Finance Bill 2012 — Schedule 1 — Income Threshold for Recovery of Child Benefit — 19 Apr 2012 at 18:00
The majority of MPs voted against a proposal from Christopher Chope MP (Conservative, Christchurch) to recover child benefit from those couples with a total income of over £100,000, rather than from couples in which either individual has an income of over £50,000[1].
A tax on those with an income over £50,000 designed to recover child benefit paid to such individuals was present in the bill under discussion[2]. The tax would only apply to the higher earning individual in a couple.
During the debate Mr Chope suggested the original proposal was unfair saying[3]:
- two people on £50,000 a year with children will not have to pay the high income child benefit charge, whereas a family with children with one person earning over £60,000 will have to pay it.
The text of Mr Chope's rejected amendment was:
- in schedule 1, at end insert—
- (5) A person (P) is not liable to a high income child benefit charge if the total adjusted net income for the year of that person and any partner does not exceed £100,000’.
Minister David Gauke, The Exchequer Secretary, explained the Government's position, which was reflected in the bill as introduced, was based on ease of administration, saying[4]:
- The focus on doing this through the tax system and on having one taxpayer above a certain threshold enables us to avoid the position whereby we would have to put every child benefit claimant through the tax credit system and apply a means-tested system to 8 million different cases, creating a substantially greater administrative struggle for both Government and many individuals. That is why we have taken that particular point.
A vote for Mr Chope's amendment is a vote in favour of greater recognition of couples in the tax and benefits system.
- [1] Christopher Chope MP (Conservative, Christchurch) House of Commons, 19 April 2012
- [2] Schedule 1 of the Finance Bill 2012 as introduced on 28 March 2012
- [3] Christopher Chope MP (Conservative, Christchurch) House of Commons, 19 April 2012
- [4] David Gauke MP, (South West Hertfordshire, Conservative) House of Commons 19 April 2012
All Votes Cast - sorted by party
MPs for which their vote in this division differed from the majority vote of their party are marked in red. Also shows which MPs were ministers at the time of this vote. You can also see every eligible MP including those who did not vote in this division.
Sort by: Name | Constituency | Party | Vote