Child Support, Pensions and Social Security Bill — Recovery of housing benefit — 29 Mar 2000
Public Whip is run as a free not-for-profit service. If you'd like to support us, please
consider switching your (UK) electricity and/or gas to Octopus Energy or tip us via Ko-Fi.
Key: Vote in majority | Vote against majority | Absent from vote | Minister | PPS.top
This is an experimental slab view. Tell us what you think. Email: team@publicwhip.org.uk or leave a comment on the forum.
| Lab partytype">Lab | absent lab topborder"> Malcolm Chisholm | favour lab topborder"> Jeff Ennis | favour lab topborder"> Joan Humble | favour minister lab topborder"> Thomas McAvoy | favour lab topborder"> Gwyn Prosser | favour lab topborder">Mr Gareth Thomas | absent minister snp topborder"> Alex Salmond | absent ldem topborder"> Jim Wallace | absent minister con topborder"> Michael Fabricant | absent minister con topborder rightborder">P McLoughlin. |
| Lab partytype2">+261 -0 (155) | absent lab">Ms Judith Church | favour lab"> Bill Etherington | favour lab">Mr Alan Hurst | favour minister lab"> Steve McCabe | absent lab"> Ken Purchase | absent lab"> Gareth Thomas | absent snp"> John Swinney | against minister ldem"> Steve Webb | absent minister con"> Michael Fallon | absent con rightborder"> Malcolm Moss |
| absent minister lab"> Diane Abbott | absent lab"> Michael Clapham | favour lab"> Frank Field | favour minister lab"> John Hutton | favour lab"> Chris McCafferty | absent minister lab">Ms Joyce Quin | absent minister lab"> Stephen Timms | absent snp"> Andrew Welsh | absent minister ldem"> Phil Willis | absent con">Mr Howard Flight | absent con rightborder">P Nicholls. |
| absent minister lab">Mrs Irene Adams | absent lab">Dr David Clark | absent lab"> Mark Fisher | favour lab"> Brian Iddon | absent minister lab"> Ian McCartney | favour lab">Mr Lawrie Quinn | favour minister lab"> Paddy Tipping | SF partytype">SF | Independent Labour partytype">Independent Labour | absent con"> Eric Forth | absent con rightborder">Mr Archie Norman |
| favour lab"> Nick Ainger | absent lab">Ms Helen Clark | absent lab"> Jim Fitzpatrick | favour lab"> Eric Illsley | favour lab"> Siobhain McDonagh | favour minister lab">Mr Giles Radice | favour lab"> Mark Todd | SF partytype2">+0 -0 (2) | Independent Labour partytype2">+0 -0 (1) | absent con">Mr Norman Fowler | absent minister con rightborder">S O'Brien. |
| favour teller minister lab"> Bob Ainsworth | favour minister lab">Dr Lynda Clark | absent lab">L Fitzsimons. | absent minister lab"> Adam Ingram | favour lab">J McDonnell. | absent lab"> Bill Rammell | favour minister lab"> Don Touhig | absent sf"> Gerry Adams | absent independentlabour"> Tommy Graham | absent minister con"> Liam Fox | absent minister con rightborder"> Richard Ottaway |
| absent lab"> Douglas Alexander | absent lab"> Paul Clark | favour lab"> Caroline Flint | favour lab"> Glenda Jackson | absent minister lab"> John McFall | favour lab">Mr Syd Rapson | favour lab"> Jon Trickett | absent sf"> Martin McGuinness | Independent partytype">Independent | absent con">C Fraser. | absent con rightborder">Mr Richard Page |
| favour minister lab"> Graham Allen | favour minister lab"> Charles Clarke | favour lab"> Paul Flynn | favour lab">Mrs Helen Jackson | favour minister lab"> Anne McGuire | favour minister lab"> Nick Raynsford | favour lab"> Paul Truswell | SDLP partytype">SDLP | Independent partytype2">+0 -0 (3) | absent minister con"> Roger Gale | absent minister con rightborder"> James Paice |
| absent minister lab">Mr Donald Anderson | absent lab">Mr Eric Clarke | absent lab"> Barbara Follett | favour minister lab">Mr David Jamieson | favour lab"> Shona McIsaac | favour lab"> Andy Reed | favour minister lab">Mr Dennis Turner | SDLP partytype2">+0 -0 (3) | absent independent">Mr Martin Bell | absent minister con"> Edward Garnier | absent minister con rightborder"> Owen Paterson |
| absent minister lab"> Janet Anderson | favour lab"> Tom Clarke | absent minister lab">Mr Derek Foster | favour lab"> Brian Jenkins | favour lab"> Rosemary McKenna | favour minister lab"> John Reid | favour lab"> Desmond Turner | absent sdlp">Mr John Hume | absent independent"> Dennis Canavan | absent minister con"> Nick Gibb | absent minister con rightborder"> Eric Pickles |
| favour minister lab"> Hilary Armstrong | favour lab">Mr Tony Clarke | favour lab"> Michael Foster | favour minister lab"> Alan Johnson | absent lab"> Henry McLeish | absent lab"> Geoffrey Robinson | favour lab">Dr George Turner | absent sdlp">Mr Seamus Mallon | absent independent"> Ken Livingstone | absent con">C Gill. | absent con rightborder">M Portillo. |
| absent lab">Mr Joe Ashton | favour minister lab"> David Clelland | favour lab">M Foster. | absent minister lab">M Johnson. | absent lab">Mr Kevin McNamara | favour minister lab">Mrs Barbara Roche | favour lab"> Neil Turner | absent sdlp"> Eddie McGrady | DUP partytype">DUP | absent minister con">Dame Cheryl Gillan | absent minister con rightborder">Mr David Prior |
| favour lab">Ms Candy Atherton | favour minister lab"> Ann Clwyd | favour minister lab">Mr George Foulkes | favour lab">Mr Barry Jones | favour minister lab"> Tony McNulty | absent lab">Mr Allan Rogers | favour lab"> Derek Twigg | PC partytype">PC | DUP partytype2">+0 -0 (2) | absent con">Mrs Teresa Gorman | absent minister con rightborder"> John Randall |
| favour lab"> Charlotte Atkins | favour lab"> Vernon Coaker | favour lab">Mrs Maria Fyfe | absent lab"> Fiona Jones | favour lab">Mr Tony McWalter | favour minister lab">Mr Jeff Rooker | absent minister lab"> Stephen Twigg | PC partytype2">+0 -1 (3) | absent minister dup"> Ian Paisley | absent minister con"> James Gray | absent con rightborder"> John Redwood |
| favour lab"> John Austin | favour lab"> Ann Coffey | absent lab"> Sam Galbraith | favour minister lab"> Helen Jones | favour lab">Mr John McWilliam | favour lab"> Terry Rooney | favour lab">Mr Bill Tynan | absent pc">Mr Ieuan Wyn Jones | absent dup"> Peter Robinson | absent minister con"> Damian Green | absent minister con rightborder"> Andrew Robathan |
| favour minister lab">Mr Tony Banks | favour lab"> Harry Cohen | absent lab"> George Galloway | absent lab">Ms Jenny Jones | absent minister lab"> Michael Meacher | favour lab">Mr Ernie Ross | absent minister lab"> Keith Vaz | absent minister pc"> Elfyn Llwyd | Deputy Speaker partytype">Deputy Speaker | absent con"> John Greenway | absent minister con rightborder">L Robertson. |
| favour lab">Mr Harry Barnes | favour lab">Mr Iain Coleman | absent minister lab"> Mike Gapes | absent lab">Mr Jon Owen Jones | favour minister lab"> Alan Meale | favour minister lab">Mr Ted Rowlands | favour lab"> Rudi Vis | against pc">Mr Simon Thomas | Deputy Speaker partytype2">+0 -0 (3) | absent minister con"> Dominic Grieve | absent con rightborder">Mrs Marion Roe |
| favour minister lab"> Kevin Barron | favour lab">Mr Tony Colman | favour minister lab"> Barry Gardiner | favour lab"> Lynne Jones | absent lab"> Gillian Merron | favour lab"> Frank Roy | favour minister lab"> Joan Walley | absent pc">Mr Dafydd Wigley | absent minister deputyspeaker"> Alan Haselhurst | absent con"> John Gummer | absent con rightborder">Mr Andrew Rowe |
| absent minister lab"> John Battle | absent minister lab"> Michael Connarty | favour lab"> Bruce George | favour lab"> Martyn Jones | absent lab"> Alun Michael | favour minister lab"> Chris Ruane | absent lab"> Claire Ward | LDem partytype">LDem | absent minister deputyspeaker"> Michael Lord | absent minister con"> William Hague | absent minister con rightborder"> David Ruffley |
| favour minister lab"> Hugh Bayley | absent lab"> Frank Cook | favour lab"> Neil Gerrard | absent minister lab"> Tessa Jowell | absent lab">Mr Bill Michie | favour lab"> Joan Ruddock | favour lab"> Robert Wareing | LDem partytype2">+0 -34 (12) | absent minister deputyspeaker"> Michael Martin | absent minister con">A Hamilton. | absent con rightborder">Mr Jonathan Sayeed |
| favour lab">Mr Nigel Beard | absent minister lab"> Robin Cook | favour lab"> Ian Gibson | absent minister lab"> Gerald Kaufman | absent minister lab"> Alan Milburn | absent lab"> Christine Russell | favour minister lab"> Dave Watts | against minister ldem">Mr Richard Allan | Con partytype">Con | absent minister con"> Philip Hammond | absent con rightborder">G Shephard. |
| absent minister lab"> Margaret Beckett | absent minister lab"> Yvette Cooper | favour lab"> Linda Gilroy | favour lab"> Sally Keeble | favour lab"> Andrew Miller | favour lab"> Joan Ryan | favour lab">Mr Brian White | against ldem">Mr Paddy Ashdown | Con partytype2">+0 -0 (160) | absent con">Mr Nick Hawkins | absent con rightborder"> Richard Shepherd |
| favour minister lab"> Anne Begg | favour minister lab">Mr Robin Corbett | favour lab">Dr Norman Godman | absent lab"> Alan Keen | absent minister lab"> Austin Mitchell | absent lab"> Martin Salter | favour lab"> Alan Whitehead | against minister ldem"> Norman Baker | absent con"> Peter Ainsworth | absent minister con"> John Hayes | absent minister con rightborder"> Keith Simpson |
| absent minister lab"> Stuart Bell | favour lab"> Jeremy Corbyn | favour lab"> Roger Godsiff | absent lab"> Ann Keen | absent lab"> Laura Moffatt | favour lab"> Mohammad Sarwar | absent minister lab"> Malcolm Wicks | against ldem">Mrs Jackie Ballard | absent minister con">Sir David Amess | absent minister con"> Oliver Heald | absent con rightborder"> Nicholas Soames |
| favour minister lab"> Hilary Benn | favour lab">Ms Jean Corston | favour lab"> Paul Goggins | absent lab"> Ruth Kelly | absent minister lab">Dr Lewis Moonie | favour lab">Mr Malcolm Savidge | favour lab">Dr Alan Williams | against minister ldem"> Alan Beith | absent minister con"> Michael Ancram | absent con">Mr Edward Heath | absent minister con rightborder"> Caroline Spelman |
| absent lab">Mr Tony Benn | favour lab"> Jim Cousins | absent lab">Mrs Llin Golding | absent lab"> Fraser Kemp | absent lab"> Margaret Moran | favour lab">Mr Phil Sawford | favour lab"> Alan Williams | against minister ldem"> Tom Brake | absent minister con"> James Arbuthnot | absent con">D Heathcoat-Amor. | absent minister con rightborder"> Michael Spicer |
| favour lab">Mr Andrew Bennett | absent lab">Mr Tom Cox | favour lab">Mrs Eileen Gordon | absent minister lab"> Jane Kennedy | favour lab"> Julie Morgan | favour lab">Mr Brian Sedgemore | favour lab"> Betty Williams | against ldem">Dr Peter Brand | absent con">Mr David Atkinson | absent con">M Heseltine. | absent con rightborder"> Richard Spring |
| favour lab"> Joe Benton | absent minister lab">R Cranston | absent lab">Mr Bernie Grant | favour lab"> Piara S Khabra | favour lab">Mr Rhodri Morgan | favour lab"> Jonathan R Shaw | absent minister lab"> Michael Wills | absent ldem"> Colin Breed | absent con"> Peter Atkinson | absent con"> Douglas Hogg | absent con rightborder">Mr Nick St Aubyn |
| favour lab">G Bermingham. | favour minister lab"> David Crausby | absent lab">Ms Jane Griffiths | absent lab"> David Kidney | favour minister lab"> Elliot Morley | absent minister lab"> Barry Sheerman | absent minister lab">Mr Brian Wilson | against minister ldem"> Malcolm Bruce | absent minister con"> Tony Baldry | absent con"> John Horam | absent minister con rightborder"> John Stanley |
| favour lab"> Roger Berry | favour lab"> Ann Cryer | favour lab"> Nigel Griffiths | favour lab"> Peter Kilfoyle | absent minister lab">Ms Estelle Morris | absent minister lab">Mr Robert Sheldon | favour minister lab"> David Winnick | against ldem">Mr John Burnett | absent minister con"> John Bercow | absent con"> Michael Howard | absent con rightborder"> Anthony Steen |
| absent lab">Mr Harold Best | favour lab"> John Cryer | favour lab">Mr Win Griffiths | favour lab">Mr Andy King | absent lab">Sir John Morris | absent lab">Ms Debra Shipley | favour lab"> Rosie Winterton | against minister ldem"> Paul Burstow | absent minister con"> Paul Beresford | absent minister con"> Gerald Howarth | absent minister con rightborder"> Gary Streeter |
| favour minister lab"> Clive Betts | absent lab"> John Cummings | absent lab">Mr Bruce Grocott | absent minister lab">Ms Oona King | favour lab"> Kali Mountford | favour minister lab"> Clare Short | absent lab">Ms Audrey Wise | absent minister ldem"> Vincent Cable | absent minister con"> Crispin Blunt | absent con">Mr Andrew Hunter | absent minister con rightborder"> Desmond Swayne |
| favour lab"> Liz Blackman | absent lab">L Cunliffe. | favour minister lab"> John Grogan | absent lab">Ms Tess Kingham | absent minister lab">Dr Mo Mowlam | favour lab"> Alan Simpson | favour lab"> Mike Wood | against minister ldem"> Menzies Campbell | absent con">Mr Richard Body | absent con"> Michael Jack | absent minister con rightborder"> Robert Syms |
| absent minister lab"> Tony Blair | absent lab">Dr Jack Cunningham | absent lab">Mr John Gunnell | absent lab"> Ashok Kumar | absent lab"> George Mudie | favour lab"> Marsha Singh | favour lab"> Shaun Woodward | against minister ldem">Mr David Chidgey | absent minister con"> Tim Boswell | absent con"> Robert Jackson | absent con rightborder"> Peter Tapsell |
| favour lab"> Hazel Blears | favour minister lab"> Jim Cunningham | absent lab"> Peter Hain | favour lab"> Stephen Ladyman | favour minister lab"> Chris Mullin | favour minister lab"> Dennis Skinner | favour lab"> Phil Woolas | against minister ldem">Mr Brian Cotter | absent minister con"> Peter Bottomley | absent minister con"> Bernard Jenkin | absent con rightborder"> Ian Taylor |
| favour lab"> Bob Blizzard | favour lab">C Curtis-Thomas. | favour minister lab"> Mike Hall | absent lab">J Lawrence. | favour lab"> Denis Murphy | favour minister lab"> Andrew Smith | favour lab">T Worthington. | against minister ldem"> Edward Davey | absent con">V Bottomley. | absent con">G Johnson Smith | absent con rightborder">Mr John Taylor |
| absent minister lab"> David Blunkett | absent lab">Mr Tam Dalyell | absent lab"> Patrick Hall | favour lab"> Bob Laxton | absent minister lab"> Jim Murphy | favour lab"> Angela Smith | favour lab">Mr Jimmy Wray | absent ldem">Mr Ronnie Fearn | absent minister con"> Graham Brady | absent con"> Robert Key | absent con rightborder">Mr Teddy Taylor |
| absent minister lab">Mr Paul Boateng | favour minister lab"> Alistair Darling | favour minister lab"> Fabian Hamilton | favour lab"> David Lepper | favour minister lab"> Paul Murphy | absent minister lab">Mr Chris Smith | favour lab"> Anthony D Wright | against teller minister ldem"> Don Foster | absent minister con"> Julian Brazier | absent minister con">Mr Tom King | absent con rightborder">Mr John Townend |
| favour lab"> David Borrow | favour lab">Mr Keith Darvill | favour minister lab"> David Hanson | favour lab"> Chris Leslie | favour lab"> Doug Naysmith | favour lab"> Geraldine Smith | favour lab"> Tony Wright | against teller minister ldem"> Andrew George | absent minister con">Mr Peter Brooke | absent con"> Julie Kirkbride | absent minister con rightborder"> David Tredinnick |
| favour minister lab">Mr Keith Bradley | favour lab">Mrs Valerie Davey | favour minister lab"> Harriet Harman | favour lab"> Tom Levitt | favour lab"> Dan Norris | favour minister lab"> Jacqui Smith | absent lab"> Derek Wyatt | absent ldem"> Donald Gorrie | absent minister con"> Angela Browning | absent minister con"> Eleanor Laing | absent con rightborder">Mr Michael Trend |
| favour lab">Mr Peter Bradley | absent minister lab"> Ian Davidson | favour lab"> Sylvia Heal | favour lab"> Ivan Lewis | absent lab">B O'Brien. | favour lab"> John Smith | UUP partytype">UUP | absent minister ldem"> Mike Hancock | absent con">Mr Ian Bruce | absent con"> Jacqui Lait | absent minister con rightborder"> Andrew Tyrie |
| absent minister lab"> Ben Bradshaw | favour lab">Mr Denzil Davies | absent lab"> John Healey | favour lab">Mr Terry Lewis | favour minister lab"> Mike O'Brien | favour lab">Mr Llew Smith | UUP partytype2">+1 -0 (9) | against ldem"> Evan Harris | absent minister con"> Simon Burns | absent minister con"> Andrew Lansley | absent con rightborder"> Peter Viggers |
| absent minister lab"> Gordon Brown | absent minister lab"> Geraint Davies | absent lab"> Doug Henderson | absent minister lab">Mrs Helen Liddell | favour lab"> Edward O'Hara | favour lab">Mr Peter Snape | favour uup">Mr Roy Beggs | absent minister ldem"> Nick Harvey | absent con"> John Butterfill | absent minister con"> Edward Leigh | absent minister con rightborder"> Robert Walter |
| absent minister lab"> Nick Brown | absent lab">Mr Ron Davies | favour lab">Mr Ivan Henderson | favour lab"> Martin Linton | favour minister lab">M O'Neill. | favour minister lab">Mr Clive Soley | absent minister uup">J Donaldson. | against minister ldem"> David Heath | absent minister con"> Bill Cash | absent con"> Oliver Letwin | absent con rightborder"> Charles Wardle |
| favour minister lab"> Russell Brown | favour lab">Mr Terry Davis | absent minister lab"> Stephen Hepburn | favour lab"> Tony Lloyd | absent lab"> Bill Olner | favour lab"> Helen Southworth | absent uup">C Forsythe. | against minister ldem"> Simon Hughes | absent con">Sir Sydney Chapman | absent minister con"> Julian Lewis | absent con rightborder"> Nigel Waterson |
| favour lab"> Des Browne | favour lab">Mr Hilton Dawson | favour lab"> John Heppell | absent minister lab">Mr David Lock | absent lab">Mrs Diana Organ | favour minister lab"> John Spellar | absent uup">Mr Ken Maginnis | absent minister ldem">Mr Nigel Jones | absent minister con"> Christopher Chope | absent minister con"> David Lidington | absent con rightborder">Mr Bowen Wells |
| favour minister lab"> Karen Buck | favour lab"> Janet Dean | absent lab"> Stephen Hesford | favour minister lab"> Andrew Love | absent lab"> Sandra Osborne | favour lab"> Rachel Squire | absent uup">Mr William Ross | against ldem"> Paul Keetch | absent minister con"> James Clappison | absent con"> Peter Lilley | absent con rightborder">Sir Ray Whitney |
| favour lab"> Richard Burden | absent minister lab"> John Denham | absent minister lab"> Patricia Hewitt | absent lab">Mr Calum MacDonald | absent lab"> Nick Palmer | favour lab"> Phyllis Starkey | absent uup"> Martin Smyth | against minister ldem"> Charles Kennedy | absent con">Dr Michael Clark | absent con">Sir Peter Lloyd | absent con rightborder"> John Whittingdale |
| favour lab"> Colin Burgon | absent lab"> Donald Dewar | favour minister lab"> Keith Hill | favour lab"> Andrew MacKinlay | favour lab"> Ian Pearson | favour lab">Mr Gerry Steinberg | absent uup"> John Taylor | against minister ldem">Mr Archy Kirkwood | absent con"> Kenneth Clarke | absent minister con"> Tim Loughton | absent con rightborder"> Ann Widdecombe |
| favour lab">C Butler. | favour lab"> Andrew Dismore | favour lab">D Hinchliffe. | absent lab"> Denis MacShane | favour lab">Mr Tom Pendry | favour lab">G Stevenson. | absent uup">W Thompson. | against minister ldem">Mr Richard Livsey | absent minister con">G Clifton-Brown | absent minister con"> Peter Luff | absent con rightborder">Mr John Wilkinson |
| absent minister lab"> Stephen Byers | absent lab"> Jim Dobbin | absent minister lab"> Margaret Hodge | favour lab"> Fiona Mactaggart | favour lab">Ms Linda Perham | favour lab">Mr David Stewart | absent minister uup">D Trimble. | against ldem">R Maclennan. | absent con">Mr Tim Collins | absent con">Sir Nicholas Lyell | absent minister con rightborder"> David Willetts |
| absent minister lab"> Richard Caborn | absent lab"> Frank Dobson | absent minister lab"> Kate Hoey | favour lab">Mrs Alice Mahon | favour lab">Mr Colin Pickthall | favour lab"> Ian Stewart | absent uup">Mr Cecil Walker | absent ldem">Mrs Ray Michie | absent minister con"> Patrick Cormack | absent con">Mr John MacGregor | absent con rightborder"> David Wilshire |
| absent minister lab"> Alan Campbell | favour minister lab"> Brian H Donohoe | absent lab">J Home Robertson. | favour lab"> Judy Mallaber | absent lab">Mr Peter Pike | absent lab">P Stinchcombe. | UKUP partytype">UKUP | against minister ldem"> Michael Moore | absent con">Mr James Cran | absent con"> Andrew MacKay | absent con rightborder"> Ann Winterton |
| absent lab">Mrs Anne Campbell | favour lab"> Frank Doran | absent minister lab"> Jimmy Hood | absent minister lab">Mr Peter Mandelson | favour lab"> James Plaskitt | favour lab"> Howard Stoate | UKUP partytype2">+0 -0 (1) | absent ldem"> Mark Oaten | absent con"> David Curry | absent con"> David Maclean | absent con rightborder">N Winterton. |
| absent minister lab"> Ronnie Campbell | favour teller minister lab"> Jim Dowd | absent minister lab"> Geoff Hoon | absent lab">Dr John Marek | favour lab">Mr Kerry Pollard | favour lab"> Gavin Strang | absent ukup"> Robert McCartney | against ldem"> Lembit Öpik | absent con"> Quentin Davies | absent con">Mr David Madel | absent minister con rightborder"> Tim Yeo |
| favour minister lab">D Campbell-Savours | favour minister lab"> David Drew | favour lab"> Phil Hope | absent minister lab"> Gordon Marsden | favour lab">Mr Chris Pond | absent minister lab"> Jack Straw | SPK partytype">SPK | against ldem">Mr David Rendel | absent minister con"> David Davis | absent con">Mr John Major | absent minister con rightborder"> George Young |
| favour lab">Mr Jamie Cann | absent lab">Ms Julia Drown | favour lab"> Kelvin Hopkins | absent lab">Mr Paul Marsden | favour minister lab"> Greg Pope | favour minister lab"> Graham Stringer | SPK partytype2">+0 -0 (1) | against minister ldem"> Bob Russell | absent con">Mr Stephen Day | absent con"> Humfrey Malins | topborder rightborder"> |
| favour lab">Mr Ivor Caplin | absent lab"> Gwyneth Dunwoody | absent minister lab">Mr Alan Howarth | absent lab"> David Marshall | favour minister lab"> Steve Pound | favour minister lab"> Gisela Stuart | absent minister spk">B Boothroyd. | against minister ldem"> Adrian Sanders | absent con"> Stephen Dorrell | absent con"> John Maples | |
| favour lab">Mr Roger Casale | favour minister lab"> Angela Eagle | favour minister lab"> George Howarth | favour lab">Dr Jim Marshall | absent lab">Mr Raymond Powell | favour minister lab"> Gerry Sutcliffe | SNP partytype">SNP | against minister ldem"> Robert Smith | absent minister con"> Alan Duncan | absent con"> Michael Mates | |
| favour minister lab"> Martin Caton | favour lab"> Maria Eagle | absent minister lab"> Kim Howells | favour lab">R Marshall-Andrews | absent lab"> Bridget Prentice | favour minister lab">Mrs Ann Taylor | SNP partytype2">+0 -1 (5) | against minister ldem"> Andrew Stunell | absent minister con"> Iain Duncan Smith | absent minister con"> Francis Maude | |
| favour lab"> Ian Cawsey | absent lab">Mr Huw Edwards | favour minister lab"> Lindsay Hoyle | favour lab"> Eric Martlew | favour lab"> Gordon Prentice | favour lab"> Dari Taylor | absent snp">R Cunningham. | absent minister ldem"> Matthew Taylor | absent con">Sir Peter Emery | absent con">Dr Brian Mawhinney | |
| absent lab"> Ben Chapman | absent minister lab"> Clive Efford | favour minister lab"> Beverley Hughes | absent lab">Mr John Maxton | favour minister lab"> John Prescott | favour lab"> David Taylor | absent snp"> Margaret Ewing | against ldem">Dr Jenny Tonge | absent minister con"> Nigel Evans | absent minister con"> Theresa May | |
| favour lab bottomborder"> David Chaytor | favour lab bottomborder"> Louise Ellman | favour minister lab bottomborder">Mr Kevin Hughes | absent lab bottomborder"> John McAllion | favour minister lab bottomborder"> Dawn Primarolo | favour lab bottomborder">P Temple-Morris. | against snp bottomborder"> Alasdair Morgan | against minister ldem bottomborder">Mr Paul Tyler | absent con bottomborder">Mr David Faber | absent minister con bottomborder"> Anne McIntosh |