Voting Comparison — Lord Mackie of Benshie
to Baroness Howarth of Breckland

Lord Mackie of Benshie

Note: our records only go back to 1997 for the Commons and 2001 for the Lords (more details).

FromToPartyRebellions (explain...)Attendance (explain...)Teller

Voting Differences

HouseDateSubjectLord Mackie of BenshieBaroness Howarth of BrecklandRôle
Lords5 Mar 2009Control Orders — Annual renewal 2009 — Declines to approve — rejected minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords19 Nov 2008Dormant Bank and Building Society Accounts Bill [HL] minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords4 Nov 2008Counter-Terrorism Bill — Post-charge questioning: England and Wales minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords15 Jul 2008Criminal Evidence (Witness Anonymity) Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords7 Jul 2008Housing and Regeneration Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords2 Jul 2008Pensions Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords2 Jul 2008National Insurance Contributions Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords17 Jun 2008Pensions Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords23 Apr 2008Criminal Justice and Immigration Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords19 Mar 2008Regulatory Enforcement and Sanctions Bill [HL] minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords11 Mar 2008Climate Change Bill — Adaptation Sub-Committee Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords5 Mar 2008Criminal Justice and Immigration Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords4 Mar 2008Climate Change Bill — Statement of emissions, delete aviation minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords24 Oct 2007Serious Crime Bill [HL] minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords17 Oct 2007Legal Services Bill [HL] Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords17 Oct 2007Legal Services Bill [HL] Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords9 Oct 2007Greater London Authority Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords8 Oct 2007Local Government and Public Involvement in Health Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords25 Jul 2007Further Education and Training Bill [HL] Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords3 Jul 2007Offender Management Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords27 Jun 2007Offender Management Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords27 Jun 2007Offender Management Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords19 Jun 2007Greater London Authority Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords19 Jun 2007Greater London Authority Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords15 May 2007Legal Services Bill [HL] Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords2 May 2007Statistics and Registration Service Bill — Committee Stage — pre-release of official statistics Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords25 Apr 2007Serious Crime Bill [HL] minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords18 Apr 2007Legal Services Bill [HL] Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords18 Apr 2007Legal Services Bill [HL] Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords20 Mar 2007Fraud (Trials without a Jury) Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords27 Feb 2007Further Education and Training Bill [HL] Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords7 Nov 2006Police and Justice Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords6 Nov 2006Armed Forces Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords6 Nov 2006Armed Forces Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords6 Nov 2006Armed Forces Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords6 Nov 2006Armed Forces Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords30 Oct 2006Education and Inspections Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords11 Jul 2006Police and Justice Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords28 Jun 2006Civil Aviation Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords27 Jun 2006Government of Wales Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords19 Jun 2006Health Bill Majoritytellno agrees with policy
Lords7 Jun 2006Electoral Administration Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords6 Jun 2006Government of Wales Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords23 May 2006Company Law Reform Bill [HL] Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords15 May 2006Use of personal identifier information minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords9 May 2006Company Law Reform Bill [HL] Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords26 Apr 2006Violent Crime Reduction Bill — revenue from alcohol disorder zones minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords19 Apr 2006Government of Wales Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords21 Mar 2006Consumer Credit Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords15 Mar 2006Identity Cards Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords7 Mar 2006Compensation Bill [HL] minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords6 Mar 2006London Olympic Games and Paralympic Games Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords28 Feb 2006Motion A minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords28 Feb 2006Motion A Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords25 Jan 2006Terrorism Bill — Consent to prosecution for terrorism in other countries minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords23 Jan 2006Identity Cards Bill (amendment 46: compulsion to register) Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords23 Jan 2006Identity Cards Bill (amendment 38: compulsion via designated documents) Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords17 Jan 2006Terrorism Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords30 Nov 2005Commons Bill [HL] minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords29 Nov 2005Road Safety Bill [HL] — Compulsory surrender of old-form licences Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords17 Oct 2005Criminal Defence Service Bill [HL] Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords6 Apr 2005Railways Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords8 Mar 2005Prevention of Terrorism Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords8 Mar 2005Prevention of Terrorism Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords8 Mar 2005Prevention of Terrorism Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords28 Feb 2005Inquiries Bill [HL] Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords21 Dec 2004Administration and Works Committee minoritytellaye disagrees with policy
Lords17 Nov 2004Pensions Bill — Lords Amendment Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords9 Nov 2004Civil Contingencies Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords4 Nov 2004Pensions Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords28 Jun 2004Asylum and Immigration (Treatment of Claimants, etc.) Bill — Failed asylum seekers should not have to take part in community service to be provided with accommodation — rejected minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords22 Jun 2004Higher Education Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords8 Jun 2004Higher Education Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords8 Jun 2004Higher Education Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords22 Mar 2004Energy Bill [HL] minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords16 Mar 2004Planning and Compulsory Purchase Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords16 Mar 2004"Piloting conduct at European and local elections Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords9 Mar 2004Domestic Violence, Crime and Victims Bill [HL] Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords23 Feb 2004European Parliamentary and Local Elections (Pilots) Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords23 Feb 2004European Parliamentary and Local Elections (Pilots) Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords4 Nov 2003Criminal Justice Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords4 Nov 2003Criminal Justice Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords3 Nov 2003Anti-social Behaviour Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords21 Oct 2003Hunting Bill: amendment — "intentional" hunting Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords20 Oct 2003Health and Social Care (Community Health and Standards) Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords14 Oct 2003Criminal Justice Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords17 Sep 2003Lords Amendment Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords8 Jul 2003Communications Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords30 Jun 2003Food Supplements (England) Regulations 2003 Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords30 Jun 2003Criminal Justice Bill Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords24 Jun 2003Water Bill [HL] Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords19 May 2003Courts Bill [HL] minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords19 May 2003Courts Bill [HL] minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords13 May 2003Sexual Offences Bill [HL] Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords3 Apr 2003Commons Amendment Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords18 Feb 2003Community Care (Delayed Discharges etc.) Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords6 Nov 2002Lords Amendment Majorityaye disagrees with policy
Lords4 Nov 2002Animal Health Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords31 Oct 2002Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords30 Oct 2002Adoption and Children Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords23 Oct 2002Adoption and Children Bill minorityno disagrees with policy
Lords11 Jul 2002Proceeds of Crime Bill Majorityno disagrees with policy
Lords25 Apr 2002Police Reform Bill [HL] Majorityno disagrees with policy

About the Project

The Public Whip is a not-for-profit, open source website created in 2003 by Francis Irving and Julian Todd and now run by Bairwell Ltd.

PublicWhip v2 codebase is currently under development - you can join the Slack group to find out more or email [email protected]

The Whip on the Web

Help keep PublicWhip alive