |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 26 Oct 2011 | Education Bill — Report (3rd Day) |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 12 Oct 2011 | Health and Social Care Bill — select comittee to scrutinise Bill |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 12 Oct 2011 | Health and Social Care Bill — Reject at Second Reading |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 6 Sep 2011 | Equality Act 2010 (Specific Duties) Regulations 2011 — Motion to Approve |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 6 Sep 2011 | Equality Act 2010 (Specific Duties) Regulations 2011 — Motion to Approve |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 5 Sep 2011 | Localism Bill — Report (1st Day) |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 5 Sep 2011 | Localism Bill — Report (1st Day) |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 15 Jun 2011 | European Union Bill — Expiry of Provisions Requiring Referendum Before Tranfering UK Powers to the EU |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 10 May 2011 | Fixed-term Parliaments Bill — Report (1st Day) |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 10 May 2011 | Fixed-term Parliaments Bill — Report (1st Day) |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 10 May 2011 | Fixed-term Parliaments Bill — Report (1st Day) |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 4 May 2011 | Postal Services Bill — Report (1st Day) |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 4 May 2011 | Postal Services Bill — Report (1st Day) |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 4 May 2011 | Postal Services Bill — Report (1st Day) |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 4 May 2011 | Postal Services Bill — Report (1st Day) |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 28 Mar 2011 | Public Bodies Bill [HL] — Report (2nd Day) |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 23 Mar 2011 | Public Bodies Bill [HL] — Report (1st Day) |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 16 Feb 2011 | Parliamentary Voting System and Constituencies Bill — No Threshold for Making Result of AV Referendum Binding |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 16 Feb 2011 | Parliamentary Voting System and Constituencies Bill — Allowing Greater Variation from Mean Number of Electors in MP Constituency in Exceptional Circumstances |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 8 Feb 2011 | Parliamentary Voting System and Constituencies Bill — Establish Committee on Parliamentary Constituency Reforms |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 8 Feb 2011 | Parliamentary Voting System and Constituencies Bill — Consultation Period on New Constituency Boundaries |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 26 Jan 2011 | Parliamentary Voting System and Constituencies Bill — Minimum of 35 MPs for Wales |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 15 Dec 2010 | Parliamentary Voting System and Constituencies Bill — Political Party Spending During Referenda |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 14 Dec 2010 | University Tuition Fee Cap raise to £9,000 |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 14 Dec 2010 | University Tuition Fee Cap raise to £6,000 |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 8 Dec 2010 | Parliamentary Voting System and Constituencies Bill — Committee (3rd Day) |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 30 Nov 2010 | Parliamentary Voting System and Constituencies Bill — Committee to Decide on Form of AV to Put to Referendum |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 13 Jul 2010 | Academies Bill [HL] — Third Reading — low incidence special educational needs |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 8 Jun 2010 | Local Government Bill [HL] — Motion to refer to the Examiners |
minority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 22 Mar 2010 | Norwich and Norfolk (Structural Changes) Order 2010 — Motion to Approve |
Majority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 9 Mar 2010 | Child Poverty Bill — Report |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 2 Mar 2010 | Equality Bill — Report |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 25 Jan 2010 | Equality Bill — Committee (4th Day) |
Majority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 25 Jan 2010 | Equality Bill — Committee (4th Day) |
Majority | aye |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 25 Jan 2010 | Equality Bill — Committee (4th Day) |
Majority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 9 Nov 2009 | Health Bill [HL] — Commons Amendments |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 9 Jun 2009 | Business Rate Supplements Bill — Report (2nd Day) |
Majority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 2 Jul 2008 | National Insurance Contributions Bill |
Majority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 18 Jun 2008 | Lisbon Treaty — Delay till 20 October 2008 — rejected |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 11 Jun 2008 | Lisbon Treaty — Change the date upon which the Treaty will come into force — rejected |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 26 Mar 2008 | Criminal Justice and Immigration Bill |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 4 Mar 2008 | Climate Change Bill — Statement of emissions — responsibility of Prime Minister |
Majority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 26 Feb 2008 | Dormant Bank and Building Society Accounts Bill [HL] |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 21 Jan 2008 | Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill [HL] — need for a father |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 21 Jan 2008 | Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill [HL] — saviour siblings — definition of serious illness |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 21 Jan 2008 | Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill [HL] — Saviour siblings — life threatening condition |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 18 Jul 2007 | Housing Act 2004 (Commencement No. 8) (England and Wales) Order 2007 |
Majority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 25 Jun 2007 | Statistics and Registration Service Bill |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 27 Mar 2007 | Police (Northern Ireland) Act 2000 (Renewal of Temporary Provisions) Order 2007 |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 30 Oct 2006 | Education and Inspections Bill |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 24 Oct 2006 | Education and Inspections Bill — IGCSE for state schools — rejected |
minority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 30 Jan 2006 | Identity Cards Bill |
Majority | no |
disagrees with policy |
Lords | 30 Jan 2006 | Identity Cards Bill |
Majority | no |
disagrees with policy |