Voting Comparison — The Earl of Mar and Kellie
to Lord Alton of Liverpool

The Earl of Mar and Kellie

Note: our records only go back to 1997 for the Commons and 2001 for the Lords (more details).

FromToPartyRebellions (explain...)Attendance (explain...)Teller
19 Apr 2000 30 Jun 2017 LDem 11 votes out of 990, 1.1% 990 votes out of 2052, 48.2% 42 times

Voting Differences

HouseDateSubjectThe Earl of Mar and KellieLord Alton of LiverpoolRôle
Lords18 Nov 2015European Union Referendum Bill — Report (1st Day) Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords25 Mar 2015Modern Slavery Bill — Commons Amendments Majoritytellaye disagrees with policy
Lords11 Mar 2015Small Business, Enterprise and Employment Bill — Report (3rd Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords11 Feb 2015Deregulation Bill — Report (3rd Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords11 Feb 2015Deregulation Bill — Report (3rd Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords26 Nov 2014Consumer Rights Bill — Report (3rd Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords26 Nov 2014Consumer Rights Bill — Report (3rd Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords26 Nov 2014Consumer Rights Bill — Report (3rd Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords11 Nov 2014Wales Bill — Report Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords10 Nov 2014Infrastructure Bill [HL] — Report (3rd Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords7 May 2014Care Bill [HL] — Commons Amendments Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords7 May 2014Care Bill [HL] — Commons Amendments Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords28 Jan 2014Children and Families Bill — Report (4th Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords28 Jan 2014Transparency of Lobbying, Non-Party Campaigning and Trade Union Administration Bill — Commons Reasons and Amendments Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords28 Jan 2014Transparency of Lobbying, Non-Party Campaigning and Trade Union Administration Bill — Commons Reasons and Amendments Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords15 Jan 2014Transparency of Lobbying, Non-Party Campaigning and Trade Union Administration Bill — Committee (2nd Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords15 Jan 2014Transparency of Lobbying, Non-Party Campaigning and Trade Union Administration Bill — Committee (2nd Day) minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords17 Dec 2013Children and Families Bill — Report (2nd Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords11 Dec 2013Energy Bill — Commons Reason Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords26 Nov 2013Financial Services (Banking Reform) Bill — Report (1st Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords26 Nov 2013Financial Services (Banking Reform) Bill — Report (1st Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords6 Nov 2013Energy Bill — Report (3rd Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords16 Oct 2013Care Bill [HL] — Report (3rd Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords23 Jul 2013EU: Police and Criminal Justice Measures — Motion to Agree Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords23 Jul 2013Intellectual Property Bill [HL] — Report Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords9 Jul 2013Offender Rehabilitation Bill [HL] — Third Reading Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords24 Apr 2013National Health Service (Procurement, Patient Choice and Competition) (No. 2) Regulations 2013 — Motion to Annul Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords24 Apr 2013Procedure of the House — Motion to Resolve Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords23 Apr 2013Defamation Bill — Commons Reasons Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords20 Mar 2013Enterprise and Regulatory Reform Bill — Third Reading Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords19 Mar 2013Welfare Benefits Up-rating Bill — Report Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords19 Mar 2013Welfare Benefits Up-rating Bill — Report Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords19 Mar 2013Welfare Benefits Up-rating Bill — Report Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords19 Mar 2013Welfare Benefits Up-rating Bill — Report Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords27 Feb 2013Growth and Infrastructure Bill — Report (1st Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords26 Feb 2013Enterprise and Regulatory Reform Bill — Report (1st Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords26 Feb 2013Enterprise and Regulatory Reform Bill — Report (1st Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords18 Dec 2012Crime and Courts Bill [HL] — Third Reading minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords4 Dec 2012Crime and Courts Bill [HL] — Report (2nd Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords28 Nov 2012Financial Services Bill — Report (5th Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords28 Nov 2012Financial Services Bill — Report (5th Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords27 Nov 2012Crime and Courts Bill [HL] — Report (1st Day) minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords16 Oct 2012Local Government Finance Bill — Report (2nd Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords10 Oct 2012Local Government Finance Bill — Report (1st Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords24 Apr 2012Protection of Freedoms Bill — Commons Reason and Amendments Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords24 Apr 2012Protection of Freedoms Bill — Commons Reason and Amendments Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords23 Apr 2012Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill — Commons Reasons and Amendments Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords23 Apr 2012Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill — Commons Reasons and Amendments Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords23 Apr 2012Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill — Commons Reasons and Amendments minoritytellaye disagrees with policy
Lords23 Apr 2012Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill — Commons Reasons and Amendments Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords23 Apr 2012Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill — Commons Reasons and Amendments Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords23 Apr 2012Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill — Commons Reasons and Amendments minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords27 Mar 2012Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill — Third Reading Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords27 Mar 2012Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill — Third Reading Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords27 Mar 2012Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill — Third Reading Majoritytellaye disagrees with policy
Lords27 Mar 2012Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill — Third Reading Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords27 Mar 2012Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill — Third Reading Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords27 Mar 2012Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill — Third Reading Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords27 Mar 2012Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill — Third Reading Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords27 Mar 2012Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill — Third Reading minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords27 Mar 2012Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill — Third Reading minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords26 Mar 2012Procedure of the House — Motion to Agree minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords20 Mar 2012Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill — Report (5th Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords20 Mar 2012Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill — Report (5th Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords14 Mar 2012Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill — Report (4th Day) noaye disagrees with policy
Lords14 Mar 2012Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill — Report (4th Day) minoritytellaye disagrees with policy
Lords14 Mar 2012Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill — Report (4th Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords14 Mar 2012Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill — Report (4th Day) minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords6 Mar 2012Health and Social Care Bill — Report (5th Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords6 Mar 2012Health and Social Care Bill — Report (5th Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords29 Feb 2012Health and Social Care Bill — Report (4th Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords27 Feb 2012Health and Social Care Bill — Report (3rd Day)Relevant documents: 18th and 22nd Reports from the Constitution Committee Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords27 Feb 2012Health and Social Care Bill — Report (3rd Day)Relevant documents: 18th and 22nd Reports from the Constitution Committee Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords14 Feb 2012Welfare Reform Bill — Commons Reasons and Amendment minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords31 Jan 2012Welfare Reform Bill — Third Reading minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords25 Jan 2012Welfare Reform Bill — Report (6th Day) minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords25 Jan 2012Welfare Reform Bill — Report (6th Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords17 Jan 2012Welfare Reform Bill — Report (4th Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords11 Jan 2012Welfare Reform Bill — Report (3rd Day) minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords11 Jan 2012Welfare Reform Bill — Report (3rd Day) minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords11 Jan 2012Welfare Reform Bill — Report (3rd Day) minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords7 Dec 2011Health and Social Care Bill — Committee (11th Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords22 Nov 2011Health and Social Care Bill — Committee (7th Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords22 Nov 2011Health and Social Care Bill — Committee (7th Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords8 Nov 2011Procedure of the House (Proposal 9) — Motion to Resolve minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords8 Nov 2011Procedure of the House (Proposal 1) — Motion to Resolve minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords26 Oct 2011Education Bill — Report (3rd Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords18 Oct 2011Education Bill — Report (1st Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords12 Oct 2011Localism Bill — Report (6th Day) (Continued) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords12 Oct 2011Health and Social Care Bill — select comittee to scrutinise Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords12 Oct 2011Health and Social Care Bill — Reject at Second Reading Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords14 Sep 2011Welfare Reform Bill — Motion to Refer to Grand Committee Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords6 Sep 2011Equality Act 2010 (Specific Duties) Regulations 2011 — Motion to Approve Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords5 Sep 2011Localism Bill — Report (1st Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords5 Sep 2011Localism Bill — Report (1st Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords5 Sep 2011Localism Bill — Report (1st Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords20 Jul 2011Police Reform and Social Responsibility Bill — Third Reading Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords8 Jun 2011European Union Bill — Inconsequential wording change : supporting to permitting noaye disagrees with policy
Lords21 Dec 2010Identity Documents Bill — Consideration of Commons Reason: Motion to adjourn Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords14 Dec 2010University Tuition Fee Cap raise to £9,000 Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords14 Dec 2010University Tuition Fee Cap raise to £6,000 Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords14 Dec 2010Public Bodies Bill [HL] — Committee (4th Day) — Abolition of Chief Coroner minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords30 Nov 2010Parliamentary Voting System and Constituencies Bill — Committee to Decide on Form of AV to Put to Referendum Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords23 Nov 2010Public Bodies Bill [HL] — Committee (1st Day) minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords17 Nov 2010Identity Documents Bill — Report minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords7 Apr 2010Children, Schools and Families Bill — Committee (and remaining stages) minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords3 Feb 2010Digital Economy Bill — New functions of Channel 4 — requires special annual report Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords11 Nov 2009Coroners and Justice Bill — Commons Reasons and Amendments minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords11 Nov 2009Coroners and Justice Bill — Commons Reasons and Amendments minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords7 Jul 2009Coroners and Justice Bill — New Clause — Assisted Suicide Majoritytellno agrees with policy
Lords15 Jun 2009Political Parties and Elections Bill — Report (1st Day) (Continued) minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords1 Jun 2009Marine and Coastal Access Bill [HL] — Report (4th Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords11 Mar 2009Northern Ireland Bill — Committee minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords27 Oct 2008Pensions Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords18 Jun 2008Lisbon Treaty — Ratification by all states before coming into force — rejected Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords18 Jun 2008Lisbon Treaty — Delay till 20 October 2008 — rejected Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords11 Jun 2008Lisbon Treaty — Change the date upon which the Treaty will come into force — rejected Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords19 May 2008Employment Bill [HL] Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords7 May 2008Criminal Justice and Immigration Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords21 Feb 2008Banking (Special Provisions) Bill — Month or year sunset clause Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords4 Feb 2008Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill — Strong evidence required to use admix embryos Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords21 Jan 2008Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill [HL] — saviour siblings — definition of serious illness Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords16 Jan 2008Local Transport Bill [HL] Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords15 Jan 2008Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill [HL] — creation of admix (inter-species) embroyos Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords26 Jun 2007Greater London Authority Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords27 Mar 2007Police (Northern Ireland) Act 2000 (Renewal of Temporary Provisions) Order 2007 minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords27 Feb 2007Further Education and Training Bill [HL] tellayeaye agrees with policy
Lords7 Nov 2006Police and Justice Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords6 Nov 2006Armed Forces Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords6 Nov 2006Armed Forces Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords31 Oct 2006Armed Forces Bill tellayeno disagrees with policy
Lords30 Oct 2006Education and Inspections Bill — Stop faith schools requiring that candidates for headteacher posts belong to the relevant faith — rejected tellayeno disagrees with policy
Lords30 Oct 2006Education and Inspections Bill tellayeaye agrees with policy
Lords24 Oct 2006Education and Inspections Bill — IGCSE for state schools — rejected Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords24 Oct 2006Education and Inspections Bill -- Amendment No. 91A minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords17 Oct 2006Education and Inspections Bill — Local Authorities to encourage 'Foundation' status — rejected Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords16 Oct 2006Violent Crime Reduction Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords16 Oct 2006Violent Crime Reduction Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords10 Oct 2006Police and Justice Bill tellayeno disagrees with policy
Lords28 Jun 2006Government of Wales Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords27 Jun 2006Government of Wales Bill tellayeaye agrees with policy
Lords27 Jun 2006Government of Wales Bill tellayeaye agrees with policy
Lords23 May 2006Company Law Reform Bill [HL] Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords17 Jan 2006Terrorism Bill tellayeno disagrees with policy
Lords29 Nov 2005Road Safety Bill [HL] — level crossings tellayeaye agrees with policy
Lords29 Nov 2005Road Safety Bill [HL] — Compulsory surrender of old-form licences tellayeno disagrees with policy
Lords22 Nov 2005Road Safety Bill [HL] — motorway speed limit to 80mph Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords8 Nov 2005Racial and Religious Hatred Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords6 Apr 2005Railways Bill tellayeaye agrees with policy
Lords24 Mar 2005Mental Capacity Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords24 Mar 2005Procedure of the House: Select Committee Report Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords15 Mar 2005Constitutional Reform Bill [HL] minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords15 Mar 2005Constitutional Reform Bill [HL] minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords7 Dec 2004Constitutional Reform Bill [HL] minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords7 Dec 2004Constitutional Reform Bill [HL] minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords16 Nov 2004Civil Contingencies Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords16 Nov 2004Civil Contingencies Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords11 Nov 2004Hunting Bill: amendment — commencement minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords28 Jun 2004Mersey Tunnels Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords18 May 2004Asylum and Immigration (Treatment of Claimants, etc.) Bill — Only withdraw support from failed asylum seekers after an independent evaluation — rejected tellayeaye agrees with policy
Lords11 May 2004Lords Amendment tellayeno disagrees with policy
Lords20 Apr 2004Energy Bill [HL] tellayeaye agrees with policy
Lords16 Mar 2004Planning and Compulsory Purchase Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords8 Mar 2004Constitutional Reform Bill [HL] minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords24 Feb 2004Planning and Compulsory Purchase Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords24 Feb 2004Planning and Compulsory Purchase Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords3 Feb 2004Justice (Northern Ireland) Bill [HL] Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords14 Jan 2004Liaison: Select Committee Report Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords17 Dec 2003Procedure of the House: Select Committee Report tellnono agrees with policy
Lords16 Dec 2003Extradition Act 2003 (Designation of Part 2 Territories) Order 2003 minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords20 Nov 2003Commons Response to Lords Amendments 114 to 119 and 121 to 131 Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords20 Nov 2003Lords Amendment — Criminal Justice Bill — Juries in serious or complex fraud trials Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords20 Nov 2003Lords Amendment — Criminal Justice Bill — Juries and fraud trials Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords12 Nov 2003Extradition Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords4 Nov 2003Criminal Justice Bill tellayeaye agrees with policy
Lords4 Nov 2003Criminal Justice Bill tellayeaye agrees with policy
Lords4 Nov 2003Criminal Justice Bill tellayeaye agrees with policy
Lords17 Jul 2003Local Government Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords16 Jul 2003Lords Amendment Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords8 Jul 2003Communications Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords17 Jun 2003Sexual Offences Bill [HL] Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords17 Jun 2003Sexual Offences Bill [HL] Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords12 Jun 2003Water Bill [HL] Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords19 May 2003Courts Bill [HL] minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords19 May 2003Courts Bill [HL] Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords19 May 2003Courts Bill [HL] Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords6 May 2003Extradition Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords27 Feb 2003Licensing Bill [HL] Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords24 Feb 2003Licensing Bill [HL] Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords24 Feb 2003Licensing Bill [HL] Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords24 Feb 2003Licensing Bill [HL] Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords11 Feb 2003Strategic Investment and Regeneration of Sites (Northern Ireland) Order 2003 tellayeaye agrees with policy
Lords24 Oct 2002Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Bill — Remove the government's power to remove subsistence-only support from all asylum seekers — rejected tellayeaye agrees with policy
Lords23 Oct 2002Adoption and Children Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords15 Oct 2002Enterprise Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords3 Jul 2002Education Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords3 Jul 2002Education Bill — Leave out Clause 11 (Form or invest in companies) Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords26 Jun 2002Education Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords25 Jun 2002Proceeds of Crime Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords25 Jun 2002Proceeds of Crime Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords25 Jun 2002Proceeds of Crime Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords12 Jun 2002Tax Credits Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords22 Jan 2002European Communities (Amendment) Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords17 Jan 2002European Communities (Amendment) Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords20 Nov 2001European Communities (Amendment) Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords20 Nov 2001European Communities (Amendment) Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords20 Nov 2001European Communities (Amendment) Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords19 Nov 2001Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill [HL] minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords19 Nov 2001Human Rights Act 1998 (Designated Derogation) Order 2001 minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords8 Nov 2001Land Registration Bill [HL] Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords29 Oct 2001Office of Communications Bill [HL] Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords26 Mar 2001Hunting Bill minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords13 Feb 2001Regulatory Reform Bill [H.L.] Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords13 Feb 2001Regulatory Reform Bill [H.L.] Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords23 Jan 2001Procedure of the House: Select Committee Report minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords22 Jan 2001Human Fertilisation and Embryology (Research Purposes) Regulations 2000 Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords8 Nov 2000Extension of Corresponding Northern Ireland Offence: Conduct Towards 14 to 16 Year Olds. 1960 C. 33. Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords3 Oct 2000Countryside and Rights of Way Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords8 Jun 2000Postal Services Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy

About the Project

The Public Whip is a not-for-profit, open source website created in 2003 by Francis Irving and Julian Todd and now run by Bairwell Ltd.

The Whip on the Web

Help keep PublicWhip alive