Voting Comparison — Malcolm Chisholm MSP, Edinburgh North and Leith
to Jackson Carlaw MSP, West of Scotland
Malcolm Chisholm
Note: our records only go back to 1997 for the Commons and 2001 for the Lords (more details).
| Constituency | From | To | Party | Rebellions (explain...) | Attendance (explain...) | Teller |
| Edinburgh Northern and Leith | 6 May 2011 | 23 Mar 2016 | Lab | votes out of | votes out of | n/a |
| Edinburgh North and Leith | 3 May 2007 | 23 Mar 2011 | Lab | 7 votes out of 589, 1.2% | 589 votes out of 606, 97.2% | n/a |
| Edinburgh North and Leith | 1 May 2003 | 2 Apr 2007 | Lab | 5 votes out of 1387, 0.4% | 1387 votes out of 1411, 98.3% | n/a |
| Edinburgh North and Leith | 6 May 1999 | 31 Mar 2003 | Lab | 5 votes out of 1199, 0.4% | 1199 votes out of 1287, 93.2% | n/a |
| Edinburgh North and Leith | 1 May 1997 | 14 May 2001 | Lab | 4 votes out of 494, 0.8% | 494 votes out of 1273, 38.8% | 0 times |
Voting Differences
| House | Date | Subject | Malcolm Chisholm | Jackson Carlaw | Rôle | |
| no votes listed | ||||||
| House | Date | Subject | Malcolm Chisholm | Jackson Carlaw | Rôle | |
| Scotland | 11 Mar 2010 | [S3M-5926] Decision Time | abstention | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 11 Mar 2010 | [S3M-5926.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 10 Mar 2010 | [S3M-5908.4 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 10 Mar 2010 | [S3M-5908.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 25 Feb 2010 | [S3M-5808] Decision Time | abstention | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 25 Feb 2010 | [S3M-5808.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | abstention | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 25 Feb 2010 | [S3M-5808.2.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | abstention | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 25 Feb 2010 | [S3M-5809.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 4 Feb 2010 | Marine (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Long title | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 4 Feb 2010 | Marine (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 145 — Orders and regulations | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 4 Feb 2010 | Marine (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 132 — Power to direct vessel or marine installation to port | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 4 Feb 2010 | Marine (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — After section 79 | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 4 Feb 2010 | Marine (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 79 — Representations and hearings in relation to proposed marine conservation orders etc | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 4 Feb 2010 | Marine (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 79 — Representations and hearings in relation to proposed marine conservation orders etc | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 4 Feb 2010 | Marine (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 69 — Advice etc by Scottish Natural Heritage as regards Nature Conservation MPAs and Demonstration and Research MPAs | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 4 Feb 2010 | Marine (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 59 — Nature Conservation MPAs: additional requirements relating to designation | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 4 Feb 2010 | Marine (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 25 — Activities below specified threshold of environmental impact | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 4 Feb 2010 | Marine (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — After section 8 | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 4 Feb 2010 | Marine (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 3 — National marine plan and regional marine plans | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 3 Feb 2010 | [S3M-5637] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 3 Feb 2010 | [S3M-5637.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 27 Jan 2010 | [S3M-5560] Decision Time | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 27 Jan 2010 | Tobacco and Primary Medical Services (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 35 — Short title and commencement | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 27 Jan 2010 | Tobacco and Primary Medical Services (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 30 — Section 17C arrangements: persons with whom agreements can be made | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 27 Jan 2010 | Tobacco and Primary Medical Services (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 29 — Contractual arrangements for the provision of primary medical services | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 27 Jan 2010 | Tobacco and Primary Medical Services (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 6 — Prohibition of vending machines for the sale of tobacco products | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 27 Jan 2010 | Tobacco and Primary Medical Services (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 5 — Display of warning statements | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 27 Jan 2010 | Tobacco and Primary Medical Services (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 2 — Displays which are also advertisements | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 27 Jan 2010 | Tobacco and Primary Medical Services (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — After Section 1 | aye | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 27 Jan 2010 | Tobacco and Primary Medical Services (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 1 — Prohibition of tobacco displays etc | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 21 Jan 2010 | [S3M-5572.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | abstention | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 21 Jan 2010 | [S3M-5572.3 (Amendment)] Decision Time | abstention | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 20 Jan 2010 | [S3M-5541] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 14 Jan 2010 | [S3M-5515] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 14 Jan 2010 | [S3M-5515.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 14 Jan 2010 | [S3M-5512.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 3 Dec 2009 | [S3M-5334] Decision Time | Majority | abstention | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 3 Dec 2009 | [S3M-5334.3 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 3 Dec 2009 | [S3M-5334.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | abstention | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 3 Dec 2009 | [S3M-5313] Minister | abstention | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 2 Dec 2009 | [S3M-5307.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | abstention | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 25 Nov 2009 | [S3M-5267.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 25 Nov 2009 | [S3M-5266] Decision Time | Majority | abstention | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 25 Nov 2009 | [S3M-5266.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | abstention | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 25 Nov 2009 | [S3M-5266.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | abstention | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 19 Nov 2009 | [S3M-5221] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 19 Nov 2009 | [S3M-5221.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 19 Nov 2009 | [S3M-5221.1.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 4 Nov 2009 | [S3M-5110.3 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 4 Nov 2009 | [S3M-5110.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | no | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 29 Oct 2009 | [S3M-5071] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 29 Oct 2009 | [S3M-5071.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 29 Oct 2009 | [S3M-5071.3 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 8 Oct 2009 | [S3M-4988.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 24 Sep 2009 | [S3M-4807] Decision Time | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 24 Sep 2009 | [S3M-4911] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 24 Sep 2009 | [S3M-4911.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | abstention | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 17 Sep 2009 | [S3M-4861] Decision Time | Majority | abstention | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 17 Sep 2009 | [S3M-4861.3 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 17 Sep 2009 | [S3M-4861.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 9 Sep 2009 | [S3M-4797.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | aye | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 9 Sep 2009 | [S3M-4811] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 2 Sep 2009 | [S3M-4748] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 2 Sep 2009 | [S3M-4748.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 2 Sep 2009 | [S3M-4748.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 2 Sep 2009 | [S3M-4748.1.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 24 Jun 2009 | Climate Change (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 53 — Information on waste | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 24 Jun 2009 | Climate Change (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 36 — Duties of public bodies relating to climate change | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 24 Jun 2009 | Climate Change (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 36 — Duties of public bodies relating to climate change | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 24 Jun 2009 | Climate Change (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 18A — Limits on use of carbon units | aye | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 24 Jun 2009 | Climate Change (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 12 — The net Scottish emissions account | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 24 Jun 2009 | Climate Change (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 7A — Achievement of annual targets: domestic effort target | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 24 Jun 2009 | Climate Change (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 4 — Setting annual targets | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 24 Jun 2009 | Climate Change (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 3 — Annual targets | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 11 Jun 2009 | [S3M-4348] Decision Time | abstention | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 11 Jun 2009 | [S3M-4348.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 11 Jun 2009 | [S3M-4348.4 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 11 Jun 2009 | [S3M-4348.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 11 Jun 2009 | [S3M-4344] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 10 Jun 2009 | Sexual Offences (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Schedule 1 — Penalties | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 10 Jun 2009 | Sexual Offences (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Schedule 1 — Penalties | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 10 Jun 2009 | Sexual Offences (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 37 — Penalties | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 28 May 2009 | [S3M-4246.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 21 May 2009 | [S3M-4187.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 20 May 2009 | Education (Additional Support for Learning) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 7B — Provision by education authority for education of pupils belonging to areas of other authorities: recovery of costs where pupil has additional support needs | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 20 May 2009 | Education (Additional Support for Learning) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 5C — Additional support needs etc: specified children and young people | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 7 May 2009 | [S3M-4067] Decision Time | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 7 May 2009 | [S3M-4067.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 7 May 2009 | [S3M-4067.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 7 May 2009 | [S3M-3963.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 29 Apr 2009 | [S3M-3994] Decision Time | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 29 Apr 2009 | [S3M-3994.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 29 Apr 2009 | [S3M-3994.3 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 23 Apr 2009 | [S3M-3938] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 23 Apr 2009 | [S3M-3938.3 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | abstention | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 23 Apr 2009 | [S3M-3938.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 23 Apr 2009 | [S3M-3947] Decision Time | Majority | abstention | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 23 Apr 2009 | [S3M-3947.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 23 Apr 2009 | [S3M-3947.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 2 Apr 2009 | [S3M-3849] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 2 Apr 2009 | [S3M-3849.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 2 Apr 2009 | [S3M-3849.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 2 Apr 2009 | [S3M-3848] Decision Time | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 2 Apr 2009 | [S3M-3848.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 2 Apr 2009 | [S3M-3848.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 2 Apr 2009 | [S3M-3848.3 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 26 Mar 2009 | [S3M-3778] Decision Time | Majority | abstention | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 26 Mar 2009 | [S3M-3778.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 26 Mar 2009 | [S3M-3778.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 26 Mar 2009 | [S3M-3796] Decision Time | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 26 Mar 2009 | [S3M-3796.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 19 Mar 2009 | [S3M-3726.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 19 Mar 2009 | [S3M-3726.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | abstention | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 19 Mar 2009 | [S3M-3726.1.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 12 Mar 2009 | [S3M-3674] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 12 Mar 2009 | [S3M-3674.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 12 Mar 2009 | Health Boards (Membership and Elections) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 2 — Health Board elections | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 12 Mar 2009 | Health Boards (Membership and Elections) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 2 — Health Board elections | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 12 Mar 2009 | Health Boards (Membership and Elections) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 1 — Constitution of Health Boards | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 12 Mar 2009 | Health Boards (Membership and Elections) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 1 — Constitution of Health Boards | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 11 Mar 2009 | [S3M-3542] Decision Time | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 5 Mar 2009 | [S3M-3584] Decision Time | abstention | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 5 Mar 2009 | [S3M-3584.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | abstention | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 26 Feb 2009 | [S3M-3528.3 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 12 Feb 2009 | [S3M-3427.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 12 Feb 2009 | [S3M-3428] Decision Time | aye | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 12 Feb 2009 | [S3M-3428.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 12 Feb 2009 | [S3M-3428.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 29 Jan 2009 | [S3M-3325] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 29 Jan 2009 | [S3M-3325.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 29 Jan 2009 | [S3M-3325.1.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 28 Jan 2009 | [S3M-3299] Decision Time | no | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 21 Jan 2009 | [S3M-3250.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | abstention | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 21 Jan 2009 | [S3M-3250.3 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | abstention | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 15 Jan 2009 | [S3M-3214.4 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 15 Jan 2009 | [S3M-3214.3 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 8 Jan 2009 | [S3M-3174.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 8 Jan 2009 | [S3M-3173.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 7 Jan 2009 | [S3M-3164.3 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 11 Dec 2008 | [S3M-3078] Decision Time | Majority | abstention | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 11 Dec 2008 | [S3M-3078.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | abstention | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 11 Dec 2008 | [S3M-3075] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 11 Dec 2008 | [S3M-3075.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 27 Nov 2008 | [S3M-2958] Decision Time | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 27 Nov 2008 | [S3M-2958.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 27 Nov 2008 | [S3M-2966.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 19 Nov 2008 | [S3M-2906] Decision Time | abstention | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 19 Nov 2008 | [S3M-2906.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | abstention | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 19 Nov 2008 | [S3M-2906.2.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | abstention | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 13 Nov 2008 | [S3M-2862] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 13 Nov 2008 | [S3M-2862.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 13 Nov 2008 | [S3M-2862.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 13 Nov 2008 | [S3M-2862.3 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 13 Nov 2008 | [S3M-2863] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 13 Nov 2008 | [S3M-2863.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 13 Nov 2008 | [S3M-2864] Decision Time | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 13 Nov 2008 | [S3M-2864.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 12 Nov 2008 | [S3M-2853] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 12 Nov 2008 | [S3M-2853.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 12 Nov 2008 | [S3M-2853.4 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 30 Oct 2008 | [S3M-2779.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 30 Oct 2008 | [S3M-2780] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 30 Oct 2008 | [S3M-2780.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 8 Oct 2008 | [S3M-2671.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | abstention | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 2 Oct 2008 | [S3M-2635] Decision Time | minority | abstention | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 2 Oct 2008 | [S3M-2631] Decision Time | minority | abstention | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 2 Oct 2008 | [S3M-2631.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | abstention | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 18 Sep 2008 | [S3M-2553] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 18 Sep 2008 | [S3M-2553.3 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 18 Sep 2008 | [S3M-2553.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 18 Sep 2008 | [S3M-2553.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 11 Sep 2008 | [S3M-2524] Decision Time | Majority | abstention | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 11 Sep 2008 | [S3M-2524.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 19 Jun 2008 | [S3M-2204.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 11 Jun 2008 | [S3M-2102] Decision Time | abstention | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 11 Jun 2008 | [S3M-2102.3 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 11 Jun 2008 | [S3M-2102.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | abstention | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 11 Jun 2008 | [S3M-2102.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 5 Jun 2008 | [S3M-2057] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 5 Jun 2008 | [S3M-2057.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 5 Jun 2008 | [S3M-2057.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 5 Jun 2008 | [S3M-2057.3 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 5 Jun 2008 | [S3M-2056.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 4 Jun 2008 | [S3M-2038.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 29 May 2008 | [S3M-2002.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | abstention | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 29 May 2008 | [S3M-2002.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | abstention | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 22 May 2008 | [S3M-1951.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 21 May 2008 | [S3M-1956] Business Motion | abstention | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 21 May 2008 | [S3M-1956.1 (Amendment)] Business Motion | abstention | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 15 May 2008 | [S3M-1902] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 8 May 2008 | [S3M-1849] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 8 May 2008 | [S3M-1849.3 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 8 May 2008 | [S3M-1849.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 8 May 2008 | [S3M-1849.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 7 May 2008 | [S3M-1838.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 1 May 2008 | [S3M-1814] Decision Time | abstention | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 1 May 2008 | [S3M-1814.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | abstention | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 1 May 2008 | [S3M-1814.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | abstention | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 1 May 2008 | [S3M-1812] Decision Time | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 1 May 2008 | [S3M-1812.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | aye | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 1 May 2008 | [S3M-1812.3 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 24 Apr 2008 | [S3M-1768] Decision Time | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 24 Apr 2008 | [S3M-1768.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 24 Apr 2008 | [S3M-1768.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 23 Apr 2008 | [S3M-1751.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | abstention | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 23 Apr 2008 | [S3M-1751.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | abstention | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 17 Apr 2008 | [S3M-1706.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 17 Apr 2008 | [S3M-1706.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 17 Apr 2008 | [S3M-1706.2.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 27 Mar 2008 | [S3M-1631.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 26 Mar 2008 | [S3M-1621.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | abstention | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 20 Mar 2008 | [S3M-1602] Decision Time | Majority | abstention | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 20 Mar 2008 | [S3M-1602.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | abstention | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 20 Mar 2008 | [S3M-1602.1.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 13 Mar 2008 | [S3M-1548.3 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 13 Mar 2008 | [S3M-1550] Decision Time | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 13 Mar 2008 | [S3M-1550.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 13 Mar 2008 | [S3M-1549] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 13 Mar 2008 | [S3M-1549.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 13 Mar 2008 | [S3M-1549.1.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 13 Mar 2008 | [S3M-1549.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 6 Mar 2008 | [S3M-1489.3 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 6 Mar 2008 | [S3M-1489.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 28 Feb 2008 | [S3M-1367.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | abstention | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 28 Feb 2008 | [S3M-1432] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 28 Feb 2008 | [S3M-1432.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 28 Feb 2008 | [S3M-1432.1.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 28 Feb 2008 | [S3M-1432.1.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 28 Feb 2008 | [S3M-1434.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 28 Feb 2008 | [S3M-1434.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 7 Feb 2008 | [S3M-1306] Decision Time | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 6 Feb 2008 | [S3M-1296] Decision Time | abstention | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 31 Jan 2008 | [S3M-1260] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 31 Jan 2008 | [S3M-1260.3 (Amendment)] Decision Time | abstention | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 31 Jan 2008 | [S3M-1260.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | abstention | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 31 Jan 2008 | [S3M-1260.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 31 Jan 2008 | [S3M-1258.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 31 Jan 2008 | [S3M-1258.1.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | abstention | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 31 Jan 2008 | [S3M-1246] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 31 Jan 2008 | [S3M-1246.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 31 Jan 2008 | [S3M-1246.1.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 31 Jan 2008 | [S3M-1246.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 24 Jan 2008 | [S3M-1200.1.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | abstention | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 23 Jan 2008 | [S3M-1176] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 23 Jan 2008 | [S3M-1176.3 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 23 Jan 2008 | [S3M-1176.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 23 Jan 2008 | [S3M-1176.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | abstention | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 17 Jan 2008 | [S3M-1153.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | abstention | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 17 Jan 2008 | [S3M-1153.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 17 Jan 2008 | [S3M-1152.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | abstention | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 16 Jan 2008 | [S3M-1131] Decision Time | Majority | abstention | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 16 Jan 2008 | [S3M-1131.3 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 10 Jan 2008 | [S3M-1105] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 10 Jan 2008 | [S3M-1105.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 10 Jan 2008 | [S3M-1105.2.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 19 Dec 2007 | [S3M-1053] Decision Time | abstention | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 19 Dec 2007 | [S3M-1053.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 13 Dec 2007 | [S3M-1017.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | abstention | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 13 Dec 2007 | [S3M-1017.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | abstention | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 12 Dec 2007 | [S3M-1008.4 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 12 Dec 2007 | [S3M-1008.3 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 29 Nov 2007 | [S3M-946.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 29 Nov 2007 | [S3M-946.3 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 29 Nov 2007 | [S3M-945.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 29 Nov 2007 | [S3M-945.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 28 Nov 2007 | [S3M-928.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | abstention | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 21 Nov 2007 | [S3M-883] Decision Time | abstention | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 21 Nov 2007 | [S3M-883.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 21 Nov 2007 | [S3M-883.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | abstention | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 21 Nov 2007 | [S3M-883.3 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 8 Nov 2007 | [S3M-788] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 8 Nov 2007 | [S3M-788.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 8 Nov 2007 | [S3M-788.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 1 Nov 2007 | [S3M-739.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 25 Oct 2007 | [S3M-681] Decision Time | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 25 Oct 2007 | [S3M-681.3 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 25 Oct 2007 | [S3M-681.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 25 Oct 2007 | [S3M-679] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 25 Oct 2007 | [S3M-679.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 25 Oct 2007 | [S3M-679.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 24 Oct 2007 | [S3M-667] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 24 Oct 2007 | [S3M-667.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 27 Sep 2007 | [S3M-546] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 27 Sep 2007 | [S3M-546.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 27 Sep 2007 | [S3M-545.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 26 Sep 2007 | [S3M-539] Decision Time | no | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 26 Sep 2007 | [S3M-539.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | aye | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 20 Sep 2007 | [S3M-498.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | abstention | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 20 Sep 2007 | [S3M-498.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 20 Sep 2007 | [S3M-499.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 12 Sep 2007 | [S3M-443.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 12 Sep 2007 | [S3M-443.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 6 Sep 2007 | [S3M-415.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 5 Sep 2007 | [S3M-412] Business Motion | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 21 Jun 2007 | [S3M-201.3 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 21 Jun 2007 | [S3M-204] Decision Time | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 14 Jun 2007 | [S3M-173] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 14 Jun 2007 | [S3M-173.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 14 Jun 2007 | [S3M-173.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 14 Jun 2007 | [S3M-173.4 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 14 Jun 2007 | [S3M-169] Decision Time | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 14 Jun 2007 | [S3M-169.4 (Amendment)] Decision Time | abstention | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 14 Jun 2007 | [S3M-169.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | abstention | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 7 Jun 2007 | [S3M-127] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 7 Jun 2007 | [S3M-127.3 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 7 Jun 2007 | [S3M-127.3.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| House | Date | Subject | Malcolm Chisholm | Jackson Carlaw | Rôle | |
| no votes listed | ||||||
| House | Date | Subject | Malcolm Chisholm | Jackson Carlaw | Rôle | |
| no votes listed | ||||||
| House | Date | Subject | Malcolm Chisholm | Jackson Carlaw | Rôle | |
| no votes listed | ||||||