Voting Comparison — Baroness Scotland of Asthal
to Lord Macfarlane of Bearsden
Baroness Scotland of Asthal
Note: our records only go back to 1997 for the Commons and 2001 for the Lords (more details).
| From | To | Party | Rebellions (explain...) | Attendance (explain...) | Teller |
| 30 Nov 1996 | still in office | Lab | 5 votes out of 1296, 0.4% | 1296 votes out of 2858, 45.3% | 0 times |
Voting Differences
| House | Date | Subject | Baroness Scotland of Asthal | Lord Macfarlane of Bearsden | Rôle |
| Lords | 26 Mar 2014 | Defence Reform Bill — Report (2nd Day) | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 25 Mar 2014 | Water Bill — Report (1st Day) | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 25 Mar 2014 | Water Bill — Report (1st Day) | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 24 Mar 2014 | Defence Reform Bill — Report (First Day) | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 26 Feb 2014 | Pensions Bill — Report (2nd Day) — 3.39 pm | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 24 Feb 2014 | Pensions Bill — Report (1st Day) | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 24 Feb 2014 | Pensions Bill — Report (1st Day) | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 31 Jan 2014 | European Union (Referendum) Bill — Motion That The House Do Now Resume | Majority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 31 Jan 2014 | European Union (Referendum) Bill — Require Report on UK Relationship With EU Post Withdrawl Prior to EU Membership Referendum | Majority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 29 Oct 2013 | Care Bill [HL] — Third Reading | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 14 Oct 2013 | Care Bill [HL] — Report (2nd Day) | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 9 Jul 2013 | Offender Rehabilitation Bill [HL] — Third Reading | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 6 Mar 2013 | Enterprise and Regulatory Reform Bill — Report (3rd Day) | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 4 Mar 2013 | Enterprise and Regulatory Reform Bill — Report (2nd Day) | Majority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 4 Mar 2013 | Enterprise and Regulatory Reform Bill — Report (2nd Day) | Majority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 28 Nov 2012 | Financial Services Bill — Report (5th Day) | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 28 Nov 2012 | Financial Services Bill — Report (5th Day) | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 27 Nov 2012 | Crime and Courts Bill [HL] — Report (1st Day) | Majority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 16 Jul 2012 | Groceries Code Adjudicator Bill [HL] Report — Report | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 16 Jul 2012 | Groceries Code Adjudicator Bill [HL] Report — Report | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 19 Mar 2012 | Health and Social Care Bill — Third Reading | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 19 Mar 2012 | Health and Social Care Bill — Third Reading | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 19 Mar 2012 | Health and Social Care Bill — Third Reading | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 6 Mar 2012 | Health and Social Care Bill — Report (5th Day) | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 6 Mar 2012 | Health and Social Care Bill — Report (5th Day) | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 5 Mar 2012 | Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill — Report (1st Day) | Majority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 5 Mar 2012 | Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill — Report (1st Day) | Majority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 8 Feb 2012 | Health and Social Care Bill — Report (1st Day) — mental health as a definition of health to to be improved | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 6 Feb 2012 | Protection of Freedoms Bill — Report (2nd Day) (Continued) | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 6 Feb 2012 | Protection of Freedoms Bill — Report (2nd Day) | Majority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 12 Oct 2011 | Health and Social Care Bill — select comittee to scrutinise Bill | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 12 Oct 2011 | Health and Social Care Bill — Reject at Second Reading | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 17 May 2011 | Postal Services Bill — Report (2nd Day) (Continued) | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 16 May 2011 | Fixed-term Parliaments Bill — Report (2nd Day) | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 16 Feb 2011 | Parliamentary Voting System and Constituencies Bill — Allowing Greater Variation from Mean Number of Electors in MP Constituency in Exceptional Circumstances | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 16 Feb 2011 | Parliamentary Voting System and Constituencies Bill — Threshold for Making Result of AV Referendum Binding | Majority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 14 Feb 2011 | Parliamentary Voting System and Constituencies Bill — Ban on Party Political Broadcasts Taking Sides in AV Referendum | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 14 Dec 2010 | University Tuition Fee Cap raise to £9,000 | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 14 Dec 2010 | University Tuition Fee Cap raise to £6,000 | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 14 Dec 2010 | Public Bodies Bill [HL] — Committee (4th Day) — Abolition of Chief Coroner | Majority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 1 Dec 2010 | Superannuation Bill — Report | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 29 Nov 2010 | Business of the House — Motion on Standing Orders | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 28 Jul 2010 | Local Government Bill [HL] — Report | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 28 Apr 2009 | Health Bill [HL] — Report (1st Day) | minority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 11 Jun 2008 | Lisbon Treaty — Change the date upon which the Treaty will come into force — rejected | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 9 Jun 2008 | Lisbon Treaty — Parliamentary approval required before the UK can take on more obligations from the European Union — rejected | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 4 Jun 2008 | Lisbon Treaty — Parliament must approve the government's policy towards the Common Agricultural Policy — rejected | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 7 May 2008 | Criminal Justice and Immigration Bill — ping pong — Protection of freedom of expression (sexual orientation) | minority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 7 May 2008 | Criminal Justice and Immigration Bill | minority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 29 Jan 2008 | Dormant Bank and Building Society Accounts Bill [HL] | minority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 29 Jan 2008 | Dormant Bank and Building Society Accounts Bill [HL] | minority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 29 Jan 2008 | Dormant Bank and Building Society Accounts Bill [HL] | minority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 29 Jan 2008 | Dormant Bank and Building Society Accounts Bill [HL] | minority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 27 Feb 2007 | Further Education and Training Bill [HL] | minority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 26 Feb 2007 | Mental Health Bill [HL] — services for minors. | minority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 10 Jan 2006 | Road Safety Bill [HL] — causing death by careless, or inconsiderate, driving | minority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 15 Mar 2005 | Constitutional Reform Bill [HL] | minority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 15 Mar 2005 | Constitutional Reform Bill [HL] | minority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 8 Mar 2005 | Prevention of Terrorism Bill | minority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 8 Mar 2005 | Prevention of Terrorism Bill | minority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 8 Mar 2005 | Prevention of Terrorism Bill | minority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 7 Mar 2005 | Prevention of Terrorism Bill | minority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 28 Feb 2005 | Inquiries Bill [HL] | minority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 28 Feb 2005 | Inquiries Bill [HL] | minority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 8 Feb 2005 | Disability Discrimination Bill [HL] | minority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 7 Feb 2005 | International Organisations Bill [HL] | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 13 Jul 2004 | Constitutional Reform Bill [HL] | minority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 17 Dec 2003 | Procedure of the House: Select Committee Report | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 2 Dec 2003 | Address in Reply to Her Majesty's Most Gracious Speech | minority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 30 Oct 2003 | Criminal Justice Bill | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 17 Jul 2003 | Local Government Bill | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 17 Jul 2003 | Local Government Bill | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 20 Mar 2003 | Regional Assemblies (Preparations) Bill | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 18 Jun 2002 | Employment Bill | Majority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 12 Jun 2002 | Tax Credits Bill | minority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 15 Jan 2002 | Homelessness Bill | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 25 Oct 2001 | International Development Bill [HL] | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 26 Mar 2001 | Hunting Bill | minority | no | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 26 Mar 2001 | Hunting Bill | minority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 1 Mar 2001 | Special Educational Needs and Disability Bill [H.L.] | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 1 Mar 2001 | Special Educational Needs and Disability Bill [H.L.] | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 19 Feb 2001 | Regulatory Reform Bill [H.L.] | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 19 Feb 2001 | Regulatory Reform Bill [H.L.] | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 19 Feb 2001 | Regulatory Reform Bill [H.L.] | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 27 Nov 2000 | Political Parties, Elections and Referendums Bill | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 27 Nov 2000 | Political Parties, Elections and Referendums Bill | minority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 27 Nov 2000 | Political Parties, Elections and Referendums Bill | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 15 Nov 2000 | Police (Northern Ireland) Bill | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 15 Nov 2000 | Police (Northern Ireland) Bill | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 15 Nov 2000 | Police (Northern Ireland) Bill | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 24 Jul 2000 | Local Government Bill, removing bullying clause | minority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 24 Jul 2000 | Motion Moved on Consideration of Commons Amendment No. 10 | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 18 Jul 2000 | As an Amendment to Commons Amendment No. 180 | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 18 Jul 2000 | As an Amendment to Commons Amendment No. 136 | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 12 Jul 2000 | Regulation of Investigatory Powers Bill | minority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 12 Jul 2000 | Regulation of Investigatory Powers Bill | minority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 12 Jul 2000 | Government Resources and Accounts Bill | minority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 12 Jul 2000 | Government Resources and Accounts Bill | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 11 Jul 2000 | Postal Services Bill | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 11 Jul 2000 | Utilities Bill | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 15 Jun 2000 | Postal Services Bill | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 18 Apr 2000 | Financial Services and Markets Bill | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 20 Jan 2000 | Criminal Justice (Mode of Trial) Bill [H.L.] | minority | aye | disagrees with policy |
| Lords | 24 Nov 1999 | Address in Reply to Her Majesty's Most Gracious Speech | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy |