Voting Comparison — The Earl of Mar and Kellie
to Lord Mackie of Benshie
The Earl of Mar and Kellie
Note: our records only go back to 1997 for the Commons and 2001 for the Lords (more details).
| From | To | Party | Rebellions (explain...) | Attendance (explain...) | Teller |
| 19 Apr 2000 | 30 Jun 2017 | LDem | 11 votes out of 990, 1.1% | 990 votes out of 2052, 48.2% | 42 times |
Voting Differences
| House | Date | Subject | The Earl of Mar and Kellie | Lord Mackie of Benshie | Rôle |
| Lords | 5 Mar 2008 | Criminal Justice and Immigration Bill | minority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 18 Jul 2007 | Housing Act 2004 (Commencement No. 8) (England and Wales) Order 2007 | Majority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 14 Mar 2007 | House of Lords Reform — Fully Elected — rejected | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 14 Mar 2007 | House of Lords: Reform (80pc elected, 20pc appointed) | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 14 Mar 2007 | House of Lords: Reform (Fully Appointed) | minority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 27 Feb 2007 | Further Education and Training Bill [HL] | tellaye | aye | agrees with policy |
| Lords | 31 Oct 2006 | Armed Forces Bill | tellaye | aye | agrees with policy |
| Lords | 30 Oct 2006 | Education and Inspections Bill — Stop faith schools requiring that candidates for headteacher posts belong to the relevant faith — rejected | tellaye | aye | agrees with policy |
| Lords | 30 Oct 2006 | Education and Inspections Bill | tellaye | aye | agrees with policy |
| Lords | 10 Oct 2006 | Police and Justice Bill | tellaye | aye | agrees with policy |
| Lords | 28 Jun 2006 | Civil Aviation Bill | tellaye | aye | agrees with policy |
| Lords | 27 Jun 2006 | Government of Wales Bill | tellaye | aye | agrees with policy |
| Lords | 27 Jun 2006 | Government of Wales Bill | tellaye | aye | agrees with policy |
| Lords | 22 May 2006 | Conventions: Joint Committee | tellaye | aye | agrees with policy |
| Lords | 8 Mar 2006 | Civil Aviation Bill | tellaye | aye | agrees with policy |
| Lords | 17 Jan 2006 | Terrorism Bill | tellaye | aye | agrees with policy |
| Lords | 29 Nov 2005 | Road Safety Bill [HL] — Compulsory surrender of old-form licences | tellaye | aye | agrees with policy |
| Lords | 25 Oct 2005 | Racial and Religious Hatred Bill | Majority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 6 Apr 2005 | Railways Bill | tellaye | aye | agrees with policy |
| Lords | 2 Mar 2005 | Education Bill — Amendment No. 3 | tellaye | aye | agrees with policy |
| Lords | 21 Dec 2004 | Administration and Works Committee | Majority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 17 Nov 2004 | Hunting Bill — Lords Amendment — commencement | minority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 17 Nov 2004 | Hunting Bill — Lords Amendment | minority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 11 Nov 2004 | Hunting Bill: amendment — commencement | minority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 11 Nov 2004 | Hunting Bill: amendment — registered hunting | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 14 Jul 2004 | Lords Amendment | tellaye | aye | agrees with policy |
| Lords | 18 May 2004 | Asylum and Immigration (Treatment of Claimants, etc.) Bill — Only withdraw support from failed asylum seekers after an independent evaluation — rejected | tellaye | aye | agrees with policy |
| Lords | 11 May 2004 | Lords Amendment | tellaye | aye | agrees with policy |
| Lords | 20 Apr 2004 | Energy Bill [HL] | tellaye | aye | agrees with policy |
| Lords | 17 Dec 2003 | Procedure of the House: Select Committee Report | tellno | no | agrees with policy |
| Lords | 11 Nov 2003 | "Prisoners Liable to Removal from United Kingdom:Modifications of Criminal Justice Act 1991 | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 4 Nov 2003 | Criminal Justice Bill | tellaye | aye | agrees with policy |
| Lords | 4 Nov 2003 | Criminal Justice Bill | tellaye | aye | agrees with policy |
| Lords | 4 Nov 2003 | Criminal Justice Bill | tellaye | aye | agrees with policy |
| Lords | 27 Oct 2003 | Extradition Bill | tellaye | aye | agrees with policy |
| Lords | 22 Oct 2003 | Extradition Bill | tellaye | aye | agrees with policy |
| Lords | 15 Jul 2003 | Criminal Justice Bill | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 17 Jun 2003 | Employment Equality (Sexual Orientation) Regulations 2003 | tellaye | aye | agrees with policy |
| Lords | 25 Feb 2003 | Crime (International Co-operation) Bill [HL] | tellaye | aye | agrees with policy |
| Lords | 11 Feb 2003 | Strategic Investment and Regeneration of Sites (Northern Ireland) Order 2003 | tellaye | aye | agrees with policy |
| Lords | 4 Feb 2003 | House of Lords Reform — 80 per cent elected/20 per cent appointed | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 4 Feb 2003 | House of Lords Reform — fully elected | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 4 Feb 2003 | House of Lords Reform — fully appointed | minority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 6 Nov 2002 | Lords Amendment | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 24 Oct 2002 | Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Bill — Remove the government's power to remove subsistence-only support from all asylum seekers — rejected | tellaye | aye | agrees with policy |
| Lords | 26 Mar 2002 | Animal Health Bill | Majority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 30 Apr 2001 | Liaison: Select Committee Report | Majority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 23 Jan 2001 | Procedure of the House: Select Committee Report | minority | aye | disagrees with policy |