Voting Comparison — Mr Calum MacDonald MP, Na h-Eileanan an Iar
to Mr David Jamieson MP, Plymouth, Devonport

Mr Calum MacDonald

Note: our records only go back to 1997 for the Commons and 2001 for the Lords (more details).

From	To	Party	Rebellions (explain...)	Attendance (explain...)	Teller
7 Jun 2001	11 Apr 2005	Lab	12 votes out of 860, 1.4%	860 votes out of 1246, 69.0%	0 times
1 May 1997	14 May 2001	Lab	2 votes out of 790, 0.3%	790 votes out of 1273, 62.1%	0 times

Voting Differences

House	Date	Subject	Mr Calum MacDonald	Mr David Jamieson	Rôle
no votes listed
House	Date	Subject	Mr Calum MacDonald	Mr David Jamieson	Rôle
Commons	4 Apr 2001	Election Publications Bill [Lords]	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	4 Apr 2001	Election Publications Bill [Lords]	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	4 Apr 2001	Election Publications Bill [Lords]	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	27 Mar 2001	Social Security Fraud Bill [Lords] (Programme) - Lords messages	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	21 Mar 2001	Foot and Mouth Disease	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	13 Mar 2001	Budget Resolutions and Economic Situation - 36 Landfill tax (rate)	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	13 Mar 2001	Budget Resolutions and Economic Situation - 12 Income tax (charge and rates for 2001-02)	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	13 Mar 2001	Budget Resolutions and Economic Situation - 11 Aggregates levy	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	6 Mar 2001	International Development Bill [Money]	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	6 Mar 2001	International Development Bill (Programme) - Lords amendments and further messages from the Lords	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	14 Feb 2001	Health and Social Care Bill (Programme)(No.2) - Consideration of Lords Amendments and further messages from the Lords	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	7 Feb 2001	Homes Bill - Duty to persons with priority need who are not homeless intentionally	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	31 Jan 2001	Local Government Finance (England)	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	31 Jan 2001	Police	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	29 Jan 2001	Criminal Justice and Police Bill (Programme) - Lords amendments and further messages from the Lords	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	10 Jan 2001	Health and Social Care Bill	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	10 Jan 2001	Health and Social Care Bill	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	9 Jan 2001	Armed Forces Bill (Programme) - Select Committee	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	19 Dec 2000	Human Fertilisation and Embryology (Research Purposes) Regulations	minority	tellaye	disagrees with policy
Commons	29 Nov 2000	Political Parties, Elections and Referendums Bill and Disqualifications Bill (Allocation of Time) - The allotted day12. In this Order, "allotted day" means any day on which the Disqualifications Bill is put down on the main business as first Government Order of the Day.	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	28 Nov 2000	Transport Bill	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	27 Nov 2000	Freedom of Information Bill — Information held for the purpose of investigation	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	22 Nov 2000	Business of the House	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	21 Nov 2000	Police (Northern Ireland) Bill - Discrimination in appointments	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	21 Nov 2000	Police (Northern Ireland) Bill - The Board's policing plan	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	21 Nov 2000	Police (Northern Ireland) Bill - The Secretary of State's long term policing objectives	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	20 Nov 2000	Sittings in Westminster Hall	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	7 Nov 2000	Programming of Bills - I. Programme orders: supplementary provisions	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	7 Nov 2000	Programming of Bills	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	7 Nov 2000	Programming of Bills - I. Programme orders: supplementary provisions	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	6 Nov 2000	Pensions and Pensioners	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	6 Nov 2000	Pensions and Pensioners	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	25 Oct 2000	Fuel Protests	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	25 Oct 2000	Fuel Protests	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	23 Oct 2000	Election of Speaker	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	23 Oct 2000	Election of Speaker	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Commons	23 Oct 2000	Election of Speaker	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Commons	25 Jul 2000	Delegated Legislation - Local Government Finance	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	25 Jul 2000	Delegated Legislation - Local Government Finance	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	25 Jul 2000	Delegated Legislation - Local Government Finance	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	24 Jul 2000	Child Support, Pensions and Social Security Bill - Preservation of rights in respect of additional pensions	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	11 Jul 2000	Delegated Legislation - Education	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	11 Jul 2000	Delegated Legislation - Local Government Finance (England)	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	11 Jul 2000	Delegated Legislation - Environmental Protection	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	11 Jul 2000	Delegated Legislation - Constitutional Law	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	11 Jul 2000	Police (Northern Ireland) Bill	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	3 Jul 2000	Prisoners (Early Release)	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	3 Jul 2000	Prisoners (Early Release)	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	27 Jun 2000	Learning and Skills Bill [Lords] - Sex education	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	20 Jun 2000	Government Planning Policy	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	20 Jun 2000	Government Planning Policy	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	6 Jun 2000	Police (Northern Ireland) Bill	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	6 Jun 2000	Police (Northern Ireland) Bill	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	24 May 2000	Crime	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	22 May 2000	Nuclear Safeguards Bill [Lords] - Rights of searching persons	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	22 May 2000	Nuclear Safeguards Bill [Lords] and Sea Fishing Grants (Charges) Bill (Allocation of Time) - Supplemental Orders	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	16 May 2000	UK Manufacturing and Enterprise	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	10 May 2000	Transport Bill - Purposes	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	10 May 2000	Transport Bill - Use of receipts from licensing schemes	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	9 May 2000	Transport Bill - Transfer to be to not for profit company	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	9 May 2000	Transport Bill - Transfer to be to company owned by Crown	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	17 Apr 2000	European Community Documents - White Paper on Food Safety	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	17 Apr 2000	Finance Bill	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	4 Apr 2000	Freedom of Information Bill — Purpose of Act	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	3 Apr 2000	Child Support, Pensions and Social Security Bill - Widows'/widowers' SERPS entitlements	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	3 Apr 2000	Child Support, Pensions and Social Security Bill - Contributions in Respect of Benefits in Kind: Great Britain	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	27 Mar 2000	"Table	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	27 Mar 2000	Budget Resolutions and Economic Situation - 5. Hydrocarbon oil (rates of duty and rebate)	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	27 Mar 2000	Budget Resolutions and Economic Situation — 2. Beer (rate of duty)	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	20 Mar 2000	Delegated Legislation - Access to Justice	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	20 Mar 2000	Delegated Legislation - Legal Services Commission	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	20 Mar 2000	Countryside and Rights of Way Bill	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	14 Mar 2000	Political Parties, Elections and Referendums Bill - Orders regulating conduct of referendums	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	14 Mar 2000	Political Parties, Elections and Referendums Bill - Special restrictions on referendum expenses by permitted participants	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	29 Feb 2000	Government Resources and Accounts Bill - Public service agencies' accounts: scrutiny	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	21 Feb 2000	Social Security	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	21 Feb 2000	Millennium Dome	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	21 Feb 2000	Millennium Dome	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	8 Feb 2000	Northern Ireland Bill	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	2 Feb 2000	Asylum and Immigration	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	1 Feb 2000	Financial Services and Markets Bill - Reviews	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	1 Feb 2000	Financial Services and Markets Bill - Judicial review	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	27 Jan 2000	Financial Services and Markets Bill - Reports by Director General of Fair Trading	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	24 Jan 2000	Disqualifications Bill	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	13 Dec 1999	Fisheries	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	7 Dec 1999	Freedom of Information Bill — Committee of the whole House	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	7 Dec 1999	Freedom of Information Bill — Second Reading	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	30 Nov 1999	Northern Ireland	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	29 Nov 1999	Electronic Communications Bill	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	9 Nov 1999	Immigration and Asylum Bill - New Clause	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	8 Nov 1999	Greater London Authority Bill - New Clause	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	8 Nov 1999	Greater London Authority Bill - New Clause	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	8 Nov 1999	Greater London Authority Bill - New Clause	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	2 Nov 1999	Planning	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	26 Oct 1999	National Health Service	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	26 Oct 1999	National Health Service	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	20 Oct 1999	Transport Safety	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	13 Jul 1999	Northern Ireland Bill	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	6 Jul 1999	Finance Bill - Repeals	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	15 Jun 1999	Health Bill [Lords] - Repeals	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	15 Jun 1999	Health Bill [Lords] - Health and safety of NHS doctors	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	15 Jun 1999	Health Bill [Lords] - Criteria for appraisals by the National Institute for Clinical Excellence	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	19 May 1999	Delegated Legislation - Terms and conditions of employment	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	19 May 1999	Delegated Legislation - Section 5 of the European Communities (Amendment) Act 1993	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	17 May 1999	Welfare Reform and Pensions Bill - Excessive pension contributions made by persons who have become insolvent	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	30 Mar 1999	Employment Relations Bill - Small employers' exemption	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	29 Mar 1999	New Writ (Newark)	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	15 Mar 1999	Budget Resolutions and Economic Situation - 5. Tobacco products duty (rates)	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	15 Mar 1999	Budget Resolutions and Economic Situation - 3. Hydrocarbon oil duties (rates and rebates)	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	15 Mar 1999	Budget Resolutions and Economic Situation — 2. Sparkling cider (rate of duty)	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	11 Feb 1999	Local Government Finance (Scotland)	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	2 Feb 1999	House of Lords Bill — Second Reading	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	2 Feb 1999	House of Lords Bill — Decline to give a Second Reading — rejected	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	19 Jan 1999	Greater London Authority Bill - Membership of the Authority and the Assembly	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	12 Jan 1999	Local Government Bill	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	12 Jan 1999	Local Government Bill	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	8 Dec 1998	Road Traffic (NHS Charges) Bill	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	2 Dec 1998	European Parliamentary Elections Bill [Money] - Electoral regions in England	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	2 Dec 1998	European Parliamentary Elections Bill (Allocation of Time)	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	4 Nov 1998	The Economy	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	27 Oct 1998	European Parliamentary Elections Bill - Number of MEPs, electoral regions and electoral system	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	26 Oct 1998	Economy	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	29 Jul 1998	Government Policy (Presentation)	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	22 Jul 1998	Government of Wales Bill - Disqualification from being Assembly member	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	22 Jul 1998	Government of Wales Bill - Transfer of Ministerial functions	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	20 Jul 1998	Northern Ireland Bill	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	15 Jul 1998	School Standards and Framework Bill - School organisation committees	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	8 Jul 1998	Competition Bill [Lords] - Abuse of dominant position	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	7 Jul 1998	Select Committees (Information)	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	24 Jun 1998	Human Rights Bill [Lords]	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	24 Jun 1998	Human Rights Bill [Lords] - Proceedings	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	3 Jun 1998	Human Rights Bill [Lords] - Legislation	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	16 Mar 1998	Teaching and Higher Education Bill [Lords]	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	16 Mar 1998	Teaching and Higher Education Bill [Lords]	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	19 Feb 1998	Local Government Finance (Scotland)	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	12 Feb 1998	Scotland Bill	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	12 Feb 1998	Scotland Bill - Scottish Consolidated Fund	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	5 Feb 1998	Local Government Finance	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	5 Feb 1998	Local Government Finance	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	5 Feb 1998	Local Government Finance	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	4 Feb 1998	Public Processions (Northern Ireland) Bill [Lords] - Prohibition orders	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	3 Feb 1998	Delegated Legislation - Northern Ireland	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	3 Feb 1998	Government of Wales Bill - Relations with local government	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	29 Jan 1998	Scotland Bill - Acts of the Scottish Parliament	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	28 Jan 1998	Scotland Bill - Constituencies, regions and regional members	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	27 Jan 1998	London Underground	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	14 Jan 1998	Regional Development Agencies Bill	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	14 Jan 1998	Regional Development Agencies Bill	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	17 Dec 1997	European Communities (Amendment) Bill (Allocation of Time)	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	16 Dec 1997	National Minimum Wage Bill	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	10 Dec 1997	European Community Documents - Employment Law	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	10 Dec 1997	Social Security Bill - Short title, commencement and extent	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	10 Dec 1997	Social Security Bill - Power to reduce child benefit for lone parents	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	10 Dec 1997	Social Security Bill - New schedule 1	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	10 Dec 1997	Social Security Bill - Backdating of benefit	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	10 Dec 1997	Social Security Bill	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	1 Dec 1997	Burdens on Business	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	25 Nov 1997	European Parliamentary Elections Bill	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	24 Nov 1997	Greater London Authority (Referendum) Bill	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	24 Nov 1997	Greater London Authority (Referendum) Bill - Functions of the Local Government Commission	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	24 Nov 1997	Greater London Authority (Referendum) Bill - Counting Officers	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	19 Nov 1997	Greater London Authority (Referendum) Bill	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	11 Nov 1997	Bank of England Bill	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	10 Nov 1997	Greater London Authority (Referendum) Bill	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	4 Nov 1997	Rural Life	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	4 Nov 1997	Rural Life	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	3 Nov 1997	Firearms (Amendment) Bill - Disabled persons: exemption.	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	29 Jul 1997	Table - Tax credits	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	29 Jul 1997	Table	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	22 Jul 1997	Social Security Bill	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	16 Jul 1997	Finance Bill	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	16 Jul 1997	Finance Bill - Pension funds no longer entitled to payment of tax credits	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	14 Jul 1997	Orders of the Day National Health Service (Private Finance) Bill [Lords] - Powers of NHS trusts to enter into agreements	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	8 Jul 1997	Local Government Finance (Supplementary Credit Approvals) Bill - Power in place of duty to specify amortisation period	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	8 Jul 1997	Local Government Finance (Supplementary Credit Approvals) Bill - Local authority debt reduction strategies	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy
Commons	25 Jun 1997	London Underground	Majority	tellaye	agrees with policy
Commons	25 Jun 1997	London Underground - NHS Services (Charging)	Majority	tellno	agrees with policy

Voting Comparison — Mr Calum MacDonald MP, Na h-Eileanan an Iar
to Mr David Jamieson MP, Plymouth, Devonport

Voting Differences

About the Project

The Whip on the Web

Help keep PublicWhip alive

Voting Comparison — Mr Calum MacDonald MP, Na h-Eileanan an Iar to Mr David Jamieson MP, Plymouth, Devonport

Voting Differences

About the Project

The Whip on the Web

Help keep PublicWhip alive

Voting Comparison — Mr Calum MacDonald MP, Na h-Eileanan an Iar
to Mr David Jamieson MP, Plymouth, Devonport