Voting Comparison — Dorothy-Grace Elder MSP, Glasgow
to Ian Welsh MSP, Ayr
Dorothy-Grace Elder
Note: our records only go back to 1997 for the Commons and 2001 for the Lords (more details).
| From | To | Party | Rebellions (explain...) | Attendance (explain...) | Teller |
| 1 May 2002 | 31 Mar 2003 | Independent | no whip | 95 votes out of 387, 24.5% | n/a |
| 6 May 1999 | 30 Apr 2002 | Independent | no whip | 714 votes out of 900, 79.3% | n/a |
Voting Differences
| House | Date | Subject | Dorothy-Grace Elder | Ian Welsh | Rôle | |
| no votes listed | ||||||
| House | Date | Subject | Dorothy-Grace Elder | Ian Welsh | Rôle | |
| Scotland | 16 Dec 1999 | [S1M-383] Decision Time | abstention | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 16 Dec 1999 | [S1M-383.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 15 Dec 1999 | [S1M-378] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 15 Dec 1999 | [S1M-378.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 9 Dec 1999 | [S1M-354.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 8 Dec 1999 | [S1M-358.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 1 Dec 1999 | Public Finance and Accountability (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 — After section 1 — Financial procedures: written agreements | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 18 Nov 1999 | [S1M-295.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 18 Nov 1999 | [S1M-296.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 10 Nov 1999 | [S1M-258] Decision Time | minority | abstention | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 10 Nov 1999 | [S1M-258.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 4 Nov 1999 | [S1M-242.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 3 Nov 1999 | [S1M-240.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 28 Oct 1999 | [S1M-230] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 28 Oct 1999 | [S1M-230.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 7 Oct 1999 | [S1M-185] Decision Time | abstention | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 7 Oct 1999 | [S1M-185.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | abstention | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 7 Oct 1999 | [S1M-185.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 7 Oct 1999 | [S1M-186.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 7 Oct 1999 | [S1M-186.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 29 Sep 1999 | [S1M-171.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 9 Sep 1999 | [S1M-127] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 9 Sep 1999 | [S1M-127.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 8 Sep 1999 | Mental Health (Public Safety and Appeals) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2 — Section 3 — Meaning of "Mental Disorder" in the 1984 Act | abstention | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 8 Sep 1999 | Mental Health (Public Safety and Appeals) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2 — Section 3 — Meaning of "Mental Disorder" in the 1984 Act | abstention | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 8 Sep 1999 | Mental Health (Public Safety and Appeals) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2 — Section 3 — Meaning of "Mental Disorder" in the 1984 Act | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 8 Sep 1999 | Mental Health (Public Safety and Appeals) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2 — Section 1 — Continued Detention of Mentally Disordered Patients on Grounds of Public Safety | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 8 Sep 1999 | Mental Health (Public Safety and Appeals) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2 — Section 1 — Continued Detention of Mentally Disordered Patients on Grounds of Public Safety | abstention | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 2 Sep 1999 | [S1M-107] Decision Time | abstention | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 2 Jul 1999 | [S1M-82] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 24 Jun 1999 | [S1M-68.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | abstention | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 24 Jun 1999 | [S1M-68.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 24 Jun 1999 | [S1M-67] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 24 Jun 1999 | [S1M-67.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 17 Jun 1999 | [S1M-2] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 17 Jun 1999 | [S1M-52] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 17 Jun 1999 | [S1M-52] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 17 Jun 1999 | [S1M-52.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 8 Jun 1999 | [S1M-40.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 8 Jun 1999 | [S1M-40.1 (Amendment)] Decision Time | Majority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 3 Jun 1999 | [S1M-19.2 (Amendment)] Decision Time | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 3 Jun 1999 | [S1M-29] Decision Time | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 2 Jun 1999 | [S1M-17] Business Motion | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 19 May 1999 | [S1M-5.1 (Amendment)] Junior Ministers | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 19 May 1999 | [S1M-5.1 (Amendment)] Junior Ministers | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 19 May 1999 | [S1M-4.3 (Amendment)] Ministers | minority | aye | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 19 May 1999 | [S1M-4.3 (Amendment)] Ministers | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 19 May 1999 | [S1M-4.1 (Amendment)] Ministers | minority | no | disagrees with policy | |
| Scotland | 18 May 1999 | Prayers | Majority | no | disagrees with policy | |