Planning etc (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 10 — Pre-application consultation — 15 Nov 2006 at 17:45

The question is, that amendment 74 be agreed to. Are we agreed?

No.

There will be a division.

Public Whip is run as a free not-for-profit service. If you'd like to support us, please consider switching your (UK) electricity and/or gas to Octopus Energy or tip us via Ko-Fi.

All Votes Cast - sorted by constituency

MPs for which their vote in this division differed from the majority vote of their party are marked in red. Also shows which MPs were ministers at the time of this vote. You can also see every eligible MP including those who did not vote in this division.

Sort by: Name | Constituency | Party | Vote

Name	Constituency	Party	Vote
Lewis Macdonald	Aberdeen Central	Lab	no
Brian Adam	Aberdeen North	SNP	abstention
Nicol Stephen	Aberdeen South	LDem	no
Karen Whitefield	Airdrie and Shotts	Lab	no
Andrew Welsh	Angus	SNP	abstention
George Lyon	Argyll and Bute	LDem	no
John Scott	Ayr	Con	no
Stewart Stevenson	Banff and Buchan	SNP	abstention
Cathy Jamieson	Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley	Lab	no
Christine May	Central Fife	Lab	no
Linda Fabiani	Central Scotland	SNP	abstention
Donald Gorrie	Central Scotland	LDem	aye
Carolyn Leckie	Central Scotland	SSP	aye
Margaret Mitchell	Central Scotland	Con	no
Alex Neil	Central Scotland	SNP	abstention
John Swinburne	Central Scotland	SSCUP	aye
Des McNulty	Clydebank and Milngavie	Lab	no
Karen Gillon	Clydesdale	Lab	no
Elaine Smith	Coatbridge and Chryston	Lab	no
Cathie Craigie	Cumbernauld and Kilsyth	Lab	no
Allan Wilson	Cunninghame North	Lab	no
Irene Oldfather	Cunninghame South	Lab	no
Jackie Baillie	Dumbarton	Lab	no
Elaine Murray	Dumfries	Lab	no
Shona Robison	Dundee East	SNP	abstention
Kate Maclean	Dundee West	Lab	no
Helen Eadie	Dunfermline East	Lab	no
Scott Barrie	Dunfermline West	Lab	no
Andy Kerr	East Kilbride	Lab	no
John Home Robertson	East Lothian	Lab	no
Kenneth Macintosh	Eastwood	Lab	no
Sarah Boyack	Edinburgh Central	Lab	no
Malcolm Chisholm	Edinburgh North and Leith	Lab	no
David McLetchie	Edinburgh Pentlands	Con	no
Mike Pringle	Edinburgh South	LDem	no
Margaret Smith	Edinburgh West	LDem	no
Cathy Peattie	Falkirk East	Lab	no
Dennis Canavan	Falkirk West	Independent	aye
Bill Aitken	Glasgow	Con	no
Robert Brown	Glasgow	LDem	no
Patrick Harvie	Glasgow	Green	aye
Rosie Kane	Glasgow	SSP	aye
Tommy Sheridan	Glasgow	whilst SG	aye
Nicola Sturgeon	Glasgow	SNP	abstention
Sandra White	Glasgow	SNP	abstention
Bill Butler	Glasgow Anniesland	Lab	no
Margaret Curran	Glasgow Baillieston	Lab	no
Charlie Gordon	Glasgow Cathcart	Lab	no
Gordon Jackson	Glasgow Govan	Lab	no
Pauline McNeill	Glasgow Kelvin	Lab	no
Patricia Ferguson	Glasgow Maryhill	Lab	no
Johann Lamont	Glasgow Pollok	Lab	no
Janis Hughes	Glasgow Rutherglen	Lab	no
Frank McAveety	Glasgow Shettleston	Lab	no
Paul Martin	Glasgow Springburn	Lab	no
Nora Radcliffe	Gordon	LDem	no
Duncan McNeil	Greenock and Inverclyde	Lab	no
Michael McMahon	Hamilton North and Bellshill	Lab	no
Tom McCabe	Hamilton South	Lab	no
Rob Gibson	Highlands and Islands	SNP	abstention
Maureen Macmillan	Highlands and Islands	Lab	no
Jim Mather	Highlands and Islands	SNP	abstention
Jamie McGrigor	Highlands and Islands	Con	no
Dave Petrie	Highlands and Islands	Con	no
Eleanor Scott	Highlands and Islands	Green	aye
Margaret Jamieson	Kilmarnock and Loudoun	Lab	no
Marilyn Livingstone	Kirkcaldy	Lab	no
Mary Mulligan	Linlithgow	Lab	no
Bristow Muldoon	Livingston	Lab	no
Lord James [Missing last name for 80026]	Lothians	Con	abstention
Mark Ballard	Lothians	Green	aye
Colin Fox	Lothians	SSP	aye
Robin Harper	Lothians	Green	aye
Fiona Hyslop	Lothians	SNP	abstention
Kenny MacAskill	Lothians	SNP	abstention
Margo MacDonald	Lothians	Independent	aye
Mr Andrew Arbuckle	Mid Scotland and Fife	LDem	no
Ted Brocklebank	Mid Scotland and Fife	Con	no
Bruce Crawford	Mid Scotland and Fife	SNP	abstention
Murdo Fraser	Mid Scotland and Fife	Con	no
Tricia Marwick	Mid Scotland and Fife	SNP	abstention
Mr Mark Ruskell	Mid Scotland and Fife	Green	aye
Rhona Brankin	Midlothian	Lab	no
Richard Lochhead	Moray	SNP	abstention
Rt Hon Jack McConnell	Motherwell and Wishaw	Lab	no
Iain Smith	North East Fife	LDem	no
Shiona Baird	North East Scotland	Green	aye
Richard Baker	North East Scotland	Lab	no
David Davidson	North East Scotland	Con	no
Marlyn Glen	North East Scotland	Lab	no
Alex Johnstone	North East Scotland	Con	no
Nanette Milne	North East Scotland	Con	no
Maureen Watt	North East Scotland	SNP	abstention
Jim Wallace	Orkney Islands	LDem	no
Wendy Alexander	Paisley North	Lab	no
Hugh Henry	Paisley South	Lab	no
Roseanna Cunningham	Perth	SNP	abstention
John Farquhar Munro	Ross, Skye and Inverness West	LDem	no
Euan Robson	Roxburgh and Berwickshire	LDem	no
Tavish Scott	Shetland Islands	LDem	no
Chris Ballance	South of Scotland	Green	aye
Derek Brownlee	South of Scotland	Con	no
Ms Rosemary Byrne	South of Scotland	whilst SG	aye
Phil Gallie	South of Scotland	Con	no
Christine Grahame	South of Scotland	SNP	abstention
Adam Ingram	South of Scotland	SNP	abstention
Alasdair Morgan	South of Scotland	SNP	abstention
Sylvia Jackson	Stirling	Lab	no
Dr Jean Turner	Strathkelvin and Bearsden	Independent	abstention
Jeremy Purvis	Tweeddale, Ettrick and Lauderdale	LDem	no
Mike Rumbles	West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine	LDem	no
Frances Curran	West of Scotland	SSP	aye
Ross Finnie	West of Scotland	LDem	no
Annabel Goldie	West of Scotland	Con	no
Campbell Martin	West of Scotland	whilst Independent	aye
Stewart Maxwell	West of Scotland	SNP	abstention
Mr Bruce McFee	West of Scotland	SNP	abstention
Murray Tosh	West of Scotland	Con	no
Trish Godman	West Renfrewshire	Lab	no
Alasdair Morrison	Western Isles	Lab	no

Planning etc (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — Section 10 — Pre-application consultation — 15 Nov 2006 at 17:45

All Votes Cast - sorted by constituency

About the Project

The Whip on the Web

Help keep PublicWhip alive