Voting Comparison — Lord Carlile of Berriew
to Lord Butler of Brockwell

Lord Carlile of Berriew

Note: our records only go back to 1997 for the Commons and 2001 for the Lords (more details).

FromToPartyRebellions (explain...)Attendance (explain...)Teller
13 Jan 2017 still in office Crossbench 74 votes out of 377, 19.6% 377 votes out of 804, 46.9% 1 time
30 Nov 1998 12 Jan 2017 LDem 43 votes out of 487, 8.8% 487 votes out of 2049, 23.8% 0 times

Voting Differences

HouseDateSubjectLord Carlile of BerriewLord Butler of BrockwellRôle
Lords16 Apr 2024Safety of Rwanda (Asylum and Immigration) Bill - Commons Amendments and Reasons — Motion C1 (as an amendment to Motion C) Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords6 Mar 2024Safety of Rwanda (Asylum and Immigration) Bill - Report (2nd Day) — Amendment 33 Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords19 Jul 2023Online Safety Bill - Report (5th Day) — Amendment 245 Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords28 Jun 2023Illegal Migration Bill - Report (1st Day) — Amendment 12 Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords28 Jun 2023Illegal Migration Bill - Report (1st Day) — Amendment 6 Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords21 Jun 2023National Security Bill - Commons Amendments and Reasons — Motion A1 (as an amendment to Motion A) tellayeno disagrees with policy
Lords1 Mar 2023National Security Bill - Report (1st Day) — Amendment 18A minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords4 Apr 2022Nationality and Borders Bill - Commons Amendments — Motion B1 (as an amendment to Motion B) minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords28 Feb 2022Nationality and Borders Bill - Report (1st Day) — Amendment 24 minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords20 Jul 2021Conduct - Motion to Agree — Motion Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords13 Jul 2021Procedure and Privileges - Motion to Agree — Amendment to the Motion Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords28 Apr 2021Abortion (Northern Ireland) Regulations 2021 - Motion to Approve — Amendment to the Motion Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords28 Apr 2021Abortion (Northern Ireland) Regulations 2021 - Motion to Approve — Amendment to the Motion Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords21 Apr 2021Domestic Abuse Bill - Commons Reasons and Amendments — Motion F1 (as an amendment to Motion F) Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords17 Mar 2021Domestic Abuse Bill - Report (4th Day) Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords15 Mar 2021Domestic Abuse Bill - Report (3rd Day) — Amendment 70 Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords10 Mar 2021Domestic Abuse Bill - Report (2nd Day) — Amendment 44 Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords10 Mar 2021Domestic Abuse Bill - Report (2nd Day) — Amendment 21 Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords3 Mar 2021Counter-Terrorism and Sentencing Bill - Report — Amendment 1 Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords23 Feb 2021Trade Bill - Commons Reasons and Amendments — Motion B1 (as an amendment to Motion B) minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords2 Feb 2021Trade Bill - Commons Amendments — Motion C1 (as an amendment to Motion C) Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords2 Feb 2021Trade Bill - Commons Amendments — Motion B1 (as an amendment to Motion B) Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords2 Feb 2021Trade Bill - Commons Amendments — Motion A1 (as an amendment to Motion A) minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords2 Feb 2021Public Health (Coronavirus) (Protection from Eviction) (England) Regulations 2021 - Motion to Approve — Amendment to the Motion Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords13 Jan 2021Covert Human Intelligence Sources (Criminal Conduct) Bill - Report (2nd Day) — Amendment 42 Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords13 Jan 2021Covert Human Intelligence Sources (Criminal Conduct) Bill - Report (2nd Day) — Amendment 24 minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords12 Jan 2021Medicines and Medical Devices Bill - Report (1st Day) — Amendment 3 minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords12 Jan 2021Medicines and Medical Devices Bill - Report (1st Day) — Amendment 2 minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords6 Jan 2021Trade Bill - Report (3rd Day) — Amendment 31A (to Amendment 31) Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords15 Dec 2020Trade Bill - Report (Day 2) — Amendment 12 minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords14 Dec 2020United Kingdom Internal Market Bill - Commons Reasons and Amendments — Motion G1 (as an amendment to Motion G) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords14 Dec 2020United Kingdom Internal Market Bill - Commons Reasons and Amendments — Motion A1 (as an amendment to Motion A) Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords9 Dec 2020United Kingdom Internal Market Bill - Commons Reasons and Amendments — Motion B1 (as an amendment to Motion B) minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords30 Nov 2020High Speed Rail (West Midlands–Crewe) Bill - Report (1st Day) — Amendment 5 Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords26 Nov 2020Parliamentary Constituencies Bill - Commons Reasons — Motion E1 (as an amendment to Motion E) minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords25 Nov 2020United Kingdom Internal Market Bill - Report (3rd Day) — Amendment 64 Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords17 Nov 2020Fire Safety Bill - Report — Amendment 13 minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords21 Oct 2020Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill - Commons Reasons — Motion E1 (as an amendment to Motion E) minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords21 Oct 2020Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill - Commons Reasons — Motion B1 (as an amendment to Motion B) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords20 Oct 2020Agriculture Bill - Commons Reasons — Motion C1 (as an amendment to Motion C) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords8 Oct 2020Parliamentary Constituencies Bill - Report — Amendment 16 minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords5 Oct 2020Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill - Report (2nd Day) (Continued) — Amendment 18 minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords1 Jul 2020Prisoners (Disclosure of Information About Victims) Bill - Report — Amendment 17 minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords29 Jun 2020Telecommunications Infrastructure (Leasehold Property) Bill - Report — Amendment 1 Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords15 Jun 2020Extradition (Provisional Arrest) Bill [HL] - Third Reading — Amendment 2 minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords20 Jan 2020European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Bill - Report (1st Day) — Amendment 1 Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords26 Feb 2019Mental Capacity (Amendment) Bill [HL] - Commons Amendments — Amendment 25A (as an amendment to Commons Amendment 25) Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords12 Jun 2018Civil Liability Bill [HL] - Report minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords8 May 2018European Union (Withdrawal) Bill - Report (6th Day) Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords2 May 2018European Union (Withdrawal) Bill - Report (5th Day) Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords30 Apr 2018European Union (Withdrawal) Bill - Report (4th Day) Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords30 Apr 2018European Union (Withdrawal) Bill - Report (4th Day) Majoritytellaye disagrees with policy
Lords23 Apr 2018European Union (Withdrawal) Bill - Report (2nd Day) Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords23 Apr 2018European Union (Withdrawal) Bill - Report (2nd Day) Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords17 Apr 2018Haulage Permits and Trailer Registration Bill [HL] - Report Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords27 Mar 2017Technical and Further Education Bill - Report Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords20 Mar 2017Digital Economy Bill - Report (2nd Day) minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords7 Mar 2017European Union (Notification of Withdrawal) Bill - Report (Continued) minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords7 Mar 2017European Union (Notification of Withdrawal) Bill - Report Majorityaye disagrees with policy
HouseDateSubjectLord Carlile of BerriewLord Butler of BrockwellRôle
Lords12 Oct 2016Bus Services Bill [HL] - Report (1st Day) minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords12 Oct 2016Bus Services Bill [HL] - Report (1st Day) Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords9 Mar 2016Immigration Bill — Report (1st Day) Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords9 Mar 2016Immigration Bill — Report (1st Day) Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords7 Mar 2016Tax Credits (Income Thresholds and Determination of Rates) (Amendment) Regulations 2016 — Motion to Approve minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords29 Feb 2016Welfare Reform and Work Bill - Commons Reasons and Amendment Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords2 Feb 2016Feed-in Tariffs (Amendment) (No. 3) Order 2015 — Motion to Annul minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords20 Jan 2016Trade Union Bill — Motion Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords11 Mar 2015Small Business, Enterprise and Employment Bill — Report (3rd Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords16 Jan 2015Assisted Dying Bill [HL] — Committee (2nd Day) minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords16 Jan 2015Assisted Dying Bill [HL] — Committee (2nd Day) minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords26 Nov 2014Consumer Rights Bill — Report (3rd Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords27 Oct 2014Criminal Justice and Courts Bill — Report (3rd Day) Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords15 Jan 2014Transparency of Lobbying, Non-Party Campaigning and Trade Union Administration Bill — Committee (2nd Day) minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords10 Jul 2013Marriage (Same Sex Couples) Bill — Report (2nd Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords8 Jul 2013Marriage (Same Sex Couples) Bill — Report (1st Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords8 Jul 2013Marriage (Same Sex Couples) Bill — Report (1st Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords4 Jun 2013Marriage (Same Sex Couples) Bill — Second Reading (2nd Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords24 Apr 2013Procedure of the House — Motion to Resolve Majoritytellaye disagrees with policy
Lords14 Jan 2013Electoral Registration and Administration Bill — Committee (2nd Day) Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords25 Apr 2012Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill — Commons Reasons and Amendment Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords23 Apr 2012Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill — Commons Reasons and Amendments Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords7 Mar 2012Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill — Report (2nd Day) Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords7 Mar 2012Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill — Report (2nd Day) Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords5 Mar 2012Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill — Report (1st Day) minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords5 Mar 2012Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill — Report (1st Day) Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords6 Feb 2012Protection of Freedoms Bill — Report (2nd Day) minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords31 Jan 2012Welfare Reform Bill — Third Reading Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords8 Nov 2011Procedure of the House (Proposal 9) — Motion to Resolve Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords18 Jul 2011Fixed-term Parliaments Bill — Consideration of Commons Reason minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords13 Jul 2011European Union Bill — Minister Empowered to Determine Referendum on Increased EU Powers and Competences Not Required Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords8 Jun 2011European Union Bill — Report (1st Day) — Clause 2 — Treaties amending or replacing TEU or TFEU Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords10 May 2011Fixed-term Parliaments Bill — Report (1st Day) minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords4 Apr 2011Public Bodies Bill [HL] — Report (3rd Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords4 Apr 2011Public Bodies Bill [HL] — Report (3rd Day) Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords9 Feb 2011Parliamentary Voting System and Constituencies Bill — Allowing Greater Variation from Mean Number of Electors in MP Constituency in Exceptional Circumstances minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords9 Nov 2010Public Bodies Bill [HL] — Second Reading Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords25 Jan 2010Equality Bill — Committee (4th Day) minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords25 Jan 2010Equality Bill — Committee (4th Day) minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords25 Jan 2010Equality Bill — Committee (4th Day) minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords7 Jul 2009Coroners and Justice Bill — New Clause — Assisted Suicide Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords12 May 2006Assisted Dying for the Terminally Ill Bill — Delay Second Reading Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords15 Mar 2006Identity Cards Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords4 Feb 2003House of Lords Reform — 80 per cent appointed/20 per cent elected Majoritytellaye disagrees with policy
Lords4 Feb 2003House of Lords Reform — fully elected minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords5 Nov 2002Lords Amendment Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords26 Mar 2001Hunting Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords28 Sep 2000Criminal Justice (Mode of Trial) (No. 2) Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords24 Jul 2000Local Government Bill, removing bullying clause minorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords20 Jan 2000Criminal Justice (Mode of Trial) Bill [H.L.] Majorityno disagrees with policy

About the Project

The Public Whip is a not-for-profit, open source website created in 2003 by Francis Irving and Julian Todd and now run by Bairwell Ltd.

The Whip on the Web

Help keep PublicWhip alive