Environment Bill — Report (2nd Day) — Amendment 27 — 8 Sep 2021 at 19:45

Moved by Lord Anderson of Ipswich

27: Clause 38, page 23, line 8, leave out subsection (8) and insert-“(8) Where the court makes a statement of non-compliance it may grant any remedy that may be granted by it on a judicial review other than damages.(8A) In determining whether it would be in the interests of justice to grant a remedy, the court must have regard to-(a) the nature and consequences of the authority’s failure to comply with environmental law, and(b) the likelihood that the grant of a remedy would cause-(i) substantial hardship to, or substantial prejudice to the rights of, any person other than the authority, or(ii) any detriment to good administration.”Member’s explanatory statementThis amendment removes the restrictions on the discretion of a court to grant a remedy where the court has found there to be a breach of environmental law, while requiring the court to have regard to relevant factors. The bar on awarding damages to the OEP is retained.

Ayes 153, Noes 143.

Debate in Parliament |

Public Whip is run as a free not-for-profit free service. If you'd like to support us, please consider switching your electricity and/or gas to Bulb Energy who provide 100% renewable electricity and tend to be 20% cheaper than the 'Big Six'. They'll also pay any exit fees (up to £120) from your old supplier AND give you (and us) a £50 credit for joining up via our Bulb Referral Link.

All Votes Cast - sorted by party

Lords for which their vote in this division differed from the majority vote of their party are marked in red. Also shows which lords were ministers at the time of this vote. You can also see every eligible lord including those who did not vote in this division.

Sort by: Name | Party | Vote

NamePartyVote
The Bishop of OxfordBishopaye
Lord Duncan of SpringbankCon (front bench)aye
Lord Garnier Conaye
Lord Mackay of ClashfernConaye
The Duke of WellingtonConaye
Lord Agnew of OultonCon (front bench)no
Lord Ahmad of WimbledonCon (front bench)no
Baroness Anelay of St JohnsCon (front bench)no
Lord Ashton of HydeCon (front bench)no
Lord Astor of HeverConno
Earl Attlee Conno
Lord Balfe Conno
Baroness Barran Con (front bench)no
Baroness Berridge Con (front bench)no
Lord Bethell Con (front bench)no
Lord Black of BrentwoodCon (front bench)no
Lord Blackwell Conno
Lord Blencathra Con (front bench)no
Baroness Bloomfield of Hinton WaldristCon (front bench)no
Lord Borwick Con (front bench)no
Lord Brabazon of TaraCon (front bench)no
Lord Brougham and Vaux Con (front bench)no
Lord Brownlow of Shurlock RowConno
Lord Caine Con (front bench)no
Lord Callanan Con (front bench)no
Lord Carrington of FulhamConno
Earl Cathcart Conno
Baroness Chalker of WallaseyCon (front bench)no
Baroness Chisholm of OwlpenCon (front bench)no
Lord Cormack Con (front bench)no
The Earl of CourtownCon (front bench)no
Lord Crathorne Con (front bench)no
Lord Davies of GowerCon (front bench)no
Lord de Mauley Con (front bench)no
Lord Dobbs Conno
Baroness Eaton Con (front bench)no
Viscount Eccles Con (front bench)no
Baroness Eccles of MoultonConno
Baroness Evans of Bowes ParkCon (front bench)no
Lord Fairfax of CameronConno
Baroness Fall Con (front bench)no
Lord Farmer Conno
Lord Finkelstein Conno
Baroness Fookes Con (front bench)no
Lord Forsyth of DrumleanCon (front bench)no
Lord Frost Conno
Lord Geddes Con (front bench)no
Lord Glendonbrook Conno
Baroness Goldie Con (front bench)no
Lord Goldsmith of Richmond ParkCon (front bench)no
Lord Greenhalgh Conno
Lord Hamilton of EpsomConno
Lord Haselhurst Con (front bench)no
Lord Hayward Con (front bench)no
Baroness Helic Con (front bench)no
Lord Henley Conno
Baroness Hodgson of AbingerCon (front bench)no
Lord Hodgson of Astley AbbottsCon (front bench)no
Lord Holmes of RichmondCon (front bench)no
Baroness Hooper Conno
Lord Horam Con (front bench)no
Lord Howard of LympneConno
Lord Howard of RisingConno
Earl Howe Con (front bench)no
Lord Howell of GuildfordCon (front bench)no
Lord Hunt of WirralConno
Baroness Jenkin of KenningtonCon (front bench)no
Lord Jopling Conno
Lord Kirkham Conno
Lord Lamont of LerwickCon (front bench)no
Lord Lilley Con (front bench)no
The Earl of LindsayCon (front bench)no
Lord Lingfield Con (front bench)no
Lord Lucas Con (front bench)no
Lord Mancroft Con (front bench)no
Baroness Manzoor Conno
Lord McColl of DulwichCon (front bench)no
Lord McInnes of KilwinningCon (front bench)no
Baroness Meyer Con (front bench)no
Baroness Mobarik Conno
The Duke of MontroseCon (front bench)no
Baroness Morgan of CotesCon (front bench)no
Lord Moynihan Conno
Lord Naseby Con (front bench)no
Lord Nash Conno
Baroness Noakes Con (front bench)no
Lord Norton of LouthConno
Lord Parkinson of Whitley BayCon (front bench)no
Lord Pickles Con (front bench)no
Baroness Pidding Con (front bench)no
Lord Popat Conno
Lord Price Conno
Lord Reay Conno
Baroness Redfern Conno
Lord Risby Conno
Baroness Rock Con (front bench)no
Baroness Sanderson of WeltonCon (front bench)no
Baroness Sater Con (front bench)no
Baroness Scott of BybrookCon (front bench)no
Baroness Seccombe Con (front bench)no
Lord Sheikh Conno
Lord Sherbourne of DidsburyCon (front bench)no
Lord Shinkwin Conno
The Earl of ShrewsburyConno
Lord Smith of HindheadCon (front bench)no
Baroness Stedman-Scott Con (front bench)no
Lord Sterling of PlaistowConno
Baroness Stowell of BeestonConno
Baroness Stroud Conno
Lord Suri Conno
Lord Taylor of HolbeachConno
Lord Tebbit Conno
Lord Trefgarne Conno
Viscount Trenchard Con (front bench)no
Lord True Con (front bench)no
Baroness Vere of NorbitonCon (front bench)no
Baroness Verma Con (front bench)no
Lord Wei Conno
Lord Whitby Conno
Baroness Williams of TraffordCon (front bench)no
Lord Young of CookhamCon (front bench)no
Viscount Younger of LeckieCon (front bench)no
Lord Aberdare Crossbenchaye
Lord Alton of LiverpoolCrossbench (front bench)aye
Lord Anderson of IpswichCrossbench (front bench)aye
Baroness Boycott Crossbench (front bench)aye
Baroness Brown of CambridgeCrossbench (front bench)aye
Viscount Craigavon Crossbenchaye
Baroness Finlay of LlandaffCrossbench (front bench)aye
Lord Hannay of ChiswickCrossbench (front bench)aye
Lord Krebs Crossbench (front bench)aye
Baroness Masham of IltonCrossbenchaye
Baroness O'Loan Crossbenchaye
Lord Pannick Crossbench (front bench)aye
Lord Ravensdale Crossbenchaye
The Earl of SandwichCrossbench (front bench)aye
Lord Carrington Crossbenchno
Lord Browne of BelmontDUPno
Lord Morrow DUPno
Baroness Bennett of Manor CastleGreenaye
Baroness Jones of MoulsecoombGreenaye
Lord Hope of CraigheadJudge (front bench)aye
Lord Judge Judge (front bench)aye
Lord Thomas of CwmgieddJudge (front bench)aye
Baroness Adams of CraigieleaLab (minister)aye
Lord Anderson of SwanseaLab (minister)aye
Lord Bach Labaye
Baroness Blackstone Lab (minister)aye
Baroness Blower Labaye
Lord Boateng Labaye
Lord Bradley Lab (minister)aye
Lord Browne of LadytonLab (minister)aye
Baroness Bryan of PartickLab (minister)aye
Lord Campbell-Savours Lab (minister)aye
Baroness Chakrabarti Labaye
Lord Clark of WindermereLabaye
Lord Collins of HighburyLab (minister)aye
Baroness Corston Lab (minister)aye
Baroness Crawley Lab (minister)aye
Lord Davidson of Glen ClovaLab (minister)aye
Baroness Donaghy Lab (minister)aye
Baroness Drake Lab (minister)aye
Lord Dubs Lab (minister)aye
Lord Elder Lab (minister)aye
Lord Faulkner of WorcesterLab (minister)aye
Lord Foulkes of CumnockLab (minister)aye
Baroness Golding Labaye
Lord Grantchester Lab (minister)aye
Lord Grocott Lab (minister)aye
Viscount Hanworth Lab (minister)aye
Lord Harris of HaringeyLab (minister)aye
Lord Haworth Labaye
Baroness Hayter of Kentish TownLab (minister)aye
Baroness Healy of Primrose HillLab (minister)aye
Lord Hendy Labaye
Lord Hunt of Kings HeathLab (minister)aye
Baroness Jones of WhitchurchLab (minister)aye
Lord Kennedy of SouthwarkLab (minister)aye
Lord Knight of WeymouthLab (minister)aye
Baroness Lawrence of ClarendonLabaye
Lord Layard Lab (minister)aye
Lord McAvoy Lab (minister)aye
Baroness McIntosh of HudnallLab (minister)aye
Lord McKenzie of LutonLabaye
Lord McNicol of West KilbrideLab (minister)aye
Baroness Morris of YardleyLab (minister)aye
Baroness Osamor Lab (minister)aye
Lord Ponsonby of ShulbredeLab (minister)aye
Baroness Primarolo Lab (minister)aye
Baroness Quin Lab (minister)aye
Baroness Ramsay of CartvaleLabaye
Lord Rooker Labaye
Lord Rosser Lab (minister)aye
Lord Sawyer Labaye
Baroness Sherlock Lab (minister)aye
Baroness Smith of BasildonLab (minister)aye
Baroness Taylor of BoltonLab (minister)aye
Baroness Thornton Lab (minister)aye
Lord Touhig Lab (minister)aye
Lord Tunnicliffe Lab (minister)aye
Lord Watson of InvergowrieLab (minister)aye
Lord Watts Lab (minister)aye
Baroness Wheeler Lab (minister)aye
Baroness Whitaker Labaye
Lord Whitty Lab (minister)aye
Baroness Wilcox of NewportLab (minister)aye
Baroness Young of Old SconeLab (minister)aye
Lord Addington LDem (front bench)aye
Lord Alderdice LDem (front bench)aye
Lord Allan of HallamLDemaye
Baroness Bakewell of Hardington MandevilleLDem (front bench)aye
Baroness Barker LDem (front bench)aye
Lord Beith LDem (front bench)aye
Baroness Bowles of BerkhamstedLDem (front bench)aye
Baroness Brinton LDem (front bench)aye
Lord Bruce of BennachieLDem (front bench)aye
Baroness Burt of SolihullLDemaye
Lord Campbell of PittenweemLDem (front bench)aye
Lord Chidgey LDemaye
Lord Clement-Jones LDem (front bench)aye
Lord Dholakia LDem (front bench)aye
Baroness Featherstone LDemaye
Lord Foster of BathLDem (front bench)aye
Lord Fox LDem (front bench)aye
Baroness Garden of FrognalLDem (front bench)aye
Lord German LDem (front bench)aye
Baroness Grender LDem (front bench)aye
Baroness Hamwee LDem (front bench)aye
Baroness Harris of RichmondLDem (front bench)aye
Baroness Humphreys LDem (front bench)aye
Lord Hussain LDemaye
Baroness Hussein-Ece LDem (front bench)aye
Baroness Janke LDem (front bench)aye
Baroness Jolly LDem (front bench)aye
Baroness Kramer LDem (front bench)aye
Lord Newby LDem (front bench)aye
Lord Oates LDem (front bench)aye
Lord Paddick LDem (front bench)aye
Baroness Parminter LDem (front bench)aye
Baroness Pinnock LDem (front bench)aye
Lord Purvis of TweedLDem (front bench)aye
Baroness Randerson LDem (front bench)aye
Lord Redesdale LDemaye
Lord Rennard LDemaye
Lord Scriven LDem (front bench)aye
Baroness Sheehan LDem (front bench)aye
Lord Shipley LDem (front bench)aye
Baroness Smith of NewnhamLDem (front bench)aye
Lord Stoneham of DroxfordLDem (front bench)aye
Lord Storey LDem (front bench)aye
Lord Strasburger LDemaye
Lord Stunell LDemaye
Baroness Suttie LDem (front bench)aye
Lord Teverson LDem (front bench)aye
Lord Thomas of GresfordLDem (front bench)aye
Baroness Thomas of WinchesterLDem (front bench)aye
Baroness Thornhill LDem (front bench)aye
Lord Tope LDem (front bench)aye
Lord Tyler LDem (front bench)aye
Lord Wallace of SaltaireLDem (front bench)aye
Baroness Walmsley LDem (front bench)aye
Lord Willis of KnaresboroughLDemaye
Baroness Nicholson of WinterbourneLDemno
Lord Mann Non-affiliatedaye
Baroness Ritchie of DownpatrickNon-affiliated (front bench)aye
Lord Smith of FinsburyNon-affiliatedaye
Lord Taylor of WarwickNon-affiliatedno

About the Project

The Public Whip is a not-for-profit, open source website created in 2003 by Francis Irving and Julian Todd and now run by Bairwell Ltd.

PublicWhip v2 codebase is currently under development - you can join the Slack group to find out more or email [email protected]

The Whip on the Web

Help keep PublicWhip alive