Voting Comparison — Jim Murphy MP, East Renfrewshire
to John MacDougall MP, Glenrothes

Jim Murphy

Note: our records only go back to 1997 for the Commons and 2001 for the Lords (more details).

FromToPartyRebellions (explain...)Attendance (explain...)Teller
6 May 2010 30 Mar 2015 Lab 0 votes out of 634, 0.0% 634 votes out of 1239, 51.2% 0 times
5 May 2005 12 Apr 2010 Lab 11 votes out of 896, 1.2% 896 votes out of 1288, 69.6% 0 times
7 Jun 2001 11 Apr 2005 Lab 12 votes out of 1072, 1.1% 1072 votes out of 1246, 86.0% 120 times
1 May 1997 14 May 2001 Lab 2 votes out of 721, 0.3% 721 votes out of 1273, 56.6% 0 times

Voting Differences

HouseDateSubjectJim MurphyJohn MacDougallRôle
no votes listed
HouseDateSubjectJim MurphyJohn MacDougallRôle
no votes listed
HouseDateSubjectJim MurphyJohn MacDougallRôle
Commons5 Apr 2005Mental Capacity Bill — Clause 2 — People who lack capacity tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons5 Apr 2005Mental Capacity Bill — Clause 2 — People who lack capacity tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons16 Mar 2005Constitutional Reform Bill [Lords] (Programme) (No. 3) tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons9 Mar 2005Prevention of Terrorism Bill — Rejection of New Lords' Amendment — Sunset Clause tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons9 Mar 2005Prevention of Terrorism Bill — Rejection of New Lords' Clause — Review by Privy Council tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons21 Feb 2005Clause 2 — Gating Orders — Clause 99 — Abandoned shopping and luggage trolleys tellnono agrees with policy
Commons21 Feb 2005Clean Neighbourhoods and Environment Bill — Clause 50 — Power to require owner of land to remove waste tellnono agrees with policy
Commons21 Feb 2005Clean Neighbourhoods and Environment Bill — New Clause 15 — Waste Minimisation tellnono agrees with policy
Commons21 Feb 2005Clean Neighbourhoods and Environment Bill — New Clause 2 — Duty to keep land and highways clear of litter tellnono agrees with policy
Commons10 Feb 2005Identity Cards Bill (Programme) (No. 2) tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons7 Feb 2005Serious Organized Crime and Police Bill -- Authorisation for demonstrations in a designated area tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons7 Feb 2005Serious Organized Crime and Police Bill -- Demonstrating without authorisation in a designated area tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons3 Feb 2005Child Benefit Bill — New Clause 1 — Regulations made by the Treasury: qualifying courses tellnono agrees with policy
Commons27 Jan 2005Railways Bill — New Clause 1 — Provision of First Class Passenger Accommodation tellnono agrees with policy
Commons26 Jan 2005Car Mileage Allowance Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Commons19 Jan 2005Value for Taxpayers' Money tellnono agrees with policy
Commons14 Dec 2004Mental Capacity Bill — Schedule 3 — Property and affairs: supplementary provisions tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons9 Nov 2004Civil Partnerships Bill [Lords] — Third Reading tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons9 Nov 2004Categories of civil partners other than same sex couples tellnono agrees with policy
Commons27 Oct 2004New Clause 10 — Victims of persons subject to hospital order with restriction order: representations — Clause 22 — Procedure for determining fitness to plead: England and Wales tellnono agrees with policy
Commons27 Oct 2004New Clause 10 — Victims of persons subject to hospital order with restriction order: representations — Clause 22 — Procedure for determining fitness to plead: England and Wales tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons27 Oct 2004New Clause 10 — Victims of persons subject to hospital order with restriction order: representations — Clause 17 — Application by prosecution for certain counts to be tried without a jury tellnono agrees with policy
Commons26 Oct 2004Removal of References to Strangers tellayeno disagrees with policy
Commons11 Oct 2004Mental Capacity Bill (Programme) tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons11 Oct 2004Mental Capacity Bill tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons7 Jul 2004Clause 5 — Rates — Schedule 15 — Charge to income tax on benefits received by former owner of property tellnono agrees with policy
Commons24 May 2004Civil Contingencies Bill — New Clause 3 — Emergency Powers Committee tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons24 May 2004Civil Contingencies Bill — New Clause 3 — Emergency Powers Committee tellnono agrees with policy
Commons24 May 2004Civil Contingencies Bill — New Clause 2 — Emergency Public Education And Training Board tellnono agrees with policy
Commons27 Apr 2004Finance Bill — [1st Allotted Day] — Clause 28 — The Non-Corporate Distribution Rate tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons23 Mar 2004Budget Resolutions and Economic Situation — 36. Construction industry scheme tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons23 Mar 2004Budget Resolutions and Economic Situation — 36. Construction industry scheme tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons23 Mar 2004Budget Resolutions and Economic Situation — 36. Construction industry scheme tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons23 Mar 2004Budget Resolutions 2004 — Non-Corporate Distribution Rate tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons9 Mar 2004Young People and Democracy tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons9 Mar 2004Young People and Democracy tellnono agrees with policy
Commons1 Mar 2004Asylum and Immigration (Treatment of Claimants, Etc.) Bill — Burden of proof on prosecution rather than defendant in cases where immigrants to not have travel documents — rejected tellnono agrees with policy
Commons2 Feb 2004Horserace Betting and Olympic Lottery Bill — Clause 15 — Abolition of levy tellnono agrees with policy
Commons12 Jan 2004Housing Bill tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons12 Jan 2004Housing Bill tellnono agrees with policy
Commons16 Dec 2003European Parliamentary and Local Elections (Pilots) Bill — New Clause 4 — Conduct of elections under a pilot order tellnono agrees with policy
Commons16 Dec 2003European Parliamentary and Local Elections (Pilots) Bill — New Clause 2 — Additional provisions in respect of postal voting tellnono agrees with policy
Commons9 Dec 2003Planning and Compulsory Purchase Bill — [2nd Allotted Day] — New Clause 10 — Local Development Plan tellnono agrees with policy
Commons19 Nov 2003Health and Social Care (Community Health and Standards) Bill — Clause 1 — NHS Foundation Trusts tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons10 Nov 2003Water Bill [Lords] — Clause 58 — Fluoridation of Water Supplies tellayeno disagrees with policy
Commons10 Nov 2003Water Bill [Lords] — New Clause 1 — Prohibition of Artificial Fluoridation of Water Supplies tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons27 Oct 2003Defence Policy — NATO and Europe tellnono agrees with policy
Commons8 Sep 2003Water Bill [Lords] (Programme) tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons8 Sep 2003Water Bill tellnono agrees with policy
Commons24 Jun 2003Licensing Bill [Lords] tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons16 Jun 2003Licensing Bill [Lords] — Schedule 8 — Transitional Provision Etc. tellnono agrees with policy
Commons3 Jun 2003Fire Services Bill (Programme) (No. 2) tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons19 May 2003Criminal Justice Bill — [2nd Allotted Day] — New Clause 15 — Taking Non-Intimate Samples Without Consent tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons19 May 2003Criminal Justice Bill — [2nd Allotted Day] — Government New Clause 14 — Taking Fingerprints Without Consent tellnono agrees with policy
Commons19 May 2003Criminal Justice Bill (Programme) (No. 5) tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons14 May 2003Finance Bill — Clause 139 — Employee Securities and Options tellnono agrees with policy
Commons14 May 2003Finance Bill — Clause 138 — Approved Share Plans and Schemes tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons14 May 2003Finance Bill — Clause 135 — Provision of Services Through Intermediary tellnono agrees with policy
Commons13 May 2003Finance Bill — Clause 9 — Bingo Duty tellnono agrees with policy
Commons2 Apr 2003Criminal Justice Bill tellnono agrees with policy
Commons1 Apr 2003Crime (International Co-Operation) Bill [Lords] (Programme) tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons25 Mar 2003Extradition Bill — Clause 63 — Extradition Offences: Person Not Sentenced for Offence tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons10 Mar 2003Local Government Bill — [2nd Allotted Day] — New Clause 11 — Repeal of Section 2A of Local Government Act 1986 tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons10 Mar 2003Local Government Bill — [2nd Allotted Day] — New Clause 11 — Repeal of Section 2A of Local Government Act 1986 tellnono agrees with policy
Commons24 Feb 2003Industrial Development (Financial Assistance) Bill tellnono agrees with policy
Commons10 Feb 2003Police (Northern Ireland) Bill [Lords] tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons8 Jan 2003Foundation Hospitals tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons8 Jan 2003Foundation Hospitals tellnono agrees with policy
Commons9 Dec 2002Extradition Bill tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons27 Nov 2002Health (Wales) Bill (Programme) tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons5 Nov 2002Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Bill — New Clause tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons5 Nov 2002Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Bill — New Clause tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons29 Oct 2002Start Sittings of the House of Commons at 11.30 am rather than 14.30 on Tuesdays minorityaye disagrees with policy
Commons29 Oct 2002New Provision for Earlier Sittings on Wednesdays, and for Thursdays and Fridays minorityaye disagrees with policy
Commons29 Oct 2002New Provision for Earlier Sittings on Wednesdays, and for Thursdays and Fridays minorityno disagrees with policy
Commons29 Oct 2002Modernisation of the House of Commons minorityno disagrees with policy
Commons22 Oct 2002Nuclear Power — Will be addressed on its own merits tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons22 Oct 2002Nuclear Power — Not competitive — rejected tellnono agrees with policy
Commons15 Oct 2002Urban Post Office Reinvention Programme — £210 million authorization tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons15 Jul 2002Education Bill — Clause 41 — Schools forums tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons15 Jul 2002Education Bill — Before Clause 18 tellayeaye agrees with policy
Commons10 Jul 2002Police Reform Bill [Lords] — [2nd allotted day] — New Clause 8 — Continued deployment of traffic wardens tellnono agrees with policy
Commons10 Jul 2002Police Reform Bill [Lords] — [2nd allotted day] — Clause 5 — Directions to chief officers tellnono agrees with policy
Commons25 Jun 2002Mental Health tellnono agrees with policy
Commons11 Jul 2001European Communities (Amendment) Bill — 1st Allotted Day — [Sir Alan Haselhurst in the Chair] — Clause 1 — Incorporation of provisions of the Treaty of Nice Majorityaye disagrees with policy
HouseDateSubjectJim MurphyJohn MacDougallRôle
no votes listed

About the Project

The Public Whip is a not-for-profit, open source website created in 2003 by Francis Irving and Julian Todd and now run by Bairwell Ltd.

The Whip on the Web

Help keep PublicWhip alive