Voting Comparison — Baroness Smith of Gilmorehill
to Lord Mackie of Benshie

Baroness Smith of Gilmorehill

Note: our records only go back to 1997 for the Commons and 2001 for the Lords (more details).

FromToPartyRebellions (explain...)Attendance (explain...)Teller

Voting Differences

HouseDateSubjectBaroness Smith of GilmorehillLord Mackie of BenshieRôle
Lords12 May 2009Health Bill [HL] — Third Reading minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords4 Nov 2008Counter-Terrorism Bill — Post-charge questioning: England and Wales Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords22 Oct 2008Energy Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords7 Oct 2008Pensions Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords7 Jul 2008Housing and Regeneration Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords18 Mar 2008Climate Change Bill — No report on international impace Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords4 Mar 2008Climate Change Bill — Statement of emissions, mode or purpose minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords4 Mar 2008Climate Change Bill — Statement of emissions, delete aviation Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords17 Oct 2007Legal Services Bill [HL] minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords17 Oct 2007Legal Services Bill [HL] minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords17 Oct 2007Legal Services Bill [HL] minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords22 May 2007Corporate Manslaughter and Corporate Homicide Bill — custody minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords25 Apr 2007Serious Crime Bill [HL] — intercept evidence in court minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords16 Apr 2007Legal Services Bill [HL] minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords14 Mar 2007House of Lords Reform — Fully Elected — rejected minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords6 Nov 2006Armed Forces Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords6 Nov 2006Armed Forces Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords6 Nov 2006Armed Forces Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords30 Oct 2006Education and Inspections Bill — Stop faith schools requiring that candidates for headteacher posts belong to the relevant faith — rejected Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords30 Oct 2006Education and Inspections Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords10 Oct 2006Police and Justice Bill minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords28 Jun 2006Civil Aviation Bill minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords27 Jun 2006Government of Wales Bill minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords20 Jun 2006Police and Justice Bill minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords7 Jun 2006Electoral Administration Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords23 May 2006Company Law Reform Bill [HL] minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords23 May 2006Company Law Reform Bill [HL] minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords15 May 2006Use of personal identifier information Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords9 May 2006Company Law Reform Bill [HL] minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords28 Mar 2006Civil Aviation Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords21 Mar 2006Consumer Credit Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords15 Mar 2006Identity Cards Bill minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords7 Mar 2006Compensation Bill [HL] Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords1 Feb 2006Terrorism Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords17 Jan 2006Terrorism Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords10 Jan 2006Road Safety Bill [HL] — speed limits for country lanes Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords10 Jan 2006Road Safety Bill [HL] — identifying new drivers scheme Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords10 Jan 2006Road Safety Bill [HL] — causing death by careless, or inconsiderate, driving minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords10 Jan 2006Road Safety Bill [HL] — speed limits for villages Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords28 Nov 2005On Question, amendments agreed to. Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords18 Oct 2005Charities Bill [HL] Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords18 Oct 2005Charities Bill [HL] Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords28 Jun 2005Charities Bill [HL] minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords6 Apr 2005Serious Organised Crime and Police Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords6 Apr 2005Railways Bill minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords22 Mar 2005Higher Education (Northern Ireland) Order 2005 minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords7 Jun 2004Asylum and Immigration (Treatment of Claimants, etc.) Bill — Give asylum seekers more time to appeal — rejected minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords20 Apr 2004Energy Bill [HL] minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords22 Mar 2004Energy Bill [HL] Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords16 Mar 2004"Piloting conduct at European and local elections minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords3 Feb 2004Justice (Northern Ireland) Bill [HL] minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords20 Jan 2004Planning and Compulsory Purchase Bill minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords17 Dec 2003Procedure of the House: Select Committee Report minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords16 Dec 2003Extradition Act 2003 (Designation of Part 2 Territories) Order 2003 Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords19 Nov 2003Lords Amendment — Criminal Justice Bill — Evidence of bad character minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords4 Nov 2003Criminal Justice Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords3 Nov 2003Anti-social Behaviour Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords27 Oct 2003Extradition Bill minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords22 Oct 2003Extradition Bill minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords14 Oct 2003Criminal Justice Bill minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords17 Sep 2003Lords Amendment minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords15 Sep 2003Northern Ireland (Monitoring Commission etc.) Bill [HL] minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords10 Sep 2003Local Government Bill minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords10 Sep 2003Local Government Bill minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords8 Jul 2003Communications Bill minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords8 Jul 2003Communications Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords24 Jun 2003Water Bill [HL] minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords23 Jun 2003Communications Bill minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords19 May 2003Courts Bill [HL] minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords12 May 2003Courts Bill [HL] Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords17 Mar 2003Community Care (Delayed Discharges etc.) Bill minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords10 Mar 2003Community Care (Delayed Discharges etc.) Bill minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords4 Mar 2003Licensing Bill [HL] minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords18 Feb 2003Community Care (Delayed Discharges etc.) Bill minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords17 Feb 2003Community Care (Delayed Discharges etc.) Bill minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords11 Feb 2003Courts Bill [HL] Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords11 Feb 2003Strategic Investment and Regeneration of Sites (Northern Ireland) Order 2003 Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords30 Oct 2002Adoption and Children Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords29 Oct 2002Animal Health Bill minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords29 Oct 2002Animal Health Bill minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords23 Oct 2002Adoption and Children Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords23 Oct 2002Adoption and Children Bill minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords22 Oct 2002Animal Health Bill minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords17 Oct 2002Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Bill — Refuse support to asylum seekers if they provide false or incomplete information Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords17 Oct 2002Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Bill — Refuse support to asylum seekers who make a late claim Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords10 Oct 2002Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Bill — Do not detain asylum seekers under the age of 18 — rejected Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords8 Oct 2002Animal Health Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords23 Jul 2002Lords Amendment minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords23 Jul 2002Lords Amendment Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords11 Jul 2002Proceeds of Crime Bill minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords26 Jun 2002Education Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords25 Jun 2002Proceeds of Crime Bill minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords30 Apr 2002National Health Service Reform and Health Care Professions Bill minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords9 May 2001Criminal Justice and Police Bill minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords9 May 2001Criminal Justice and Police Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords24 Apr 2001Health and Social Care Bill minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords29 Nov 2000Motion Moved on Consideration of Commons Amendment No. 27C Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords28 Nov 2000Criminal Justice and Court Services Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords31 Oct 2000Criminal Justice and Court Services Bill minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords26 Oct 2000Transport Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords26 Jul 2000Lords Amendment Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords25 Jul 2000Football (Disorder) Bill minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords25 Jul 2000Football (Disorder) Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords12 Jul 2000Government Resources and Accounts Bill minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords12 Jul 2000Government Resources and Accounts Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords11 Jul 2000Utilities Bill minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords27 Jun 2000Child Support, Pensions and Social Security Bill minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords20 Jun 2000Terrorism Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords11 May 2000Political Parties, Elections and Referendums Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords22 Feb 2000Greater London Authority Elections Rules 2000 minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords22 Feb 2000Greater London Authority (Election Expenses) Order 2000 minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords8 Feb 2000Learning and Skills Bill [H.L.] Majorityaye disagrees with policy

About the Project

The Public Whip is a not-for-profit, open source website created in 2003 by Francis Irving and Julian Todd and now run by Bairwell Ltd.

The Whip on the Web

Help keep PublicWhip alive