Voting Comparison — Lord Maxton
to Lord Mackie of Benshie

Lord Maxton

Note: our records only go back to 1997 for the Commons and 2001 for the Lords (more details).

Constituency	From	To	Party	Rebellions (explain...)	Attendance (explain...)	Teller
House of Lords	7 Jul 2004	still in office	Lab	17 votes out of 1614, 1.1%	1614 votes out of 2110, 76.5%	0 times
Glasgow Cathcart	1 May 1997	14 May 2001	Lab	8 votes out of 853, 0.9%	853 votes out of 1273, 67.0%	0 times

Voting Differences

House	Date	Subject	Lord Maxton	Lord Mackie of Benshie	Rôle
Lords	29 Oct 2009	Coroners and Justice Bill — Report (4th Day)	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	17 Jun 2009	Political Parties and Elections Bill — Report (2nd Day)	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	17 Jun 2009	Political Parties and Elections Bill — Report (2nd Day)	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	17 Jun 2009	Political Parties and Elections Bill — Report (2nd Day)	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	12 May 2009	Health Bill [HL] — Third Reading	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	1 Apr 2009	Borders, Citizenship and Immigration Bill [HL] — Report (2nd Day) — fresh asylum claims and appeals	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	1 Apr 2009	Borders, Citizenship and Immigration Bill [HL] — Report (2nd Day) Common Travel Area (Northern Ireland)	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	1 Apr 2009	Borders, Citizenship and Immigration Bill [HL] — Report (2nd Day) — Common Travel Area	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	5 Mar 2009	Control Orders — Annual renewal 2009 — Declines to approve — rejected	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	19 Nov 2008	Dormant Bank and Building Society Accounts Bill [HL]	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	18 Nov 2008	Local Transport Bill [HL]	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	18 Nov 2008	Planning Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	18 Nov 2008	Planning Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	18 Nov 2008	Planning Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	4 Nov 2008	Counter-Terrorism Bill — Post-charge questioning: England and Wales	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	13 Oct 2008	Counter-Terrorism Bill — No extension of period of detention beyond 28 days	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	7 Oct 2008	Pensions Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	15 Jul 2008	Criminal Evidence (Witness Anonymity) Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	7 Jul 2008	Housing and Regeneration Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	2 Jul 2008	Pensions Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	2 Jul 2008	National Insurance Contributions Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	23 Jun 2008	Pensions Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	23 Jun 2008	Pensions Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	17 Jun 2008	Pensions Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	7 May 2008	Criminal Justice and Immigration Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	23 Apr 2008	Criminal Justice and Immigration Bill — 10 year sunset for Violent Offender Orders	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	23 Apr 2008	Criminal Justice and Immigration Bill — disclosure of information by data controllers	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	23 Apr 2008	Criminal Justice and Immigration Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	19 Mar 2008	Regulatory Enforcement and Sanctions Bill [HL]	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	18 Mar 2008	Climate Change Bill — No report on international impace	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	11 Mar 2008	Climate Change Bill — Adaptation Sub-Committee	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	11 Mar 2008	Climate Change Bill — UK domestic effort	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	4 Mar 2008	Cheshire (Structural Changes) Order 2008	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	4 Mar 2008	Climate Change Bill — Statement of emissions, mode or purpose	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	4 Mar 2008	Climate Change Bill — Statement of emissions, delete aviation	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	4 Mar 2008	Climate Change Bill — Statement of emissions — responsibility of Prime Minister	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	26 Feb 2008	Dormant Bank and Building Society Accounts Bill [HL]	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	24 Oct 2007	Serious Crime Bill [HL]	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	17 Oct 2007	Legal Services Bill [HL]	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	17 Oct 2007	Legal Services Bill [HL]	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	17 Oct 2007	Legal Services Bill [HL]	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	17 Oct 2007	Legal Services Bill [HL]	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	9 Oct 2007	UK Borders Bill — The Border and Immigration Agency must ensure the welfare of children as part of its remit — rejected	no	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	9 Oct 2007	Greater London Authority Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	8 Oct 2007	Local Government and Public Involvement in Health Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	25 Jul 2007	Further Education and Training Bill [HL]	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	17 Jul 2007	Corporate Manslaughter and Corporate Homicide Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	4 Jul 2007	Pensions Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	4 Jul 2007	Pensions Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	3 Jul 2007	Offender Management Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	27 Jun 2007	Offender Management Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	27 Jun 2007	Offender Management Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	26 Jun 2007	Greater London Authority Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	19 Jun 2007	Community Drivers' Hours and Recording Equipment Regulations 2007	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	19 Jun 2007	Greater London Authority Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	23 May 2007	Offender Management Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	22 May 2007	Corporate Manslaughter and Corporate Homicide Bill — custody	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	15 May 2007	Legal Services Bill [HL]	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	25 Apr 2007	Serious Crime Bill [HL]	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	25 Apr 2007	Serious Crime Bill [HL] — intercept evidence in court	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	25 Apr 2007	Serious Crime Bill [HL]	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	24 Apr 2007	Statistics and Registration Service Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	24 Apr 2007	Statistics and Registration Service Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	18 Apr 2007	Legal Services Bill [HL]	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	18 Apr 2007	Legal Services Bill [HL]	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	18 Apr 2007	Legal Services Bill [HL]	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	16 Apr 2007	Legal Services Bill [HL]	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	16 Apr 2007	Legal Services Bill [HL]	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	28 Mar 2007	Gambling (Geographical Distribution of Casino Premises Licences) Order 2007	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	27 Mar 2007	Police (Northern Ireland) Act 2000 (Renewal of Temporary Provisions) Order 2007	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	20 Mar 2007	Fraud (Trials without a Jury) Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	14 Mar 2007	House of Lords Reform — Fully Elected — rejected	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Lords	27 Feb 2007	Further Education and Training Bill [HL]	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	19 Feb 2007	Mental Health Bill [HL]	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	19 Feb 2007	Mental Health Bill [HL] — Treatability test.	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	11 Dec 2006	Water and Sewerage Services (Northern Ireland) Order 2006	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	7 Nov 2006	Police and Justice Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	6 Nov 2006	Armed Forces Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	6 Nov 2006	Armed Forces Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	6 Nov 2006	Armed Forces Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	6 Nov 2006	Armed Forces Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	31 Oct 2006	Armed Forces Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	31 Oct 2006	Armed Forces Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	30 Oct 2006	Education and Inspections Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	30 Oct 2006	Education and Inspections Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	25 Oct 2006	Violent Crime Reduction Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	25 Oct 2006	NHS Redress Bill [HL]	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	16 Oct 2006	Violent Crime Reduction Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	16 Oct 2006	Violent Crime Reduction Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	10 Oct 2006	Police and Justice Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	9 Oct 2006	Police and Justice Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	9 Oct 2006	Police and Justice Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	11 Jul 2006	Police and Justice Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	28 Jun 2006	Civil Aviation Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	28 Jun 2006	Civil Aviation Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	27 Jun 2006	Government of Wales Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	27 Jun 2006	Government of Wales Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	27 Jun 2006	Government of Wales Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	27 Jun 2006	Government of Wales Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	26 Jun 2006	Childcare Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	20 Jun 2006	Police and Justice Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	20 Jun 2006	Electoral Administration Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	7 Jun 2006	Electoral Administration Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	6 Jun 2006	Government of Wales Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	23 May 2006	Company Law Reform Bill [HL]	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	23 May 2006	Company Law Reform Bill [HL]	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	22 May 2006	Criminal Justice Act 2003 (c. 44)	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	22 May 2006	Violent Crime Reduction Bill — police power to search for firearms	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	15 May 2006	Use of personal identifier information	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	9 May 2006	Company Law Reform Bill [HL]	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	26 Apr 2006	Violent Crime Reduction Bill — appeals process for alcohol disorder zones	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	26 Apr 2006	Local Government (Boundaries) (Northern Ireland) Order 2006	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	26 Apr 2006	Violent Crime Reduction Bill — revenue from alcohol disorder zones	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	19 Apr 2006	Government of Wales Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	28 Mar 2006	Civil Aviation Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	28 Mar 2006	Identity Cards Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	20 Mar 2006	Natural Environment and Rural Communities Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	15 Mar 2006	Identity Cards Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	8 Mar 2006	Civil Aviation Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	7 Mar 2006	Compensation Bill [HL]	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	7 Mar 2006	Compensation Bill [HL]	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	6 Mar 2006	London Olympic Games and Paralympic Games Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	6 Mar 2006	Identity Cards Bill — Voluntary registration when applying for a passport — insisted	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	28 Feb 2006	Motion A	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	28 Feb 2006	Motion A	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	15 Feb 2006	NHS Redress Bill [HL]	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	7 Feb 2006	Immigration, Asylum and Nationality Bill — Remove a clause which allows immigrants to be removed on national security grounds — rejected	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	1 Feb 2006	Terrorism Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	1 Feb 2006	Terrorism Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	1 Feb 2006	Terrorism Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	31 Jan 2006	Speakership of the House	minority	no	disagrees with policy
Lords	30 Jan 2006	Identity Cards Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	30 Jan 2006	Identity Cards Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	25 Jan 2006	Terrorism Bill — Consent to prosecution for terrorism in other countries	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	23 Jan 2006	Identity Cards Bill (amendment 46: compulsion to register)	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	23 Jan 2006	Identity Cards Bill (amendment 38: compulsion via designated documents)	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	17 Jan 2006	Terrorism Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	17 Jan 2006	Terrorism Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	17 Jan 2006	Terrorism Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	16 Jan 2006	Identity Cards Bill (restricted scope: efficiency of public services)	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	16 Jan 2006	Identity Cards Bill (security of data)	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	16 Jan 2006	Identity Cards Bill — Report of Costs and Benefits	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	10 Jan 2006	Road Safety Bill [HL] — speed limits for country lanes	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	10 Jan 2006	Road Safety Bill [HL] — identifying new drivers scheme	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	10 Jan 2006	Road Safety Bill [HL] — causing death by careless, or inconsiderate, driving	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	10 Jan 2006	Road Safety Bill [HL] — speed limits for villages	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	14 Dec 2005	Identity Cards Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	30 Nov 2005	Commons Bill [HL]	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	30 Nov 2005	Commons Bill [HL]	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	29 Nov 2005	Road Safety Bill [HL] — Compulsory surrender of old-form licences	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	28 Nov 2005	On Question, amendments agreed to.	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	16 Nov 2005	Identity Cards Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	14 Nov 2005	Licensing Act 2003 (Second Appointed Day) Order 2005	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	9 Nov 2005	Equality Bill [HL]	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	18 Oct 2005	Charities Bill [HL]	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	28 Jun 2005	Charities Bill [HL]	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	6 Apr 2005	Serious Organised Crime and Police Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	6 Apr 2005	Serious Organised Crime and Police Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	6 Apr 2005	Railways Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	6 Apr 2005	Railways Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	22 Mar 2005	Commissioners for Revenue and Customs Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	22 Mar 2005	Higher Education (Northern Ireland) Order 2005	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	10 Mar 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	10 Mar 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	10 Mar 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	8 Mar 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	8 Mar 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	8 Mar 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	8 Mar 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	8 Mar 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	8 Mar 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	7 Mar 2005	Prevention of Terrorism Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	2 Mar 2005	Education Bill — Requirements to be Registered with General Teaching Council — rejected	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	2 Mar 2005	Education Bill [HL]	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	2 Mar 2005	Education Bill — Amendment No. 3	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	28 Feb 2005	Disability Discrimination Bill [HL]	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	28 Feb 2005	Inquiries Bill [HL]	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	28 Feb 2005	Inquiries Bill [HL]	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	21 Dec 2004	Administration and Works Committee	Majority	no	disagrees with policy
Lords	17 Nov 2004	Hunting Bill — Lords Amendment — commencement	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	17 Nov 2004	Hunting Bill — Lords Amendment	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	17 Nov 2004	Pensions Bill — Lords Amendment	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	16 Nov 2004	Lords Amendment	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	16 Nov 2004	Civil Contingencies Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	11 Nov 2004	Hunting Bill: amendment — commencement	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	10 Nov 2004	Commons Amendment	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	10 Nov 2004	Commons Amendment	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	10 Nov 2004	Commons Amendment	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	9 Nov 2004	Civil Contingencies Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	9 Nov 2004	Civil Contingencies Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	4 Nov 2004	Pensions Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	3 Nov 2004	Housing Bill	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	2 Nov 2004	"Surcharges	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	2 Nov 2004	"Surcharges	Majority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	2 Nov 2004	Armed Forces (Pensions and Compensation) Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	26 Oct 2004	Hunting Bill: amendment — registered hunting	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	25 Oct 2004	Human Tissue Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
Lords	8 Sep 2004	Armed Forces (Pensions and Compensation) Bill	minority	aye	disagrees with policy
House	Date	Subject	Mr John Maxton	Lord Mackie of Benshie	Rôle
no votes listed

Voting Comparison — Lord Maxton
to Lord Mackie of Benshie

Voting Differences

About the Project

The Whip on the Web

Help keep PublicWhip alive

Voting Comparison — Lord Maxton to Lord Mackie of Benshie

Voting Differences

About the Project

The Whip on the Web

Help keep PublicWhip alive

Voting Comparison — Lord Maxton
to Lord Mackie of Benshie