Voting Comparison — Clare Short MP, Birmingham, Ladywood
to Mr Peter Duncan MP, Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
Clare Short
Note: our records only go back to 1997 for the Commons and 2001 for the Lords (more details).
From | To | Party | Rebellions (explain...) | Attendance (explain...) | Teller |
21 Oct 2006 | 12 Apr 2010 | Independent Labour | no whip | 117 votes out of 970, 12.1% | 0 times |
5 May 2005 | 20 Oct 2006 | Lab | 33 votes out of 179, 18.4% | 179 votes out of 318, 56.3% | 0 times |
7 Jun 2001 | 11 Apr 2005 | Lab | 43 votes out of 420, 10.2% | 420 votes out of 1246, 33.7% | 0 times |
1 May 1997 | 14 May 2001 | Lab | 0 votes out of 413, 0.0% | 413 votes out of 1273, 32.4% | 0 times |
Voting Differences
House | Date | Subject | Clare Short | Mr Peter Duncan | Rôle | |
no votes listed | ||||||
House | Date | Subject | Clare Short | Mr Peter Duncan | Rôle | |
no votes listed | ||||||
House | Date | Subject | Clare Short | Mr Peter Duncan | Rôle | |
Commons | 15 Mar 2005 | European Union Documents — Creation of a Fundamental Rights Agency | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 10 Mar 2005 | Support For Members Who Have Chosen Not To Take Their Seats | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 10 Mar 2005 | Support For Members Who Have Chosen Not To Take Their Seats | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 2 Mar 2005 | Council Tax | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 8 Feb 2005 | Belmarsh Judgment | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 1 Feb 2005 | Constitutional Reform Bill [Lords] — [2nd Allotted Day] — Clause 106 — Removal from listed judicial offices | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 1 Feb 2005 | Constitutional Reform Bill [Lords] — [2nd Allotted Day] — Clause 105 — Removal from most senior judicial offices | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 1 Dec 2004 | Economic Affairs | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 30 Nov 2004 | Health and Education | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 17 Nov 2004 | Pensions Bill | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 16 Nov 2004 | Pensions Bill — Clause 168 — Amounts to be raised by the pension protection levies | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 18 Oct 2004 | Crime | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 18 Oct 2004 | Crime | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 13 Oct 2004 | Pensions and Welfare Reform | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 13 Oct 2004 | Pensions and Welfare Reform | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 12 Oct 2004 | Civil Partnership Bill [Lords] (Programme) | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 14 Sep 2004 | Older Women | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 14 Sep 2004 | Older Women | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 14 Sep 2004 | Higher Education | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 8 Sep 2004 | Pensions Policy | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 20 Jul 2004 | Energy Bill [Lords] (Programme) (No. 2) | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 7 Jul 2004 | Finance Bill — Schedule 40 — Repeals | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 7 Jul 2004 | Clause 5 — Rates — Schedule 15 — Charge to income tax on benefits received by former owner of property | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 6 Jul 2004 | Finance Bill — [1st Allotted Day] — New Clause 7 — Application of sections 298 to 301 | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 5 Jul 2004 | Personal Indebtedness and Savings | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 5 Jul 2004 | Personal Indebtedness and Savings | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 28 Jun 2004 | Human Tissue Bill — New Clause 1 — Determination of consent for removal, storage and use of organs from Adults for purpose of transplantation | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 22 Jun 2004 | Nhs Recruitment and Retention | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 22 Jun 2004 | Electoral System | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 15 Jun 2004 | Transport | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 26 May 2004 | Local Government Finance | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 17 May 2004 | Local Government Finance | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 17 May 2004 | Iraq — Security Situation | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 5 May 2004 | Housing | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 5 May 2004 | Housing | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 4 May 2004 | Scottish Parliament (Constituencies) Bill — [Sir Alan Haselhurst in the Chair] — Clause 1 — Constituencies and Regions | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 28 Apr 2004 | Finance Bill — [2nd Allotted Day] — Schedule 37 — Stamp Duty Land Tax and Stamp Duty | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 28 Apr 2004 | Finance Bill — [2nd Allotted Day] — Clause 86 — Income Of Spouses: Jointly Held Property | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 27 Apr 2004 | Finance Bill — [1st Allotted Day] — Clause 28 — The Non-Corporate Distribution Rate | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 27 Apr 2004 | Finance Bill — [1st Allotted Day] — Clause 5 — Rates | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 21 Apr 2004 | London | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 21 Apr 2004 | London | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 30 Mar 2004 | EU Constitution Referendum | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 30 Mar 2004 | Immigration Entry Clearance Standards | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 29 Mar 2004 | Employment Relations Bill — Clause 34 — Information and Consultation: Great Britain | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 29 Mar 2004 | Employment Relations Bill — New Clause 2 — Intimidation | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 29 Mar 2004 | European Parliamentary and Local Elections (Pilots) Bill | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 23 Mar 2004 | Budget Resolutions and Economic Situation — 36. Construction industry scheme | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 23 Mar 2004 | Budget Resolutions 2004 — Non-Corporate Distribution Rate | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 23 Mar 2004 | Budget Resolutions and Economic Situation | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 23 Mar 2004 | Budget Resolutions and Economic Situation | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 23 Mar 2004 | Budget Resolutions and Economic Situation | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 16 Mar 2004 | European Parliamentary and Local Elections (Pilots) Bill — Lords Amendment 1B — Lords Disagreement and Reason | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 16 Mar 2004 | European Parliamentary and Local Elections (Pilots) Bill | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 10 Mar 2004 | Justice (Northern Ireland) Bill [Lords] | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 10 Feb 2004 | The Environment | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 9 Feb 2004 | Scottish Parliament (Constituencies) Bill (Programme) | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 9 Feb 2004 | Scottish Parliament (Constituencies) Bill | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 3 Feb 2004 | Child Trust Funds Bill — Clause 27 — Commencement | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 21 Jan 2004 | Scottish Constituencies (Members' Voting Rights) | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 21 Jan 2004 | Case for a Civil Service Bill | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 13 Jan 2004 | Future of the Post Office Network — Congratulates the Government | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 13 Jan 2004 | Future of the Post Office Network — Deplores the programme — rejected | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 13 Jan 2004 | Iraq — National Audit Office Report on Operation Telic | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 16 Dec 2003 | European Parliamentary and Local Elections (Pilots) Bill — New Clause 4 — Conduct of elections under a pilot order | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 16 Dec 2003 | European Parliamentary and Local Elections (Pilots) Bill — New Clause 2 — Additional provisions in respect of postal voting | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 18 Nov 2003 | Criminal Justice Bill — New Clause | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 18 Nov 2003 | Criminal Justice Bill (Programme) | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 18 Nov 2003 | Sexual Offences Bill [Lords] — New Clause | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 12 Nov 2003 | Taxes — Taxes | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 12 Nov 2003 | Taxes | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 5 Nov 2003 | Water Bill [Lords] (Programme) (No. 3) | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 5 Nov 2003 | Decommissioning (Northern Ireland) | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 28 Oct 2003 | Waste and Emissions Trading Bill [Lords] — New Clause 5 — Environmental impact assessment of incineration | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 28 Oct 2003 | Waste and Emissions Trading Bill [Lords] — New Clause 1 — Strategies for Waste Minimisation: England | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 15 Oct 2003 | State Pension Reform | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 16 Sep 2003 | EU Constitution | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 15 Jul 2003 | Sexual Offences Bill | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 9 Jul 2003 | Convention on the Future of Europe | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 8 Jul 2003 | Health and Social Care (Community Health and Standards) Bill (Programme) (No. 2) | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 1 Jul 2003 | Finance Bill — Clause 56 — Amount of Tax Chargeable: Rent | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 1 Jul 2003 | Finance Bill — Schedule 21 — Approved Share Plans and Schemes | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 1 Jul 2003 | Finance Bill — Clause 9 — Bingo Duty | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 1 Jul 2003 | Finance Bill — New Clause 1 — Tax Credits for Individual Savings Accounts and Personal Equity Plans | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 17 Jun 2003 | Community Pharmacies | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 10 Jun 2003 | Planning and Compulsory Purchase Bill (ReCommittal) | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 10 Jun 2003 | Planning and Compulsory Purchase Bill (Extension of Period for Proceedings) | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 4 Jun 2003 | Pensions | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 4 Jun 2003 | Pensions | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 14 Apr 2003 | Budget Resolutions and Economic Situation | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 14 Apr 2003 | Budget Resolutions and Economic Situation | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 25 Feb 2003 | Delegated Legislation — Local Government Bill (Programme) (No. 3) | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 25 Feb 2003 | Communications Bill — 'Part 1A Channel 5 Services | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 25 Feb 2003 | Communications Bill — New Clause 4 — Investigation of the BBC by the National Audit Office | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 4 Feb 2003 | House of Lords Reform — Option 1 (Fully Appointed) — rejected | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 13 Jan 2003 | Criminal Justice System | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 19 Nov 2002 | Regions, Transport and DEFRA | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 21 Oct 2002 | Tobacco Advertising and Promotion Bill [Lords] — New Clause 2 — Commission of body to study the effects of Act | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 16 Oct 2002 | Rural Economy | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 16 Oct 2002 | Rural Economy | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 8 Jul 2002 | Care Homes | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 25 Jun 2002 | Zimbabwe | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 25 Jun 2002 | Mental Health | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 19 Jun 2002 | World Poverty | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 11 Jun 2002 | Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Bill — Only allow destitute asylum seekers and those under residence restrictions to live in accommodation centres for a maximum of 10 weeks — rejected | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 11 Jun 2002 | Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Bill — [1st Allotted Day] — Clause 14 — Establishment of centres | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 11 Jun 2002 | Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Bill — [1st Allotted Day] — New Clause 8 — Compensation for depreciation of property value | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 10 Jun 2002 | National Insurance Contributions Bill — Clause 2 — Secondary Class 1 contributions | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 30 Apr 2002 | Finance Bill | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 30 Apr 2002 | Finance Bill | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 29 Apr 2002 | Tobacco Advertising and Promotion Bill [Lords] (Programme) — Consideration and Third Reading | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 29 Apr 2002 | Tobacco Advertising and Promotion Bill — Second Reading | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 24 Apr 2002 | Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Bill (Programme) — Programming Committee | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 23 Apr 2002 | Budget Resolutions and Economic Situation | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 23 Apr 2002 | Budget Resolutions and Economic Situation | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 25 Mar 2002 | State Pension Credit Bill [Lords] — Consideration and Third Reading | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 12 Mar 2002 | London and the South-East | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 12 Mar 2002 | London and the South-East | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 4 Feb 2002 | Pensions and Benefits | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 4 Feb 2002 | Pensions and Benefits | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 4 Feb 2002 | Asylum Seekers | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 29 Jan 2002 | Post Office — Condemnation of previous Conservative government | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 29 Jan 2002 | Post Office — Condemnation of government mismanagement — rejected | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 18 Dec 2001 | Facilities of the House | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 18 Dec 2001 | Facilities of the House | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 18 Dec 2001 | Facilities of the House | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 18 Dec 2001 | Facilities of the House | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 12 Dec 2001 | Deferred Divisions — European Arrest Warrant and the Surrender Procedures Between Member States | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 12 Dec 2001 | Anti-terrorism, Crime and Security Bill — Removal of Sunset Clause | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 12 Dec 2001 | Anti-terrorism, Crime and Security Bill — Lords' Amendment No. 6 | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 12 Dec 2001 | Anti-terrorism, Crime and Security Bill — Programme — Lord' Amendments | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 10 Dec 2001 | Tax Credits Bill (Programme) — Consideration and Third Reading | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 3 Dec 2001 | Public Services | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 3 Dec 2001 | Public Services | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 28 Nov 2001 | Delegated Legislation — Nurses and Midwives | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 28 Nov 2001 | Civil Defence (Grant) Bill | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 27 Nov 2001 | Employment Bill — amendment to the second reading motion | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 26 Nov 2001 | Anti-terrorism, Crime and Security Bill — Amendment to Clause 17 — Disclosure Powers | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 26 Nov 2001 | Anti-terrorism, Crime and Security Bill — Amendment to Clause 97 — Jurisdiction of MoD police | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 26 Nov 2001 | Anti-terrorism, Crime and Security Bill — Amendment to Clause 89 — Identification at a Police Station | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 26 Nov 2001 | Anti-terrorism, Crime and Security Bill — Clause 38 — Religious Hatred | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 23 Oct 2001 | Ministerial Conduct (DTLR) | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 18 Jul 2001 | European Communities (Amendment) Bill — New Clause 12 — Referendum (No. 1) | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 11 Jul 2001 | Deferred Divisions — Education | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 4 Jul 2001 | European Communities (Amendment) Bill (Programme) — Proceedings in Committee, on consideration and on Third Reading | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 4 Jul 2001 | European Communities (Amendment) Bill | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |
Commons | 4 Jul 2001 | European Communities (Amendment) Bill | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
House | Date | Subject | Clare Short | Mr Peter Duncan | Rôle | |
no votes listed |